Natural Law Lecture Notes
HIST 22000 - Week 2: Natural Law
Philosophical Questions Regarding Natural Law
What are the sources of our ideas of right and wrong?
Potential Sources: Society, Religion, Human Nature.
Is there a distinction between legality and morality?
Definition of Legal vs Moral:
Legal refers to laws enacted by government; moral pertains to ethical principles.
Do laws create morality, or does morality give rise to laws?
Legal Scenarios and Moral Considerations
Scenario: A law requiring reporting of minor traffic violations.
Questions of Obedience: Should individuals follow this law?
Validity of Law: Is it a valid law if perceived as unjust?
Role of Morality in Legal Compliance.
Overview of Natural Law Theory
Fundamental Principle: True law is based on universal moral principles.
Laws are valid only if they align with justice and moral order inherent in human nature.
Key Assertion: An unjust law is not a real law.
The validity of laws is contingent upon their alignment with moral principles.
Classical Natural Law Theory
Focus on the intersection of morals and law:
Concept: "What naturally is, ought to be."
Classification of Laws:
A law lacking a moral foundation is unjust and characterized as bad law.
Notable Philosophers in Classical Natural Law
Plato:
Justice as the essence of a good society.
Only just laws are right and just is universal.
Aristotle:
Humans as social beings needing family/community/polis.
Natural laws rooted in justice, establishing criteria for good or legitimate laws.
Thomas Aquinas:m
Laws binding due to human rationality, with intuitive knowledge of good.
Natural law is superior to human law, the latter is valid only if it aligns with natural law.
Components of Classical Natural Law Theory
(i) Universal Ethical Standards.
(ii) Founded in a Higher Law.
(iii) Reliance on Reason and Rationality.z
Debates Around Classical Natural Law Theory
Team A (Pro-Natural Law): Supports the three pillars as still relevant today.
Team B (Critical View): Argues the oversimplification of morals in diverse societies.
Discussions on Each Pillar:
Universal: Are moral values universally applicable?
Higher Law: Morality of disobeying unjust laws.
Reason/Rationality: Can moral truths be discovered through reason alone or are they influenced by context?
Contemporary Natural Law Theory
Natural law's influence on political philosophy and revolutionary thought.
Key Theorists:
Hobbes:
Natural law linked to self-preservation; man-made laws for security and order.
Essential laws of nature:
Seek peace and follow it.
Right of self-defense.
Locke:
Blissful state before social contract; necessity of surrendering some freedom for protection of property.
Rousseau:
Focus on the social contract and the general will, prioritizing community over individual selfishness.
Core Concepts:
Social Contract.
Surrender of Rights.
Inalienable Natural Rights.
The Evolution and Decline of Natural Law
Decline as a dominant theory in legal and political understanding.
Emergence of Legal Positivism: Characterized by non-cognitivism questioning the knowledge of right and wrong.
Resurgence in the 20th Century:
Post-war emphasis on human rights including UDHR and the fight against crimes against humanity.
New Natural Law theorists: E.g., Finnis, contributing to the evolution of discourse on morality and law.
Interplay of Morality and Law
Discussion on separation:
Is it possible to separate legal validity from morality?
Conditions for a law to be considered valid and moral.
Overlap of Criteria: Exploring how moral criteria may intersect with legal criteria.
Examples of Historically Immoral Laws
Illustrative Cases:
Segregation, Marital Rape.
Questions raised:
What makes these laws wrong?
Moral obligations of citizens—do they exist to disobey unjust laws?
Contemporary Examples of Immoral Laws
Issues to Consider:
Assisted dying, Mandatory vaccinations, Immigration restrictions, Access to clean drinking water.
Natural Law's Presence in Legal Systems
Inherently Present Elements: Even if not explicitly cited, natural law principles exist in the legal frameworks.
Key observations regarding sovereign authority:
Certain actions are considered inherently wrong beyond mere legal endorsement.
Death Penalty and Torture: Limitations imposed by natural law principles on sovereign authority.
Democratic Elements and Natural Law
Importance of checks-and-balances in law-making to align with morality.
Primacy of human rights, underscoring that natural law predates democratic systems.
Bureaucratic Implications
Role of reason in law enforcement and judicial processes, emphasizing due process and predictability aligned with natural law.
Natural Law in Statutes and Case Law
Indirect Manifestation in Law:
Evidence of moral foundations in statutory language.
Examples:
Preambles or Purpose provisions in statutes, such as Charter of Rights and Freedoms recognizing God and the rule of law.
Significant Legal Cases
R v Big M Drug Mart, 1985
Description of freedom embodying the absence of coercion and the rights to manifest beliefs.
R v Morgentaler, 1988
The decision regarding pregnancy termination framed as a moral issue, weighing individual conscience against state conscience.
Engagement and Reflection
Questions for Consideration:
Are morals a necessary element of law? Engage with the provided Menti link for responses.