Week 9, Strict Liability and Product Liability (1)

Page 1: Strict Liability

  • Definition: Strict liability is the third type of torts, characterized by liability without fault.

  • Application:

    • Arises when an inherently dangerous action is performed.

    • Liability exists regardless of intent or negligence.

  • Conditions for Liability:

    1. The activity poses a risk of serious harm to people or property.

    2. It is inherently dangerous and cannot be safely undertaken.

    3. It is not commonly performed in the community.

Page 2: Examples of Strict Liability

  • Animals:

    • Owners of certain animals (e.g., cows, horses, bulls) may be liable for injuries caused by those animals.

    • Liability applies to abnormally dangerous animals such as snakes and tigers.

  • Abnormally Dangerous Acts:

    • Activities with substantial risks to people or property, such as operating a nuclear power plant or using explosives.

Page 3: Product Liability Law

  • Basis: Product liability law stems from tort law.

  • Theories of Recovery:

    1. Negligence

    2. Strict Product Liability

    3. Breach of Warranty

  • Common Elements:

    1. The product is defective.

    2. The defect existed when the product left the defendant’s control.

  • Types of Defects:

    • Manufacturing defects

    • Design defects

    • Inadequate warnings

Page 4: Negligence Theory in Product Liability

  • Plaintiff's Requirements:

    1. Defendant owed a duty of care to the plaintiff.

    2. Defendant breached that duty by providing a defective product.

    3. The breach caused injury to the plaintiff.

    4. The plaintiff suffered actual injury.

  • Who Can Sue?: Any foreseeable plaintiff, including users and consumers, can sue.

Page 5: Strict Product Liability

  • Liability: Manufacturers, distributors, or retailers may be held liable to any reasonably foreseeable injured party.

  • Foreseeable Injured Parties:

    • Includes the buyer, the buyer’s family, and guests.

  • Focus: Liability focuses on the product, not the actions of the manufacturer/seller.

  • Plaintiff's Burden:

    1. Product was defective when sold.

    2. Defect rendered the product unreasonably dangerous.

    3. The defect caused the plaintiff’s injury.

Page 6: Expert Testimony in Product Liability

  • Purpose: Plaintiffs often use expert witnesses to establish that a defect exists.

  • Areas of Litigation:

    • Pharmaceuticals, medical devices, cars, environmental cases, etc.

Page 7: Breach of Warranty

  • Definition: A warranty is a promise regarding a product’s performance.

  • Nature: Breach of warranty arises from contract law rather than tort law.

Page 8: Express Warranty

  • Definition: An express warranty occurs when a seller makes specific representations about a product.

  • Plaintiff's Requirements:

    1. The representation formed the basis of the bargain.

    2. Breach of the representation occurred.

Page 9: Implied Warranty of Merchantability

  • Definition: Ensures a product is fit for its ordinary use and meets consumer expectations.

  • Examples:

    • Electronics: A malfunctioning smartphone.

    • Appliances: Refrigerator failing to keep food cold.

    • Automobiles: A defective car that cannot be driven.

    • Clothing: A winter coat that does not provide warmth.

    • Furniture: A bed frame collapsing under normal weight.

  • Note: Only applicable to products sold by regular merchants. Merchants can disclaim this warranty in certain jurisdictions if clearly communicated.

Page 10: Implied Warranty of Fitness for a Particular Purpose

  • Requirements:

    1. Seller had knowledge of the buyer’s specific purpose.

    2. Buyer relied on the seller’s skill and judgment.

  • Examples:

    • Hiking Boots: Recommended boots that fail after brief use.

    • Paint: Waterproof paint that leads to seepage.

Page 11: Additional Examples of Implied Warranty of Fitness for a Particular Purpose

  • Sports Equipment: A bike recommended for mountain biking that fails under use.

  • Medical Equipment: A device that fails to perform as intended.

  • Office Chairs: A chair causing discomfort after short use.

  • Summary: Implied warranty may be applicable when buyers rely on sellers' expertise, given that the buyer clearly expresses their particular needs.