Test #3 (cognitive dissonance and conformity)
LO 6.1 Explain what cognitive dissonance is and how people avoid dissonance to maintain a positive self-image.
The Theory of Cognitive Dissonance: Protecting Our Self-Esteem An important function of the self is to maintain self-esteem, namely people’s evaluations of their own self-worth and the extent to which they view themselves as good, competent, and decent. Cognitive dissonance arises when people act in a way that threatens their self-esteem, which people are motivated to reduce either by changing their behavior, justifying their behavior by changing a dissonant cognition, or justifying their behavior by adding new cognitions.
Decisions, Decisions, Decisions Decisions arouse dissonance because they require choosing one thing and not the other. The thought that we may have made the wrong choice causes discomfort—postdecision dissonance—because it threatens our self-image as one who makes good decisions. After the choice is final, the mind diminishes the discomfort through solidifying the case for the item chosen or the course of action taken. The more permanent and irrevocable the decision, the stronger the need to reduce dissonance.
The Justification of Effort People tend to increase their liking for something they have chosen to work hard to attain, even if the thing they have attained is not something they would otherwise like. This explains the intense loyalty that initiated recruits feel for their fraternities and military institutions after undergoing hazing.
Counterattitudinal Behavior refers to times when people act in a way that runs counter to their private belief or attitude. If there is ample external justification for the behavior (e.g., a large reward), then there is no dissonance and no change in people’s attitudes or beliefs. However, if the reward is not big enough to justify the action, people resort to internal justification, which is the reduction of dissonance by changing something about oneself (e.g., one’s attitude or behavior). Internal justification has a much more powerful effect on an individual’s long-term values and behaviors than does a situation where the external justifications are evident. Counterattitudinal behavior has been used to change people’s attitudes in many ways, from their prejudices to self-defeating beliefs and harmful practices such as bulimia. Another example involves getting someone to like you by having them do you a favor. This works because the person needs to internally justify the fact that they did something nice for you. The converse is true as well. If you harm another person, to reduce the threat to your self-image that could come from doing a bad deed, you will tend to justify what you did by denigrating your victim: the person deserved it, or he or she is not “one of us” anyway. In extreme cases such as conflict and war, many people will embrace the cognition that the victim or enemy deserved everything they got because they are less than human.
Avoiding Temptations Another way of getting people to change is by giving them mild threats not to perform an attractive activity. That is, rather than using threatening severe punishment, it is better to use insufficient punishment, which is the dissonance aroused when individuals lack sufficient external justification for having resisted a desired activity or object, as the forbidden-toy experiment demonstrated. The less severe the threat or the smaller the reward, the less external justification the person has for compliance. The resulting internal justification lasts longer than temporary obedience to avoid a punishment.
The Hypocrisy Paradigm Hypocrisy induction is a method of making people face the difference between what they say and what they do. It takes advantage of the need to reduce dissonance to foster socially beneficial behaviors. In the case of an AIDS-prevention experiment, participants videotaped speeches about the importance of using condoms and they were made aware of their own failure to use them. To reduce dissonance, they changed their behavior—they purchased condoms.
Dissonance Across Cultures Although cognitive dissonance occurs in non-Western cultures as well as Western ones, the content of what creates dissonant cognitions and the process and intensity of dissonance reduction do vary across cultures, reflecting the difference in cultural norms.
156
LO 6.2 Describe recent advances and extensions of cognitive dissonance theory.
Advances and Extensions of Cognitive Dissonance Theory Social psychologists have continued to explore this basic need to protect our self-esteem in greater depth and in new contexts.
Self-Affirmation Theory holds that people can also reduce dissonance by focusing on and affirming their competence on some dimension unrelated to the threat. One way to do so is by completing a values affirmation writing exercise, whereby people write about why a value is important to them. This exercise has been shown to have a wide range of lasting positive effects on people’s lives.
Dissonance in Close Relationships: Self-Evaluation Maintenance Theory holds that we will experience dissonance in relationships when three conditions are met: We feel close to another person, he or she is outperforming us in a particular area, and that area is central to our self-esteem. This dissonance can be reduced by changing any one of these factors: becoming less close, doing better in that area, or lowering how central the area is to our self-esteem.
LO 6.3 Summarize ways to overcome dissonance and the pros and cons of having high self-esteem.
Some Concluding Thoughts on Dissonance and Self-Esteem Much of the time, dissonance-reducing behavior can be useful because it allows us to maintain self-esteem. Yet if we were to spend all our time and energy defending our egos, we would never learn from our mistakes, bad decisions, and incorrect beliefs.
Overcoming Dissonance Dissonance reduction is counterproductive when it solidifies negative values and behaviors, and this applies to everyone from members of small cults to national leaders. Knowing that humans are dissonance-reducing animals can make us more aware of the process. The next time we feel the discomfort of having acted counter to our values, we can consciously pause the self-justification process to reflect on our action.
Narcissism and the Dangers of Too Much Self-Esteem Most of us have high self-esteem, which has the benefits of avoiding depression, allowing us to persevere in the face of failure, and, as shown by research on terror management theory, protecting us from thoughts about our own mortality. There is a form of high self-esteem, however, that is quite problematic—namely, narcissism—which is extreme high self-regard combined with a lack of empathy toward others. The best combination is to feel good about ourselves but also to look out for and care about others.
LO 8.1 Define conformity and explain why it occurs.
Conformity: When and Why Conformity occurs when people change their behavior due to the real (or imagined) influence of others. There are two main reasons people conform: informational and normative social influences.
LO 8.2 Explain how informational social influence motivates people to conform.
Informational Social Influence: The Need to Know What’s “Right” Informational social influence occurs when people do not know the correct (or best) action to take. They look to the behavior of others as an important source of information, using it to choose appropriate courses of action for themselves. Informational social influence usually results in private acceptance, in which people genuinely believe in what other people are doing or saying.
The Importance of Being Accurate In situations where it is important to be accurate, the tendency to conform to other people through informational social influence increases.
When Informational Conformity Backfires Using other people as a source of information can backfire when they are wrong about what’s going on.
When Will People Conform to Informational Social Influence? People are more likely to conform to informational social influence when the situation is ambiguous, when they are in a crisis, or if experts are present.
LO 8.3 Explain how normative social influence motivates people to conform.
Normative Social Influence: The Need to Be Accepted Normative social influence occurs when we change our behavior to match that of others because we want to remain a member of the group in good standing and continue to gain the advantages of group membership. We conform to the group’s social norms, implicit or explicit rules for acceptable behaviors, values, and attitudes. Normative social influence usually results in public compliance but not private acceptance of other people’s ideas and behaviors.
Conformity and Social Approval: The Asch Line-Judgment Studies In a series of classic studies, Solomon Asch found that people would conform, at least some of the time, to the obviously wrong answer of the group.
The Importance of Being Accurate, Revisited When it is important to be accurate, people are more likely to resist normative social influence and go against the group, giving the right answer. But public conformity still occurs.
The Consequences of Resisting Normative Social Influence Resisting normative social influence can lead to ridicule, ostracism, and rejection by the group.
When Will People Conform to Normative Social Influence? Social impact theory specifies when normative social influence is most likely to occur by referring to the strength, immediacy, and size of the group. We are more likely to conform when the group is one we care about, when the group members are unanimous in their thoughts or behaviors, when the group has three or more members, and when we are members of collectivist cultures. Past conformity gives people idiosyncrasy credits, allowing them to deviate from the group without serious consequences.
Minority Influence: When the Few Influence the Many Under certain conditions, an individual (or small number of people) can influence the group majority. The key is consistency in the presentation of the minority viewpoint.
LO 8.4 Describe how people can use their knowledge of social influence to influence others.
Conformity Tactics Knowing about the tendency to conform can inform our strategic efforts to change the behavior of others.
The Role of Injunctive and Descriptive Norms Communicating injunctive norms, expectations regarding the behaviors that society approves of, is often a more powerful way to create change than communicating descriptive norms, expectations regarding how people actually behave.
Using Norms to Change Behavior: Beware the “Boomerang Effect” One must be careful that descriptive norms do not create a boomerang effect, making an undesirable behavior more likely than it previously was.
Other Tactics of Social Influence Other efforts to change people’s behavior via direct request include the foot-in-the-door technique, in which the requestor first secures agreement with a small favor before following up with a larger request, and the door-in-the-face technique, in which the requestor first asks for a large favor that will certainly be
LO 8.5 Summarize studies that have demonstrated people’s willingness to obey authority figures.
Obedience to Authority In the most famous series of studies in social psychology, Stanley Milgram examined obedience, when people change their behavior in response to an authority figure.
The Milgram Study Milgram found chilling levels of obedience in his research, to the point where a majority of participants administered what they thought were potentially lethal shocks to a fellow human being.
The Role of Normative Social Influence Normative pressures make it difficult for people to stop obeying authority figures. They want to please the authority figure by doing a good job.
The Role of Informational Social Influence The obedience studies created a confusing situation for participants, with competing, ambiguous demands. Unclear about how to define what was going on, they followed the orders of the expert.
Other Reasons Why We Obey Participants conformed to the wrong norm: They continued to follow the norms of “obey authority” and “all in the name of science” even when it was no longer appropriate to do so. It was difficult for them to abandon these initial norms because of the fast-paced nature of the study, the fact that the shock levels increased in small increments, and their loss of a feeling of personal responsibility.
The Obedience Studies, Then and Now Milgram’s research design was criticized on ethical grounds, involving deception, informed consent, psychological distress, that found in the classic study in the 1960s.