Exhaustive Study Notes on Common Consciousness, Community, and Howard Thurman's Philosophy
Common Consciousness and Community
- Collective Consciousness Definition: Collective consciousness or common consciousness refers to a shared collective awareness between people that exists prior to societal constructs.
- Pre-Existing Human Unity: Howard Thurman's philosophy pushes an ideal and a dream of unity that exists before society introduces dividing factors such as:
- Race
- Class
- Material possessions
- Money
- Formal education status
- Humanity as Utopia: The primary goal is seeking a common consciousness that acknowledges the existence and humanity of others, treating human awareness as the foundational utopia without requiring one to adopt humanism as a formal dogma.
- Classroom vs. Community Distinction:
- Elements of a Class: Possessing a building on a campus of higher learning, a physical classroom, desks, chairs, lights, students, and a professor creates a class.
- Elements of a Community: Merely sharing physical infrastructure (desks, chairs, rooms) and roles (students, professor) does not constitute a community. A person can sit in a class and remain entirely outside the community of that class.
- Catalyst for Community: Transformation from a physical class into a genuine community requires common values and common consciousness.
Howard Thurman’s Definition of Common Consciousness
- Verbatim Definition: Common consciousness increases the possibility of shared participation and receptive encounter across the boundaries of individual life.
- Core Components of the Definition:
- Increases possibility: It creates the necessary conditions for deeper human interaction.
- Shared participation: Active engagement held in common among individuals.
- Receptive encounter: Openness to receiving and engaging with another person's presence.
- Across boundaries: Bridging individual differences in city of origin, age, background, past experiences, beliefs, and ideas.
- Application to Community Building:
- Building community requires an agreement to operate in the shared space of common consciousness.
- Establishing community creates bonds (such as brotherhood among Men of Morehouse / Morale's Men) that persist outside classroom walls and extend into real-world support and upliftment.
Religion, Relationships, and Non-Verbal Communication
- Function of Religion:
- Religion extends beyond institutional church attendance, non-attendance, or abstract declarations of being "spiritual but not religious."
- Religion fundamentally addresses how a person shows up in their humanity, makes sense of life, and acknowledges power, harmony, existence, and creation.
- Practicing Grounds for Religion:
- The primary testing ground for practicing religion is immediate, valued human relationships.
- Primary testing ground: Interactions with one's roommate.
- Secondary testing ground: Interactions with a significant other or family members if one lives alone.
- Non-Verbal Expression of Common Consciousness:
- Common consciousness is articulated and expressed largely without verbal communication.
- Practical Non-Verbal Expressions: Manner of showing up, rejecting entitlement (in dorm rooms or at home), giving gifts, physical contact, a simple nod, or informal greetings ("what up, dog").
- Mindfulness and Conscious Awareness: Pausing daily to acknowledge existing, receiving another day of life, counting days, and being mindful of body organisms and life creation.
Common Consciousness with Nature: The Toddler and the Rattlesnake
- Thurman's Rattlesnake Story:
- Scenario: A toddler was observed from inside a house playing outdoors with a venomous rattlesnake.
- Interaction: The toddler and the rattlesnake interacted harmoniously as if the snake were a household pet. There was zero fear present—the child was not afraid of the snake, and the snake was not afraid of the child.
- Outcome: The child finished playing, turned around, and walked away completely unharmed. Immediately afterward, the child's father shot and killed the rattlesnake.
- Analysis of the Story:
- The father acted based on inherited cultural assumptions and fear.
- The father operated under the rigid assumption that humans and nature cannot coexist harmoniously.
- Common Ground with Nature:
- Common ground with nature and animals requires common consciousness prior to interaction.
- Practical expressions of common consciousness with nature include avoiding littering, conserving energy, preserving resources, and engaging respectfully with animal life.
Assumptions, Willful Ignorance, and Common Ground
- Prerequisite for Common Ground: It is impossible to achieve common ground without first establishing common consciousness.
- Willful Ignorance vs. Ignorance:
- Ignorance: Lacking knowledge or awareness.
- Willful Ignorance: Actively choosing not to know, understand, or engage with another's reality.
- Impact of Assumptions:
- Operating on assumptions without engaging individuals destroys the possibility of common ground.
- Assumptions create confusion, foster false narratives, place individuals in restrictive boxes, enforce unnecessary artificial boundaries, and generate harmful stereotypes.
- Assumptions often stem from past negative experiences (e.g., broad-stroking a new roommate or significant other based on a previous partner's actions).
- Methods to Eliminate Assumptions:
- Direct communication.
- Active research and investigation.
- Engaging in dialogue and asking direct questions.
- Adopting the core posture: "Be curious, not judgmental."
- Ethical/Moral Priority Scenario:
- A political offer proposing to pay voters 5,000 (yielding 25,000 to 50,000 per household) to keep a political party in office raises a fundamental moral question regarding priorities: Is one's vote and voice worth 5,000?
Case Study: The Legacy Museum Alabama River Cruise
- Setting: An excursion on the Alabama River boat cruise connected to the Legacy Museum tour focused on African American history.
- Participants:
- A grandfather (the narrator) and his grandson (a 6′2", fit, handsome incoming college freshman).
- An approximately 50-year-old white male visitor who had dropped his daughter off at college and was killing time.
- The Interaction:
- The white man initiated conversation with the grandson, asking if he was ready for school.
- When the grandson confirmed he was starting his freshman year of college, the white man immediately asked: "Are you going to college on a football scholarship?"
- The grandson corrected the assumption directly, stating: "No, I'm majoring in engineering."
- Outcome and Analysis:
- The white man was stunned and unsure how to respond after his stereotypic assumption was disproved.
- For the remainder of the trail, the man attempted to engage the grandfather in conversation to establish connection.
- The grandfather utilized the moment to educate rather than react defensively, illustrating that common consciousness requires intentionally elevating awareness beyond stereotypic reductions of Black men to athletic status.
Principles of Common Consciousness and Shared Experience
- What Common Consciousness Does NOT Require:
- It does not require identical minds or identical ways of thinking.
- It does not require identical belief systems.
- It does not require the erasure, disappearance, or surrender of individual identity.
- Shared Space vs. Shared Experience:
- Core Principle: Shared space does not guarantee a shared experience.
- The Tree Example: Two individuals walk past the exact same tree; one perceives it as a site where bird nests and nature reside, while the other perceives it in a completely different light.
- Classroom Example: Two students occupy the same room; one experiences the lecture as extraordinary, while another experiences it as boring or irrelevant.
- Relational Example: One partner can be thoroughly enjoying an activity (e.g., watching sports) while the other partner is experiencing discomfort or boredom.
- Space Perceptions:
- The same physical space (such as a home) can be experienced by one person as a place of comfort and by another as a space of exclusion and non-belonging.
- Acceptance vs. Approval:
- Acceptance does not equate to approval.
- A person can accept the reality of who someone is or the choices they make without giving personal approval to those actions.
Critique of Westernized Religion and the Religious Manifesto
- Critique of Westernized Religion:
- Westernized religion often undermines and undercuts traditional African religious traditions.
- It promotes hyper-individualism, materialism, and doctrinal misinterpretation.
- The Religious Manifesto:
- Personal responsibility requires formulating a religious manifesto based on lived reality rather than mere verbal profession.
- A commitment to raise one's level of consciousness, expand personal awareness, and pay attention to how one shows up in relationships.
Harmful Commonality and Cultural Identity
- When Commonality Becomes Harmful:
- Quiz Definition: Commonality becomes harmful when it demands that people surrender their histories in order to belong.
- Forcing uniform commonality erases unique backgrounds, personal histories, and individual perspectives, destroying the diversity that makes community valuable.
- Collectivism vs. Individual Identity (East African Cultural Model):
- In East African cultural frameworks, community emphasis ("we over me") does not occur at the expense of individual identity.
- While the surname (family lineage) carries the overall structural weight, the individual name and person remain explicitly recognized and appreciated.
- Collectivism balances communal survival without requiring the erasure of the individual.
- Systemic Assimilation Pressures:
- Dominant societal narratives often demand marginalized groups surrender historical memory to assimilate (e.g., demanding celebration of Independence Day / Fourth of July without acknowledging the historical enslavement of Black people).
- Institutional compliance examples include administrative requirements like state mandates requiring individuals to recite or listen to the Pledge of Allegiance when applying for a driver's license in Florida.