Natural Law Lecture Notes

HIST 22000 - Week 2: Natural Law

Philosophical Questions Regarding Natural Law

  • What are the sources of our ideas of right and wrong?

    • Potential Sources: Society, Religion, Human Nature.

  • Is there a distinction between legality and morality?

    • Definition of Legal vs Moral:

    • Legal refers to laws enacted by government; moral pertains to ethical principles.

  • Do laws create morality, or does morality give rise to laws?

Legal Scenarios and Moral Considerations

  • Scenario: A law requiring reporting of minor traffic violations.

    • Questions of Obedience: Should individuals follow this law?

    • Validity of Law: Is it a valid law if perceived as unjust?

    • Role of Morality in Legal Compliance.

Overview of Natural Law Theory

  • Fundamental Principle: True law is based on universal moral principles.

    • Laws are valid only if they align with justice and moral order inherent in human nature.

  • Key Assertion: An unjust law is not a real law.

    • The validity of laws is contingent upon their alignment with moral principles.

Classical Natural Law Theory

  • Focus on the intersection of morals and law:

    • Concept: "What naturally is, ought to be."

  • Classification of Laws:

    • A law lacking a moral foundation is unjust and characterized as bad law.

Notable Philosophers in Classical Natural Law
  • Plato:

    • Justice as the essence of a good society.

    • Only just laws are right and just is universal.

  • Aristotle:

    • Humans as social beings needing family/community/polis.

    • Natural laws rooted in justice, establishing criteria for good or legitimate laws.

  • Thomas Aquinas:m

    • Laws binding due to human rationality, with intuitive knowledge of good.

    • Natural law is superior to human law, the latter is valid only if it aligns with natural law.

Components of Classical Natural Law Theory
  • (i) Universal Ethical Standards.

  • (ii) Founded in a Higher Law.

  • (iii) Reliance on Reason and Rationality.z

Debates Around Classical Natural Law Theory

  • Team A (Pro-Natural Law): Supports the three pillars as still relevant today.

  • Team B (Critical View): Argues the oversimplification of morals in diverse societies.

    • Discussions on Each Pillar:

    • Universal: Are moral values universally applicable?

    • Higher Law: Morality of disobeying unjust laws.

    • Reason/Rationality: Can moral truths be discovered through reason alone or are they influenced by context?

Contemporary Natural Law Theory

  • Natural law's influence on political philosophy and revolutionary thought.

  • Key Theorists:

    • Hobbes:

    • Natural law linked to self-preservation; man-made laws for security and order.

    • Essential laws of nature:

      1. Seek peace and follow it.

      2. Right of self-defense.

    • Locke:

    • Blissful state before social contract; necessity of surrendering some freedom for protection of property.

    • Rousseau:

    • Focus on the social contract and the general will, prioritizing community over individual selfishness.

  • Core Concepts:

    • Social Contract.

    • Surrender of Rights.

    • Inalienable Natural Rights.

The Evolution and Decline of Natural Law

  • Decline as a dominant theory in legal and political understanding.

  • Emergence of Legal Positivism: Characterized by non-cognitivism questioning the knowledge of right and wrong.

  • Resurgence in the 20th Century:

    • Post-war emphasis on human rights including UDHR and the fight against crimes against humanity.

  • New Natural Law theorists: E.g., Finnis, contributing to the evolution of discourse on morality and law.

Interplay of Morality and Law

  • Discussion on separation:

    • Is it possible to separate legal validity from morality?

    • Conditions for a law to be considered valid and moral.

  • Overlap of Criteria: Exploring how moral criteria may intersect with legal criteria.

Examples of Historically Immoral Laws

  • Illustrative Cases:

    • Segregation, Marital Rape.

  • Questions raised:

    • What makes these laws wrong?

    • Moral obligations of citizens—do they exist to disobey unjust laws?

Contemporary Examples of Immoral Laws

  • Issues to Consider:

    • Assisted dying, Mandatory vaccinations, Immigration restrictions, Access to clean drinking water.

Natural Law's Presence in Legal Systems

  • Inherently Present Elements: Even if not explicitly cited, natural law principles exist in the legal frameworks.

  • Key observations regarding sovereign authority:

    • Certain actions are considered inherently wrong beyond mere legal endorsement.

    • Death Penalty and Torture: Limitations imposed by natural law principles on sovereign authority.

Democratic Elements and Natural Law
  • Importance of checks-and-balances in law-making to align with morality.

  • Primacy of human rights, underscoring that natural law predates democratic systems.

Bureaucratic Implications
  • Role of reason in law enforcement and judicial processes, emphasizing due process and predictability aligned with natural law.

Natural Law in Statutes and Case Law

  • Indirect Manifestation in Law:

    • Evidence of moral foundations in statutory language.

  • Examples:

    • Preambles or Purpose provisions in statutes, such as Charter of Rights and Freedoms recognizing God and the rule of law.

Significant Legal Cases
  • R v Big M Drug Mart, 1985

    • Description of freedom embodying the absence of coercion and the rights to manifest beliefs.

  • R v Morgentaler, 1988

    • The decision regarding pregnancy termination framed as a moral issue, weighing individual conscience against state conscience.

Engagement and Reflection

  • Questions for Consideration:

    • Are morals a necessary element of law? Engage with the provided Menti link for responses.