Self-Esteem & Physical Activity – Comprehensive Study Notes

Self-Esteem: Definition and distinction from self-concept

  • Self-esteem differs from self-concept: self-concept describes aspects or descriptors of the self, whereas self-esteem attaches value to those descriptors. This distinction is stated by Biddle et al. (2015).
  • Self-esteem is the way an individual feels about themselves and how they appraise their own worth.

Multidimensional and hierarchical structure of self-esteem

  • Structure adapted from Biddle et al. (2015):
    • GLOBAL SELF-ESTEEM
    • PHYSICAL SELF-WORTH
    • ACADEMIC SELF-WORTH
    • OTHER DOMAINS
  • Within the GLOBAL DOMAIN: GLOBAL SELF-ESTEEM is linked to sub-domains such as Physical Self-Worth, Academic Self-Worth, and Other Domains.
  • Sub-domain hierarchy shows that some domains may be more or less changeable over time (Ease of change) and may vary in level (LOW to HIGH).

Is self-esteem an antecedent or a consequence of physical activity?

  • There are two complementary frameworks:
    • The motivational approach to physical activity and self-esteem: self-esteem is an antecedent that can motivate physical activity. This is depicted in Figure 6.2 (Biddle et al., 2015).
    • Physical activity can increase self-esteem and physical self-worth in this view.
    • Conversely, low self-esteem can act as a barrier to initiating or maintaining activity.
    • The personal development approach to physical activity and self-esteem: physical activity contributes to increased self-esteem as a consequence of engaging in activity and developing skills.
    • This perspective emphasizes growth in competence, mastery, and value from participation.
  • The two perspectives are not mutually exclusive and together imply a positive cycle (see Figure 6.4).

Positive cycle: physical activity and self-esteem

  • A positive cycle exists where:
    • Increased self-esteem and physical self-worth attract individuals to further physical activity.
    • Engagement in PA reinforces positive self-esteem and physical self-worth, promoting continued activity.
  • Conceptually:
    • extSelf−Esteem<br/>↗⇒extPhysicalActivity<br/>↗⇒extSelf−Esteem<br/>↗ext{Self-Esteem} <br />\nearrow \Rightarrow ext{Physical Activity} <br />\nearrow \Rightarrow ext{Self-Esteem} <br />\nearrow
  • This cycle captures mutual reinforcement between PA engagement and self-esteem across time.

Physical self-perception profile (Fox & Corbin, 1989)

  • Global Self-Esteem
  • Physical Self-Worth
  • Sports Competence
  • Attractive Body
  • Physical Strength
  • Physical Condition
  • For each domain, three aspects are assessed:
    • Ability
    • Learning
    • Confidence

Exercise and Self-Esteem Model (EXSEM)

  • A framework for studying the relationship between physical activity and self-esteem (Sonstroem & Morgan, 1989; Sonstroem et al., 1994; McAuley et al., 2005):
    • Physical activity
    • Self-efficacy
    • Sports competence
    • Attractive body
    • Physical condition
    • Strength
    • Physical self-worth
    • Global self-esteem
  • The model links activity to self-efficacy and body-related perceptions, which in turn influence global self-esteem.
  • Key evolution: EXSEM has been refined by McAuley et al. (2005) to emphasize pathways from physical activity to self-esteem via self-efficacy and domain-specific constructs.

Reflect: prompts to recall personal beginnings with activity

  • Think about when you first started being active (sport, recreation):
    • What started it?
    • What made you carry on?
    • Did it change the way you felt about yourself?

Evidence: PA and self-esteem in Children & Youth

  • Overall conclusion: Systematic reviews show weak to moderate evidence for the effect of physical activity on self-esteem; the most consistent evidence is for self-concept.
  • The evidence spans diverse groups (overweight/obese, disabilities, typically developing).
  • Supervised aerobic exercises tend to be more effective than unguided PA.
  • A major caveat: poor study design may explain the modest findings.
  • Source: Dale et al., 2019

Evidence: PA and self-esteem in 12-year-olds (Tremblay et al., 2000)

  • Examines Self-Esteem as a function of Vigorous Activity (Days/Week) by gender (Males vs. Females).
  • The data show a pattern where self-esteem associations with vigorous activity vary by number of activity days per week and by sex, with small-to-moderate effects overall.

Evidence: TV/screen time and self-esteem (11–13 years; Braig et al., 2018)

  • Screen time is associated with lower satisfaction with friends and lower self-esteem in this age group.
  • The figure reports significant coefficients (e.g., values such as 3.62** and 0.43** in the depicted model), indicating meaningful relationships between screen exposure, social satisfaction, and self-esteem.

Evidence: PA and self-esteem (Adults)

  • Overall, there is a small positive association between physical activity and global self-esteem: ES≈0.23ES \approx 0.23
  • Question raised: Is the influence of PA on global self-esteem over-emphasised? (Spence et al., 2005)
  • Fitness changes show a larger positive association: ESextfitness=0.32ES_{ ext{fitness}} = 0.32
  • Exercise + Lifestyle shows an even larger positive association: ESextexercise+lifestyle=0.36ES_{ ext{exercise+lifestyle}} = 0.36

Evidence: PA and self-esteem (Adults) – additional relations (Sani et al., 2016)

  • Reported correlations (or related associations) include:
    • Physical activity with self-esteem: r≈0.12r \approx 0.12
    • Body image with self-esteem: r≈0.42∗∗r \approx 0.42^{**} (p < 0.01)
  • Other variables linked in the discussion include Body Mass Index (BMI) and perceived physical fitness, suggesting nuanced links among activity, fitness perceptions, body image, and self-esteem.

Evidence: PA and self-esteem (Older adults) – McAuley et al. (2005)

  • Four-year follow-up
  • Key constructs linked to self-esteem across time:
    • Self-efficacy
    • Perception of physical condition
    • Perception of body attractiveness
    • Physical self-worth
    • Global self-esteem

Self-enhancement and self-presentation concerns in physical activity

  • Self-enhancement: a motivation to maintain positive self-esteem; seek activities/environments where competence and positive outcomes are likely; avoid areas with expected negative outcomes or threats to self-esteem.
  • Self-presentation: concerns about how one is viewed by others; striving to present oneself consistently with one’s self-image and with the expectations or preferences of the audience.

How self-presentation concerns might influence PA participation

  • Self-presentation concerns can affect:
    • 1) Motivation to engage in PA
    • 2) Selection of activities and environments
    • 3) Quality of engagement in PA
    • 4) Affective responses during PA

Social physique anxiety

  • Definition: anxiety about perceived evaluation of one’s physique by others.
  • Relevance: a type of self-presentational concern particularly salient in physical activity contexts.
  • Potential consequences:
    • Avoid scrutiny and avoidance of activities that accentuate physique
    • Attempts to modify or “improve” the body through potentially harmful behaviors

True vs contingent self-esteem

  • True self-esteem: develops through autonomy, experiences of self-efficacy, and being loved for who one is, not for achievements or external outcomes.
  • Contingent self-esteem: depends on meeting external standards of excellence or living up to expectations; hinges on social comparison and external validation.