Errors in Memory

Week 8: Errors in Memory

[memory errors, cost of memory errors, avoiding memory errors, forgetting, principles of memory]


Remembering Complex Events

  • people differ in how and the quality of how they remember the past

  • hyperthymesia (highly superior autobiographical recall)

    • remarkable autobiographical memory, otherwise normal cognition

  • some memories are effortlessly retrieved when needed, while others may be harder to retrieve

  • recall is driven party by expectations

  • memory connections link each bit of knowledge in memory to other bits of knowledge and other memories

    • elements within a memory are also linked by connections, and storage is modality-specific

    • connections serve as retrieval paths. but can lead to memory errors

    • shared connections make similar memories less distinguishable

    • elements might be connected because they are associated or because they were actually apart of the memory

  • intrusion errors: errors in which other knowledge intrudes into the remembered event

  • DRM Paradigm: people are represented with list of words, and they mistakenly recall the theme word even though it wasn’t on the list (they were even warned and still made mistakes)

  • schematic knowledge can also cause us to make errors when remembering an event

Cost of Memory Errors

  • bad news: undermine accuracy

  • good news: enrich understanding, link to schematic knowledge, retrieval paths

  • eyewitness errors contribute to 75% of false convictions

Planting False Memories

  • misinformation effect: the phenomenon whereby a person's recall of episodic memories becomes less accurate due to post-event information, often leading to distorted or false memories.

  • participants experiences event, participant is exposed to misleading suggestion about event, delay, memory test

  • Shaw and Porter: people were persuaded that they committed a crime that never happened

  • evidence of false memories demonstrations that human memory is reconstructive, mot a perfect recording and can be easily influenced by suggestion, imagination, and misinformation

  • memory is recast and actively modified with every retrieval or reconsolidation

Source Monitoring Theory

  1. reality monitoring: distinguishing between real and imagined events

  2. external source monitoring: distinguishing between different external sources

  3. Internal source monitoring: distinguishing between different internal sources


  • more often than not, recollection is detailed and correct

  • people tend to trust memories that are expressed with confidence, no reliable indicators of memory accuracy have been found, memory errors are unavoidable

  • one of the best predictors of true forgetting is the retention interval (the amount of time that elapsed between initial learning and subsequent retrieval)

  • as retention interval increases so does forgetting

Causes of Forgetting

  • decay theory of forgetting: memories may fade/erode over time

  • interference theory: newer leaning may disrupt older memories

    • evidence supports this because memory accuracy depended much more on number of intervening games than on the amount of time that had passed

  • retrieval failure: memory is intact but cannot be accessed

    • can be partial, change in context/perspective

  • hypnosis makes people more open to misinformation and prone to errors

  • cognitive interview procedure can diminish forgetting

    • effort toward context reinstatement

    • diverse retrieval cues to trigger memories

  • success of cognitive interview supports idea of forgetting resulting from retrieval failure, not loss of memory

  • technique: encourage the witness to reinstate the context, encourage the witness to report everything, have the witness recall the event from different perspectives, have the witness recall the event in different order

    • repeated retrial and testing can precent forgetting

  • autobiographical memory: memory of episodes and events in one’s own life to memory of episodes

    • the self-reference effect: this phenomenon occurs when individuals are better able to recall information that they have related to themselves compared to information that is merely presented in a neutral context.

  • emotion helps you remember because it enhances consolidation

    • increases amygdala activity, and hippocampal activity

  • tendency to mull over emotional events, equivalent to repeated rehearsal

  • flashbulb memories: extraordinary clarity, vividness, and detail associated with significant emotional events, often leading to strong and lasting recall.

    • positivity effect vs age, older adults tend to remember and focus on positive information between than negative information

    • discussion with other people can act as rehearsal

  • weapon focus effect occurs when a weapon distracts eyewitnesses, harming a memory fro the perpetrator and other details

    • some authors argue that traumatic memories can be lost can recovered

    • lost memories may be due to ordinary retrieval failure

  • psychodynamic theories of repression: repression as s protective device

    • freud believed hypnosis could uncover repressed traumatic memories that were thought to cause psychological symptoms

  • how quickly memories fade away may depend on how well established they were in the first place,

  • certain principles of autobiographical memory reflect more general memory principles

    • all memories depend on connections

    • other principles of autobiographical memory may be distinct

    • the role of emotion in autobiographical memory may be less applicable to other kinds of memory (eg. semantic, procedural)