Eanes et al Wisconsin Bioregions

Effects of Scale and Biophysical Environment on Sense of Place

Abstract

  • Sense of place encompasses individual and collective feelings and experiences tied to particular locations.

  • Limited focus on the interplay of broad-scale sense of place and biophysical dimensions in past research.

  • Study conducted via 22 semi-structured interviews in northeastern Wisconsin focusing on residents involved in watershed conservation.

  • Findings reveal that biophysical landscape characteristics, especially water, play a crucial role in shaping sense of place across different geographic scales.

Introduction

  • Growth in place scholarship across various disciplines (environmental psychology, geography, etc.).

  • Sense of place: affective bonds between individuals and specific locations.

  • Understanding sense of place can enhance insights into environmental engagement and behavior.

  • Gap identified in empirical place studies regarding broad-scale sense of place and biophysical influences.

Background on Place Dynamics

Definitions of Place
  • Cresswell (2004): Place is a ubiquitous yet complex concept.

  • Tuan (1977): Place emerges from pauses in movement, inferring a deeper emotional connection to certain locations.

  • Massey (1994): Places are shaped by social relations and contestations, while acknowledging both physical and constructed meanings.

Sense of Place
  • Sense of place literature is diverse and at times disorganized, encompassing cognitive and affective attachments.

  • Place attachment typically refers to the emotional bond and significance attached to specific locations.

  • Different operationalizations: Place attachment as dependence and identity vs. broader sense of place definitions.

Biophysical Dimension
  • Stedman (2003) highlighted the physical environment's role in constructing place meanings.

  • Observations on how landscape features impact people’s attachments and meanings associated with place.

Scale

  • Current research indicates a lack of focus on how the spatial scale of attachment varies.

  • Most studies pivot around singular or vaguely defined scales like neighborhoods or cities.

  • Calls for research to include broader scales and connections to pro-environmental behavior.

Bioregions and Bioregionalism

  • Bioregions defined by distinctive ecosystems and cultural dynamics, serving as useful spatial units for environmental analysis.

  • Bioregions integrate human cultural elements alongside ecological and geographical characteristics.

  • The research utilized bioregional frameworks to analyze sense of place among study participants.

Study Area

  • Focus on three bioregions surrounding Lake Michigan's Green Bay: Northwoods, Door Peninsula, and Fox River Valley.

  • Overview of biophysical characteristics and ecological challenges unique to each region.

  • Importance of water quality and conservation efforts highlighted for these areas.

Methods

  • Empirical, phenomenological approach employed to explore sense of place.

  • Semi-structured interviews conducted (May 2014 - May 2015) to gather qualitative data from participants.

  • Focus on vocational and avocational involvement in environmental activities related to the Fox River Valley.

Results

Participant Demographics
  • 22 interviewees from diverse backgrounds, engaged in conservation efforts.

  • Emotional connections fostered by the quality of water resources and landscapes in northeastern Wisconsin.

Sense of Place Findings
  • Participants expressed deep affinity for biophysical characteristics influencing their sense of place.

  • Water was frequently identified as a defining landscape feature contributing to attachment.

  • Seasonal and climatic variations were also associated with positive emotional responses and recreational opportunities.

Discussion

  • Findings demonstrate that both social networks and biophysical characteristics significantly shape the sense of place.

  • Sense of place developed through sensory engagement with landscapes and meaningful personal experiences.

  • Scale of place impacts sense of connection, with strong regional ties experienced at broader geographical scales.

Conclusions

  • Findings highlight how scale and biophysical environment influence sense of place.

  • Broad-scale sense of place plays a critical role in motivating environmental behaviors and conservation efforts.

  • Future research needed on how sense of place operates beyond localized environments and in relation to conservation challenges and behaviors.