Critical Thinking, Logic, and Fallacies Study Notes

Introduction to Philosophy and Its Branches

  • Definition of Philosophy: Derived from the Greek words philos ("love") and sophia ("wisdom")—φιλοσοφία—meaning "love of wisdom." It is the systematic, rational study of reality, human existence, and the logical clarification of thoughts.

  • Main Branches of Philosophy:

    • Axiology: The study of values, divided into:

    • Ethics: Study of moral values, practical reasoning, and concepts of right and wrong behavior. Subdivided into Meta-Ethics, Normative Ethics, and Applied Ethics.

    • Aesthetics: Study of art and beauty, dealing with taste, sensory-emotional values, and methods of evaluating artistic works.

    • Epistemology: Derived from episteme ("knowledge"), the philosophical study of knowledge, its justification, sources, and standards of evidence.

    • Metaphysics: Derived from meta ("beyond") and physicea ("material substance"), the study of the fundamental nature of existence beyond physical entities. Divided into Ontology (study of being) and Cosmology (study of the universe).

    • Logic: Derived from logos ("reason"), the science directing the mind in processes of reasoning to distinguish good from bad arguments and establish valid inferences.

Fundamentals of Critical and Creative Thinking

  • Creative Thinking: Focuses on generating novel ideas, forming potential solutions to problems, and working on existing concepts to create new synthesis.

  • Critical Thinking: Purposeful, reasoned, and goal-directed evaluation of proposed solutions, claims, and thinking processes to increase the probability of desirable outcomes.

  • Characteristics of Critical Thinking (Wade, 1995): Asking questions, defining problems, examining evidence, analyzing assumptions and biases, avoiding emotional reasoning, avoiding oversimplification, considering alternative interpretations, and tolerating ambiguity.

  • Tools of Analysis (Dimensions of Thinking): Purpose, Question/Problem at hand, Assumptions, Point of View, Data/Information/Evidence, Concepts/Ideas, Inferences/Interpretations, and Implications/Consequences.

  • Tools of Evaluation (Universal Intellectual Standards): Clarity, Accuracy, Precision, Relevance, Depth, Breadth, and Logic.

  • Tools of Transformation (Valuable Intellectual Traits): Intellectual Humility, Intellectual Courage, Intellectual Empathy, Intellectual Integrity, Intellectual Perseverance, Faith in Reason, and Fairmindedness.

Deductive Arguments, Validity, and Soundness

  • Deductive Argument: An argument structured such that the premises claim to provide conclusive grounds for the truth of the conclusion.

  • Logical Strength: The degree of support that premises, if true, confer upon a conclusion.

  • Validity: An attribute of deductive logical strength where, if all premises were true, the conclusion must be true by necessity. Validity depends entirely on logical form, not factual truth.

    • Valid arguments can feature true premises and a true conclusion, false premises and a false conclusion, or false premises and a true conclusion.

    • Valid arguments can never feature true premises and a false conclusion.

  • Soundness: A deductive argument is sound if and only if it is valid AND all of its premises are actually true.

Inductive Arguments, Strength, and Cogency

  • Inductive Argument: Reasoning in which the conclusion is claimed to follow with probability rather than absolute necessity.

  • Inductive Strength: An attribute of inductive arguments where, assuming the premises were true, it is highly likely or probable that the conclusion is true.

    • Inductively strong arguments can never feature true premises and a false conclusion.

  • Cogency: An inductive argument is cogent if and only if it is inductively strong AND all of its premises are actually true.

  • Good Argument: Establishes its conclusion by possessing two key attributes: logical strength and true premises.

Syllogisms and Categorical Logic

  • Syllogism: A form of deductive reasoning consisting of exactly two premises (major premise and minor premise) and a conclusion.

  • Categorical Syllogism Terms:

    • Major Term: The predicate of the conclusion (found in the major premise).

    • Minor Term: The subject of the conclusion (found in the minor premise).

    • Middle Term: The term occurring in both premises but absent from the conclusion.

  • Types of Syllogism:

    • Categorical Syllogism: Operates on categorical propositions following class inclusion logic.

    • Conditional (Hypothetical) Syllogism: Follows an "If A is true, then B is true" pattern.

    • Disjunctive Syllogism: Operates on "Either A or B is true; if A is false, then B is true."

    • Enthymeme: A rhetorical syllogism in which one premise remains implied or unstated.

  • Rules of Syllogism:

    • Must contain exactly three terms.

    • The middle term must be distrib uted in at least one premise.

    • Any term distributed in the conclusion must be distributed in its corresponding premise.

    • Cannot have two negative premises.

    • If one premise is negative, the conclusion must be negative.

    • From two universal premises, no particular conclusion can be drawn.

The Square of Opposition

  • Square of Opposition: A categorical logic diagram representing logical relationships between four standard-form categorical propositions based on form.


Square of Opposition
  • Categorical Proposition Forms:

    • A (Universal Affirmative): "Every S is P" / "All S are P"

    • E (Universal Negative): "No S is P"

    • I (Particular Affirmative): "Some S is P"

    • O (Particular Negative): "Some S is not P"

  • Logical Relationships:

    • Contradictories (A and O; E and I): Cannot both be true and cannot both be false simultaneously.

    • Contraries (A and E): Cannot both be true, but can both be false.

    • Subcontraries (I and O): Cannot both be false, but can both be true.

    • Subalternation (A to I; E to O): Truth of the superaltern implies the truth of the subaltern; falsity of the subaltern implies the falsity of the superaltern.

Informal Logical Fallacies

  • Definition: Arguments containing flawed reasoning due to errors in content, context, or language rather than formal structure.

  • Fallacies of Relevance:

    • Argumentum ad Populum: Appealing to popular emotions or masses rather than rational evidence (includes the Bandwagon fallacy and "Everyone's doing it" justification).

    • Argumentum ad Verecundiam: Appealing to an inappropriate or illegitimate authority outside their field of expertise.

    • Argumentum ad Ignorantiam: Asserting a claim is true because it has not been proven false, or false because it has not been proven true.

    • Argumentum ad Misericordiam: Appealing to pity or sympathy to win acceptance of a conclusion.

    • Argumentum ad Baculum: Appealing to force or threat of force to coerce acceptance.

    • Argumentum ad Hominem: Attacking the person presenting the argument rather than the argument itself (Abusive or Circumstantial).

    • Tu Quoque: Charging an opponent with hypocrisy to dismiss their valid claim.

    • Two Wrongs Make a Right: Asserting that a wrongful act is justified because another party acted wrongly first.

    • Ignoratio Elenchi: Directing an argument toward proving a different conclusion than the issue in question.

  • Fallacies of Presumption:

    • Petitio Principii: Begging the question by assuming as a premise the very conclusion to be proved.

    • Complex Question: Asking a single question that presupposes an answer to a prior, unasked question.

    • Accident: Unjustifiably applying a general rule to a specific case with special/accidental circumstances.

    • Converse Accident (Hasty Generalization): Generalizing a universal rule based on atypical or exceptional cases.

    • False Cause: Incorrectly assuming a causal relationship based on mere coincidence or temporal succession.

  • Fallacies of Ambiguity:

    • Accent: Shifting the meaning of a statement through altered verbal emphasis.

    • Amphiboly: Ambiguity arising from loose or defective grammatical sentence structure.

    • Equivocation: Confusing multiple definitions of a single word or relative term within the same argument.

    • Composition: Fallaciously inferring that properties belonging to individual parts belong to the whole.

    • Division: Fallaciously inferring that properties belonging to a whole belong to its individual parts.