Comprehensive Guide to Syntax, Clauses, Sentence Architecture, and Verbals
Foundations of Syntax, Semantics, and Rhetoric
The Rhetorical Formula:
Expressive language relies upon the integration of vocabulary and grammar to produce persuasive and aesthetic communication:
Syntax versus Logic:
In computational, technical, and structural disciplines, arguments often arise concerning the relative importance of code logic versus syntactical correctness (e.g., Edwin Kato, September 7, 2017: "Forget the syntax, it's the logic that really counts").
In English linguistics and composition, syntactic precision remains non-negotiable.
According to lexicographical authorities such as Dictionary.com: "While diction can be flexible, especially in casual conversation, proper syntax is comparatively strict."
Syntactic Structure versus Semantic Sense:
A sentence can adhere perfectly to structural syntactic rules while lacking cognitive or literal sense, or conversely, collapse into syntactic nonsense:
Grammatically Valid Syntax Devoid of Semantic Logic: "Colorless green ideas sleep furiously" (demonstrates standard English modification, subject-verb agreement, and adverbial placement despite contradictory meanings).
Syntactic and Semantic Collapse: "Eggs jelly pink awake fundamentally" (lacks structural hierarchy, governing relations, and syntactic coherence).
Sentence Architecture: Core Patterns, Loose, and Periodic Structures
The Core Sentence Pattern:
The standard canonical English sentence pattern is organized around Subject-Verb-Object ().
Variational arrangements modifying this core include:
Loose (cumulative) structure
Centered structure
Periodic structure
Loose (Cumulative) Sentences:
Definition: A sentence structure in which the primary independent (main) clause comes first, followed by accumulating subordinate grammatical units, including modifying phrases and dependent clauses acting as descriptive "branches."
Structural Characteristics:
Highly flexible and economical in delivering heavy informational loads and visual imagery.
Often resembles poetry because it can be densely packed with sensory detail and successive observations.
Complete grammatical sense and closure occur early; the sentence can stand alone even if severed before the final period.
Rhetorical and Psychological Effect:
Syntactic tension is resolved immediately at the opening.
Allows the reader to absorb subsequent details, qualifications, and expansions at a relaxed, exploratory pace without cognitive suspense.
Exemplars:
"He might eat all the jellybeans, if there are enough colors, if they taste delicious, and if he doesn’t get caught."
"The new mall is finally opening today, with an ice skating rink and a multiplex theater."
"Barney took a day off from work without permission and without telling anyone."
Periodic Sentences:
Definition: A sentence structured so that the main (independent) clause is deliberately withheld until the terminal position, preceded by an accumulation of modifying phrases and dependent clauses.
Structural Characteristics:
Grammatical completeness is suspended until the end; the construction does not make complete sense and cannot stand alone until the final clause is articulated.
Rhetorical and Psychological Effect:
Establishes and builds sustained narrative tension and reader suspense.
Provides powerful emphasis, dramatic weight, and rhetorical amplification to the concluding assertion.
Exemplars:
"And though I have the gift of prophecy, and understand all mysteries and all knowledge; and though I have all faith so that I could move mountains, and have not charity, I am nothing."
"After shopping at the mall, walking the dogs and washing the car, I finally got to stay in and relax."
"In spite of heavy snow and cold temperatures, the game continued."
Extended Syntactic Case Study (Oliver Wendell Holmes Sr.):
Demonstrates the execution of an expansive periodic construction containing only one main independent clause positioned near the conclusion, preceded by extended subordinated impressions and scientific analogies:
"Many times, when I have got upon the cars, expecting to be magnetized into an hour or two of blissful reverie, my thoughts shaken up by the vibrations into all sorts of new and pleasing patterns, arranging themselves in curves and nodal points, like the grains of sand in Chladni's famous experiment,—fresh ideas coming up to the surface, as the kernels do when a measure of corn is jolted in a farmer's wagon,—all this without volition, the mechanical impulse alone keeping the thoughts in motion, as the mere act of carrying certain watches in the pocket keeps them wound up,—many times, I say, just as my brain was beginning to creep and hum with this delicious locomotive intoxication, some dear detestable friend, cordial, intelligent, social, radiant, has come up and sat down by me and opened a conversation which has broken my day-dream, unharnessed the flying horses that were whirling along my fancies and hitched on the old weary omnibus-team of every-day associations, fatigued my hearing and attention, exhausted my voice, and milked the breasts of my thought dry during the hour when they should have been filling themselves full of fresh juices."
Embedded Analogies within the Holmes Period:
Chladni's Sand Experiment: Represents the spontaneous arrangement of thoughts into mathematical curves and nodal lines under rhythmic locomotive vibrations.
Farmer's Jolting Wagon: Represents subconscious, unbidden ideas surfacing like kernels of corn through continuous shaking.
Self-Winding Pocket Watch: Represents mechanical kinetic motion driving creative contemplation without deliberate conscious volition.
Flying Horses versus Weary Omnibus-Team: Contrasts transcendent poetic reverie with mundane, social conversation.
Advanced Syntactical Techniques for Stylistic Complexity
1. Inversion:
Altering the canonical order to Object-Subject-Verb () or placing the object/complement before the governing verb.
Yields striking emphasis and disrupts passive reader expectations.
Examples:
"Now, that I like!"
"The house itself she hated, but the yard was grand."
"The manuscript, especially, she treasured."
"Discussion questions, particularly, she hated."
"The obvious he overlooked."
"The bills she ignored, but the tax forms she mailed."
"The analogy, to a certain extent, I grasped."
2. Structural Interruptions:
Inserting parenthetical words or phrases into non-standard sequences (such as between an inverted object and subject) to postpone core elements.
The unexpected interruption forces heightened cognitive attention.
Examples:
"The analogy, to a certain extent, I grasped."
"Ancient wisdom, for an hour or more, he expounded."
3. Coloring Interruptions (Appositive and Modifying Clusters):
Enriching sentences by inserting descriptive units immediately adjacent to specific parts of speech:
Coloring the Subject: "The gift, an expression of his love, though an inexpensive trifle, brought great waves of happiness to his beloved." / "The application, a mere piece of paper required by bureaucratic mercenaries, imposed an insurmountable obstacle between him and the job."
Coloring the Verb: "…he made his way, carefully at first, then confidently, then with reckless steps, along the peak of the smoldering roof."
Coloring the Object: "She finally wrote the paper, a long desperate perambulation without beginning or end—without, in fact, much of an idea at all."
4. Parallelism:
The deliberate repetition of chosen grammatical forms across coordinates within a sentence.
Exhibits balance, structural control, symmetry, and rhetorical finesse.
Correlative and Sequential Templates:
"Not only [structure A], but also [structure B]"
"First, [structure A]; second, [structure B]; and third, [structure C]"
Faulty Parallelism versus True Parallelism:
Faulty: Combining a phrase with a full clause across a coordinating conjunction ("Nomar learned early the pleasure of serving sushi, and that he could be a real help in his father’s restaurant.")
Corrected: Harmonizing verbal gerund phrases ("Nomar learned early the joy of serving sushi and helping in his father’s restaurant.")
Distribution Rules for Articles and Prepositions:
Prepositions and articles must either govern the first item alone or be repeated identically before every parallel element.
Correct: "By land, by sea, and by air" OR "By land, sea, and air" (Never omit arbitrarily on middle elements).
Clarity rule: Repeat prepositions or subordinating conjunctions when coordinating long phrases or dependent clauses:
"Since all things are not equal, since consequences cannot be foreseen…"
"He looked for an air of confidence, and for a quick wit."
5. Antithesis (Balanced Structures):
Pairing parallel syntactic units that contain sharply opposing semantic meanings.
The central punctuation (semicolon or comma) serves as an intellectual fulcrum balancing the contrasted ideas.
Classic Exemplars:
"It was the best of times; it was the worst of times" (Charles Dickens)
"To err is human; to forgive, divine." (Alexander Pope)
Applied Variations:
"I struggled daily to restore her sanity; I succeeded only in destroying my tranquility."
"Many are called, but few are chosen."
"I come to bury Caesar, not to praise him."
"I used to suture the tissue of the body together; now I suture words together."
Conceptual Pairings for Synthesis Exercises:
Stress & peace
Painting & photograph
Mural & miniature
Running & swimming
6. Coordination:
Uniting two grammatically equal independent clauses using coordinating conjunctions or conjunctive adverbs to produce compound sentences.
Semantic Classifications:
Addition: also, and, besides, furthermore, likewise, moreover, then, another
Contrast: but, however, nevertheless, still, yet
Choice: either/or, neither/nor, otherwise
Result: accordingly, consequently, hence, therefore
Examples:
"We had pizzas for lunch, and they had hamburgers."
"We had a great time; however, Katya didn’t like hers."
7. Subordination:
Depressing the syntactic rank of one clause relative to another by incorporating subordinating conjunctions or relative pronouns within a complex sentence.
Clarifies the precise hierarchy and logical interrelationship between main ideas and contextual details.
Functional Categories of Subordination:
Time: after, before, until, whenever, as, since, when, while
Reason: as, because, since, whereas
Purpose: that, in order that, so that
Condition: although, though, even though, provided, if, while, unless
Subtle versus Obvious Markers: Use relative pronouns (who, which, that) for subtle levels of subordination; use explicit subordinating conjunctions (because, although) for overt causal or conditional framing.
Examples:
"We had to have pizzas for lunch, because they ate all the hamburgers."
"Before we ate, though, we complained that they ate all the good stuff."
8. Sentence Economy:
Pruning superfluous diction and compacting syntax into lean, high-impact structures.
Employs appositives, absolute phrases, and trailing participles to eliminate redundant relative clauses and linking verbs.
Examples:
"Jim Gold, a professional magician, performed at my sister's birthday party."
"There was the lake, smooth in the early air."
"Finally reaching home, discovering how tired he was, he collapsed into bed."
"Dead to the world, wrapped in sweet dreams, untroubled by bills, he slept till noon."
"He walked slowly, his dog at his side."
9. Rhetorical Fragments:
Intentional grammatical fragments employed selectively for emphasis, pacing, or conversational authority.
Distinct from accidental grammatical errors because context makes their stylistic purpose unmistakable.
Examples:
"First, a word to the wise."
"Another point."
"Not at all."
"Within limits, that is."
10. Double Appositives:
Paring two appositive nouns together to amplify or specify a preceding noun without creating an extended list.
Examples:
"They cut out his idea, root and branch."
"He lost all his holdings, houses and lands."
Progressive Syntactic Expansion from the Core:
A systematic method for building descriptive complexity onto a minimal clause nucleus:
Minimal Core: "My father spoke."
Step 1 (Adverbial phrase of time): "Last evening my father spoke."
Step 2 (Past participial phrase for physical positioning): "Last evening, settled in his armchair, my father spoke."
Step 3 (Absolute construction for visual imagery): "Settled in his armchair, his brown eyes glowing in the firelight, my father spoke."
Step 4 (Color modification and explanatory prepositional phrase): "Settled in his old red armchair, his eyes glowing, my father told of his boyhood days on an Iowa farm."
Step 5 (Refined, specific diction): "Settled in an old red armchair, his brown eyes glowing, my father told of his boyhood winters on an Iowa farm."
Candidate Core Sentences for Practicing Progressive Expansion: "A bell rang.", "The car swerved.", "The girl ran.", "The plane roared.", "A leaf fluttered.", "The baby crawled.", "My father knocked.", "A pony galloped.", "The player leaped.", "A bird flew.", "My sister sang.", "A fire blazed."
Dependent Clauses: Anatomy, Types, and Functions

Adjective Clauses:
Syntactic Role: Modify nouns or pronouns.
Diagnostic Questions Answered: Which one?, What kind?, How many?, Whose?
Positional Rigidity: Typically placed directly following the noun they modify; cannot be moved around the sentence without causing disorientation or misplacement errors.
Introductory Markers (Relative Pronouns and Adverbs): who, whom, whose, which, that, when, where, why.
Syntactic Analysis of Model Sentences:
"Stock [that rises only moderately during periods of economic growth] may be the wisest purchase." (Modifies the noun stock).
"In December of 1787, the HMS Bounty sailed for the South Pacific to pick up a cargo of breadfruit trees, [which was then delivered to the West Indies]." (Modifies cargo of breadfruit trees).
"The ship was commanded by a capable but vile-tempered captain, William Bligh, [who had been sailing master on Captain James Smith's last voyage]." (Modifies William Bligh).
"In April of 1789, mutineers set Blight and eighteen others adrift in a longboat and sailed under the leadership of Fletcher Christian, [who led them to Pitcairn Island]." (Modifies Fletcher Christian).
"The remains of the Bounty, [which was burned by the mutineers to protect their secrecy], were discovered in 1957 off the southern tip of the island." (Modifies Bounty).
Applied Construction Models:
"The elephant, [who is blue], does magic tricks."
"The girl, [who dropped out of kindergarten], brushed her hair."
"The ball, swerving neatly through the air, landed soundly in the net, [which had many holes in it]."
"A spoonful of sugar, [which can be dangerous and unhealthy], helps the medicine go down."
Adverb Clauses:
Syntactic Role: Modify verbs, adjectives, or other adverbs (typically describing circumstance, cause, or context of an action).
Diagnostic Questions Answered: When?, Where?, Why?, How?
Positional Flexibility: Highly mobile; can appear at the start, middle, or end of a sentence without undermining comprehension.
Introductory Markers (Subordinating Conjunctions): after, although, as if, because, before, since, so, unless, until, when, while, etc.
Syntactic Analysis of Model Sentences:
"According to supply-side economics, governmental income increases [when taxes are lowered]." (Adverb clause of condition/time modifying increases).
"[When the small boat landed at Timor in southeastern Indonesia, 3616 miles from the site of the mutiny], Blight’s leadership and seamanship were vindicated." (Adverb clause of time modifying were vindicated).
"[Though Pitcairn Island had been sighted and named twenty-three years before], it was uninhabited and virtually unknown." (Adverb clause of concession modifying was uninhabited and unknown).
Applied Construction Models:
"Gramps loves eating mushy peas, [although they are gross]."
"Matthew joined the circus years ago, [when it was still fashionable]."
"Sam lives in a hole in the ground [when it is raining]."
"Dylan will be a professional kangaroo trainer [after he graduates high school]."
"Larry collects yellow rubber duckies, [while there is an economic downturn happening]."
Noun Clauses:
Syntactic Role: Perform integral substantive functions within the structural framework of the main clause.
Syntactic Slots: Subject (), Direct Object (), Indirect Object (), Predicate Noun (), or Object of a Preposition ().
Positional Rigidity: Fixed strictly in location according to their grammatical slot; cannot be moved around without collapsing the sentence pattern.
Introductory Markers: what, whether, that, why, how, whoever, whatever, etc.
Syntactic Analysis of Model Sentences:
"[Whoever is ruled by money] will find it a cruel master." (Functions as the Subject of the main clause).
"The several dozen inhabitants of the island, all descendents of the original mutineers and their wives, worry about [how their simple community can continue with the few people willing to remain]." (Functions as the Object of the Preposition about).
Applied Construction Models:
"You must choose [whomever is not yourself]." (Direct Object).
"Hildegrettarena’s excuse was [that it was not her on the security tape]." (Predicate Noun).
"[Whomever gave that speech] was absolutely inspiring!" (Subject).
"Share your gumballs with [that which shall not be named]." (Object of Preposition).
"The sophomores don’t know [what is what about anything]." (Direct Object).
Punctuation Rules Governing Clauses:
Joining Independent Clauses:
Acceptable methods for linking two independent clauses without error:
Semicolon:
Clause ; clausePeriod:
Clause . ClauseComma paired with a coordinating conjunction:
Clause , and clauseColon:
Clause : clause
Syntactic Errors:
Comma Splice: Splicing two independent clauses together with only an unassisted comma.
Fused Sentence: Running two independent clauses together with no separating punctuation.
Dependent Clause Punctuation:
An introductory dependent clause opening a sentence must be followed by a comma:
"After I smokebomb the cave, all the scorpions will hide."
A dependent clause located at the close of a sentence generally takes no preceding comma:
"All the scorpions will hide after I smokebomb the cave."
Internal dependent clauses must be set off by paired commas only if they provide non-essential (non-restrictive) information.
Sentence Classification by Clause Distribution

The Structural Classification Matrix:
Simple Sentence:
Compound Sentence:
Complex Sentence:
Compound-Complex Sentence:
Syntactic Analysis of Historical Trials (Socrates and Jesus of Nazareth):
Complex: "Three citizens claimed [that Socrates’ right to free speech had corrupted the youth of Athens and turned them against the democracy]."
Breakdown: One independent clause ("Three citizens claimed…") + one noun dependent clause introduced by that.
Compound: "These allegations preyed upon the fears of the citizens, for the charges awakened memories of past uprisings initiated by pupils of Socrates."
Breakdown: Two independent clauses joined by coordinating conjunction for.
Compound-Complex: "[Before the trial occurred], Socrates’ followers arranged several opportunities for him to escape from Athens, but Socrates intended to make a statement about popular democracy’s shortcomings."
Breakdown: One adverbial dependent clause introduced by before + two independent clauses connected by but.
Simple: "Throughout the trial Socrates purposely irritated the jury and even asked for free meals and plush housing as his due 'punishment.'"
Breakdown: One independent clause containing a compound predicate (irritated and asked).
Compound-Complex: "Finding Socrates guilty, the jury condemned him to death; however, [because of a religious holiday], Socrates spent thirty days in prison awaiting his execution and imparting some of his most fruitful ideas."
Breakdown: Two independent clauses connected by semicolon and conjunctive adverb however + participial phrase (Finding Socrates guilty) + introductory modifying structures.
Syntactic Transformations and Synthesis:
Complex Conversion: "Jesus’ trial, [which contradicted all the laws of the Sanhedrin], before the religious leaders was an unjust and illegal one."
Compound-Complex Conversion: "The Jewish leaders could not find any witnesses to give testimony against Christ; they bribed two false witnesses, [who gave conflicting reports]."
Complex Conversion: "Any false witness would pay a penalty, [which would be the same as the penalty the one he testified against would have received]."
Compound Conversion: "The Sanhedrin was not allowed to prosecute an individual; yet, the Sanhedrin prosecuted Jesus."
Compound-Complex Conversion: "At the time of the Jewish Passover, Jesus became the perfect sacrifice, and He paid the price for redeeming sinners from the penalty [which was demanded by perfect law]."
Descriptive Structural Application (Multi-Clause Narrative Case Study):

Complex: "[When the dust had settled (adv)], the cops, [who had been waiting for hours (adj)], began to move in."
Compound: "Their suspect was running away, so the police chased after him."
Compound-Complex: "Their suspect, [who appeared to be a yellow man with red hair (adj)], ran in a goofy manner; he was trying to run with comically large shoes."
Complex: "The police, [who were now winded (adj)], tackled the suspect [after they caught up to him (adv)]."
Complex: "The police quickly apprehended and detained the man, or [whatever this creature was (n)]."
Compound-Complex: "As they dragged the thing, [who was resisting the arrest (adj)], back to the paddywagon, the police officers could not believe [what had happened (n)]."
Compound-Complex: "[Whomever was in their custody (n)] had just robbed ten banks, and he had attempted to get vengeance against the Burgerlar, a sinister being [who had a hankering for burgers (adj)], by bludgeoning him to the head."
Complex: "As it turns out, the creature was Ronald McDonald, [who is a known terrorist (adj)]."
Complex: "The case was solved [after two days had elapsed (adv)]."
Simple: "Finally, Ronald McDonald’s days of terror are put to an end."
Verbals and Verbal Phrases: Morphology and Function

Defining Verbals:
Words derived from verbs that do not serve as the finite predicate of a clause, but function instead as nouns, adjectives, or adverbs.
Can operate as single words or expand into full verbal phrases carrying modifiers, objects, and complements.
Distinguishing Verbals from Main Verbs:
Verb: "I can lollygag."
Verbal (Gerund as Noun Subject): "Lollygagging is so exhausting!" (Main verb = is).
Verbal (Participle as Adjective): "The broken toaster makes a nice spoon-holder." (Main verb = makes; broken describes toaster).
Verbal (Infinitive as Noun Subject): "To believe in a ludicrous idea like bigfoot is ridiculous." (Main verb = is).
Verbal Phrases in Context:
"The guy [drinking coffee at the top of the ferris wheel] is Mariswaldo’s brother." (Participial phrase modifying guy).
"Mom’s favorite thing to do is [to drink three cups of scalding coffee in rapid succession]." (Infinitive phrase functioning as predicate noun).
"The ogre, [drunk on his morning coffee], howled at the moon." (Participial adjective phrase modifying ogre).
"[Drinking coffee before bed] might not be too smart." (Gerund phrase functioning as subject).
The Three Classes of Verbals:
1. Gerunds:
Always terminate in
-ing.Function exclusively as nouns.
Occupy standard noun positions: Subject (), Direct Object (), Indirect Object (), Predicate Noun (), Object of Preposition ().
Model Sentences:
"[Being chosen as the main speaker at the assembly] was a surprise to Trafalgaroy Swanson." (Gerund phrase functioning as Subject).
"His accomplishment was in [meeting the requirements exactly]." (Gerund phrase as Object of Preposition in).
"[Interpreting the hidden agendas of the judges] also helped him a lot." (Gerund phrase functioning as Subject).
"Trafalgaroy concluded his speech by [reminding his peers about the free cake in the back]." (Gerund phrase as Object of Preposition by).
"My favorite recreational activity is [drawing]." (Gerund functioning as Predicate Noun).
2. Participles:
Present participles end in
-ing; past participles end in-ed,-en,-t, or irregular stem adjustments.Function exclusively as adjectives modifying nouns or pronouns.
Positioned directly adjacent to the noun/pronoun they modify.
Answer adjective questions: Which one?, What kind?, How many?, Whose?
Model Sentences:
"The [concealed] wit behind many nursery rhymes often underscores political and historical events of their times." (Participle modifying noun wit).
"[Having often heard 'Humpty Dumpty'], one wonders about the origin of this rhyme." (Participial phrase modifying pronoun one).
"King Richard III, [having fallen from his horse, 'Wall,' at the Battle of Bosworth Field], may have been the subject of the rhyme." (Participial phrase modifying proper noun King Richard III).
"King Richard, [tumbling from his horse in the midst of battle], soon perished at the hands of enemy soldiers." (Participial phrase modifying King Richard).
"Queen Elizabeth I, [priding herself on her control over courtly activities], was supposedly the cat in 'Hey Diddle Diddle, the Cat and the Fiddle,' another rhyme [inherited from the English]." (priding herself… modifies Queen Elizabeth I; inherited from the English modifies rhyme).
"[Applauding loudly for whole minutes], the crowd showed their appreciation for Trafalgaroy’s bravery." (Participial phrase modifying crowd).
"The [running] boy over there just hit that old granny." (Participle modifying boy).
3. Infinitives:
Constructed via the formula:
To + verb.Function flexibly as nouns, adjectives, or adverbs.
Model Sentences and Syntactic Roles:
"Aesop, the legendary storyteller, died around ; therefore, his life and works are difficult subjects [to be examined definitively]." (Adjective, modifying noun subjects).
"Researching Aesop’s life requires us [to sort through much legendary information]." (Noun, direct object complement of requires).
"Because of Aesop’s fame, almost any brief story [to have arisen during the late fifth century B.C.] was attributed to him regardless of its origin." (Adjective, modifying noun story).
"[To illustrate key morals], the animals in Aesop’s fables talk and act like humans." (Adverb, modifying verbs talk and act).
"Aesop’s intention was [to show the flaws and merits of human nature]." (Noun, predicate noun completing was).
"Sam O likes [to swim on Saturdays]." (Noun, direct object of likes).
"[To show off] is Timmy’s form of coping." (Noun, subject of is).
Dangling and Misplaced Modifiers
Diagnostic Principles:
Modifiers, participles, and verbal phrases must clearly and logically attach to the specific noun or pronoun they intend to describe.
Misplaced Modifier: A modifying phrase positioned too far from the intended word, causing it to attach mistakenly to another element.
Dangling Modifier: A modifying phrase whose logical subject is absent from the sentence, leaving the modifier attached absurdly to whatever noun follows the comma.
Remediation of Faulty Constructions:
1. Dangling Participial Phrase:
Faulty: "Flying over the barrier and into the stands, the fan could not escape the foul ball." (Illogically asserts that the fan flew over the barrier).
Corrected: "Flying over the barrier and into the stands, the foul ball struck the fan."
2. Dangling Participial Phrase:
Faulty: "Subjected to humiliation, the producers of the reality television show should have anticipated the contestant might break the contract." (Illogically asserts that the producers were subjected to humiliation).
Corrected: "Subjected to humiliation, the contestant was expected to break the contract, which the producers of the reality television show should have anticipated." (OR: "Because the contestant was subjected to humiliation, the producers of the reality television show should have anticipated that he might break the contract.")
3. Misplaced Adverb / Squinting Modifier:
Faulty: "A friend Barnett had lunch with occasionally suggested that Barnett compete on a reality show." (Ambiguous: did they have lunch occasionally, or was the suggestion made occasionally?).
Corrected: "Barnett occasionally had lunch with a friend who suggested that he compete on a reality show."
4. Misplaced Participial Modifier:
Faulty: "Bill fell asleep under a tree, tired from the long hike up the mountain." (Places the modifier closer to the tree than to Bill).
Corrected: "Bill, tired from the long hike up the mountain, fell asleep under a tree."
5. Misplaced Prepositional Modifier:
Faulty: "With leaking pipes and a broken air conditioner, the tenants rightfully withheld the month’s rent on the property." (Implies the tenants possessed the leaking pipes).
Corrected: "The tenants rightfully withheld the month’s rent on the property with leaking pipes and a broken air conditioner."
6. Misplaced Participial Modifier:
Faulty: "Surrounded by allegations of mismanagement, shareholders demanded the resignation of the company’s president." (Illogically asserts that the shareholders were surrounded by allegations).
Corrected: "Shareholders demanded the resignation of the company’s president who was surrounded by allegations of mismanagement." (OR: "Surrounded by allegations of mismanagement, the company’s president was asked by shareholders to resign.")
7. Dangling Participial Phrase:
Faulty: "Failing to pay a royalty for the performance of a song, fair use was claimed by the singer." (Illogically attaches the act of failing to pay royalties to the abstract concept of fair use).
Corrected: "A singer who failed to pay a royalty for the performance of a song claimed fair use."