lecture 6

Sex Differences and Sexual Orientation

Overview of Sexual Orientation / Preference

  • Sexual orientation refers to whether an individual is attracted to males, females, or both, as well as the degree of that attraction across various contexts.
  • Examples of same-sex sexual orientation have been observed in many species, including:
    • Songbirds: Pair bonding in zebra finches illustrates same-sex attraction.
    • Rodents: Various species exhibit homosexual behaviors.
    • Sheep:
    • Male-oriented rams show same-sex attraction, with approximately 10% classified as homosexual (male-oriented).
    • Female-oriented (heterosexual) sheep exhibit attractions towards ewes.
    • About 6% of male sheep display no libido (sexual attraction).
    • No instances of homosexual behavior in female sheep (ewes) have been documented.

Behavioral Differences in Rams

  • Comparison of Female-oriented and Male-oriented Rams:
    • Estrous Stimulus Response - Measured via precopulatory behaviors and mating attempts:
    • Female-oriented rams:
      • Precoculatory Behavior: 33.4
      • Mount Attempts: 9.2
      • Ejaculations: 2.8
    • Male-oriented rams:
      • Precoculatory Behavior: 9.4
      • Mount Attempts: 0.5
      • Ejaculations: 0
    • Notes on Mount Attempts:
    • Refers to attempts where both front feet left the ground but no firm positioning was achieved on the ewe's rump.

Neuroendocrine Differences in Rams

  • Circulating testosterone (T) levels and the “ewe effect” were observed.
  • Aromatase Enzyme:
    • Found in the preoptic area (POA) of the brain, playing a crucial role in transforming androgens to estrogens, influencing sexual behavior.
  • Estrogen Receptors in the Amygdala:
    • Involvement in sexual differentiation and behavior.
  • Ovine Sexually Dimorphic Nucleus (SDN):
    • Treatment of pregnant ewes with T results in larger open SDN in female offspring, indicating hormonal influence during development.

Potential Endocrine Influences in Humans

  • Research indicates no consistent differences in adult hormone levels between homosexuals and heterosexuals.
  • Lack of data on early developmental endocrine differences limits current understanding.
  • There is some evidence of hormonal influence, particularly in congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH) females, who exhibit differing sexual orientation tendencies.

Human Brain Anatomy and Sexual Orientation

  • Hormonal and structural differences in sexually differentiated brain regions of humans suggest a biological relationship with sexual orientation:
    • Larger Anterior Commissure: Observed in homosexual men compared to heterosexual men.
    • Larger Suprachiasmatic Nucleus (SCN): This structure is involved in circadian rhythms and reproductive behavior.
    • Smaller Interstitial Nucleus of the Anterior Hypothalamus 3 (INAH 3):
    • Located in the human POA, differences suggest sexual orientation has a structural basis.
  • Some reported differences do not have a clear correlation with sexuality, indicating further research is necessary.

Interstitial Nuclei of the Anterior Hypothalamus

  • Measurement Techniques:
    • Nissl stain utilized for histological examination.
    • An essential aspect of the methodology includes being 'blind' to the subject group during measurement to avoid bias.

Study by Simon LeVay (1991)

  • Research Purpose: Examination of brain structure differences between heterosexual and homosexual men:
    • Found the volume of INAH 3 was more than twice as large in heterosexual men compared to both women and homosexual men, suggesting it may be a substrate for sexual orientation.
  • Research Methodology:
    • Subject groups consisted of:
    • Homosexual men (n=19, including 1 bisexual man who died of AIDS).
    • Presumed heterosexual men (n=16; death causes varied).
    • Presumed heterosexual women (n=6).
    • Age means were approximately 40 years for all groups.
  • Postmortem Analysis:
    • Tissue was fixed and sectioned without knowledge of subject groups, employing Nissl staining for analysis of brain regions (INAH 1, 2, 3, and 4).
    • The volumes of these hypothalamic nuclei were calculated using one-way ANOVAs for analysis.

Results of the Study

  • Comparisons made between:
    • Homosexual men and heterosexual men who died of AIDS (n=6).
    • Heterosexual men who died of AIDS versus those dying from other causes (n=10).
  • Normalizing for brain weight did not affect research conclusions, indicating a likely correlation between INAH 3 size and sexual orientation.

Conclusion and Implications of LeVay’s Findings

  • LeVay clarified:
    • Motivation behind study linked to his personal experiences of homosexuality and events such as his partner's death from AIDS.
    • He did not claim to prove that homosexuality is genetic or that a specific 'gay center' exists in the brain; rather, INAH 3 may be one part of a network of nuclei relevant to sexual behavior in both genders.
    • Notably produced only one significant paper on these findings.

Additional Study on INAH 3

  • Observational data:
    • Presented values of brain volume (in mm³) between heterosexuals and homosexuals, revealing observed trends in volume differences linked with HIV status, demonstrating a nuanced relationship between sexuality, health, and neuroanatomy.