Military Justice Lecture Flashcards

Overview and Purpose of Military Justice

  • Primary Purpose: The military justice system is designed to enable military commanders to dispose of personnel problems within their units in the most expeditious manner possible.
  • Benefits of Speedy Case Disposition:
    • Preserves Discipline: Ensures prompt accountability and maintains order among troops.
    • Promotes Justice: Guarantees fair and structured legal processes within military ranks.
    • Enhances Mission Attainment: Prevents administrative delays from hindering the Commander's operational mission.
  • System Concept: The military justice system is structurally formulated to enforce discipline and administer justice across the entire military service.

Components of the Military Justice System

  • The military justice system consists of four (4) distinct operational components:
    • 1. Investigation: The formal process of looking into and examining the specific circumstances of a case for the purpose of verifying and establishing factual evidence.
    • 2. Prosecution: The formal accusation of a crime brought before a legally constituted tribunal.
    • 3. Trial or Adjudication: A formal legal action or proceeding conducted before a judge and jury (or court-martial panel).
    • 4. Judgment or Decision: The official punishment or sanction meted out to an accused individual who is proven to have committed a crime.

Divisions of the Military Justice System

  • The four operational components operate across two (2) distinct legal divisions within the military justice framework:
    • 1. Administrative Cases: Proceedings that yield decisions not involving penal sanctions. Corrective outcomes take mild disciplinary or instructive forms, such as admonitions, reprimands, and similar non-penal measures.
    • 2. Punitive Cases: Legal proceedings that result in severe judicial judgments upon proof of guilt. Penalties include fines, hard labor, deprivation of liberty (confinement/imprisonment), or a combination of these sanctions.

Standards of Proof and Types of Evidence

  • Punitive Cases Requirement: Requires the highest standard of proof, where guilt must be established beyond reasonable doubt to yield a penal conviction.
  • Administrative Cases Requirement: Requires a lower standard of proof, relying only on a preponderance of evidence (proof showing an event or occurrence is more likely true than not) to achieve a positive legal adjudication.

Sources of Military Law

  • Commonwealth Act No. 408 (Articles of War):
    • Enacted by the Philippine National Assembly on September 14, 1938.
    • Serves as the foundational statutory code guiding the operations and conduct of the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP).
    • Contains 120 Articles in total.
    • Defines specific military offenses punishable under law and prescribes their corresponding penalties.
  • Historical and Substantive Influence:
    • Most articles were directly adapted and lifted from the United States Uniform Code of Military Justice (American Military Code of 1928).
    • The 1928 American Military Code was adopted because its substance was found to be fully applicable to Philippine military conditions.
  • Scope of Guidance: Establishes mandatory rules governing the conduct of military personnel and provides precise procedures for punishing offenders.

Military Jurisdiction and Administering Agencies

Judges panel presiding over an international military trial tribunal

  • Legal Sources of Jurisdiction: Military jurisdiction originates primarily from the Constitution of the Philippines and principles of International Law.
  • General Rule of Jurisdiction: Courts-martial maintain exclusive jurisdiction over all persons subject to military law who commit any offense penalized under the punitive articles of war.
  • Agencies Carrying Out Military Jurisdiction:
    • 1. Courts-Martial: General, Special, and Summary Courts-Martial.
    • 2. Commanding Officers: Exercising disciplinary powers and summary punishments under Article of War 105 (AW 105).
    • 3. Courts of Inquiry: Formal investigative bodies convened to examine complex matters.
    • 4. Military Tribunals or Commissions: Special judicial bodies created under martial law or extraordinary circumstances.

Persons Subject to Military Law

  • Military jurisdiction explicitly applies to six (6) designated categories of individuals:
    • 1. Regular Force Personnel: All active duty officers and enlisted personnel within the regular force of the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP).
    • 2. Reservists: All military reservists, effective from the exact date of their official call to active duty and throughout the full duration of such active service.
    • 3. Cadets and Probationary Officers: All cadets of the Philippine Military Academy (PMA) and the Philippine Air Force (PAF) Flying School, as well as Probationary Lieutenants undergoing actual military training.
    • 4. Trainees: All military trainees undergoing official military instructions.
    • 5. Camp Retainers and Accompanying Personnel: Retainers to camp and all civilians accompanying or serving with the AFP in the field during times of war or when martial law is declared.
    • 6. Sentenced Persons: All individuals serving sentences adjudged by a court-martial or military tribunal.

Selective Punitive Articles of War

  • The Articles of War outline specific military offenses and violations categorized under key Punitive Articles:
    • Article 54: Fraudulent Enlistment
    • Article 55: Officer Making Unlawful Enlistment
    • Article 56: False Muster
    • Article 57: False Returns or Omission to Render Returns
    • Article 58: Acts to Constitute Desertion
    • Article 59: Punishment for Desertion
    • Article 60: Advising or Aiding Another to Desert
    • Article 61: Entertaining a Deserter
    • Article 62: Absence Without Leave (AWOL)
    • Article 63: Disrespect Toward the President, Vice President, Prime Minister, Chairman of the National Assembly, or Minister of National Defense
    • Article 64: Disrespect Toward Superior Officer
    • Article 65: Assaulting or Willfully Disobeying Superior Officer
    • Article 66: Insubordinate Conduct Toward Non-Commissioned Officer
    • Article 67: Mutiny or Sedition
    • Article 68: Failure to Suppress Mutiny or Sedition
    • Article 69: Quarrels, Frays, and Disorders
    • Article 70: Arrest or Confinement
    • Article 71: Charges, Action Upon
    • Article 72: Refusal to Receive and Keep Prisoners
    • Article 73: Report of Prisoners Received
    • Article 74: Releasing Prisoner Without Proper Authority
    • Article 75: Delivery of Offenders to Civil Authorities
    • Article 76: Misbehavior Before the Enemy
    • Article 77: Subordinate Compelling Commander to Surrender
    • Article 78: Improper Use of Countersign
    • Article 79: Forcing A Safeguard
    • Article 80: Captured Property to be Secured for Public Service
    • Article 81: Dealing in Captured or Abandoned Property
    • Article 82: Relieving, Corresponding with, or Aiding the Enemy
    • Article 83: Spies
    • Article 84: Military Property, Willful or Negligent Loss
    • Article 85: Waste or Unlawful Disposition of Military Property Issued to Soldiers
    • Article 86: Drunk on Duty
    • Article 87: Misbehavior of Sentinel
    • Article 88: Personal Interest in Sale of Provisions
    • Article 88A: Unlawfully Influencing Action of Court
    • Article 89: Intimidating of Persons Bringing Provisions
    • Article 90: Good Order to be Maintained and Wrong Redressed

Courts-Martial Structure and Types

Prosecution presenting evidence in a military tribunal court room setting

  • Purpose of Courts-Martial: Established to assist commanders in enforcing discipline within the military establishment and serving as active deterrents against military crimes.
  • 1. General Court Martial (GCM):
    • Composition: Consists of any number of members, provided there are not less than five (5) members.
    • Appointing Authorities:
    • The President of the Philippines.
    • The Chief of Staff of the AFP.
    • When authorized by the President: Commanding Officers of major commands or task forces, division regional commands, the Superintendent of the Philippine Military Academy (PMA), and Commanding Officers of separate brigades or separate bodies of troops.
  • 2. Special Court Martial (SCM):
    • Composition: Consists of any number of members, provided there are not less than three (3) members.
    • Appointing Authorities:
    • Commanding Officers of major commands, task forces, regional commands, or divisions.
    • When authorized by the President: Commanding Officers of a garrison, camp, brigade, regiment, detached battalion, other detached command, or a commissioned vessel.
  • 3. Summary Court Martial (SCM):
    • Composition: Consists of at least one (1) member who concurrently acts as President, Trial Judge Advocate (TJA), and Defense Counsel.
    • Operational Efficiency: Proceedings are much faster than General or Special Courts-Martial.
    • Jurisdiction and Speed: Possesses strictly limited jurisdiction over persons, offenses, and punishments, enabling it to dispose of minor cases in the most expeditious manner.

Military Commissions and Tribunals

An accused individual presenting testimony before a military commission

  • Role: Serves an identical judicial role to courts-martial during exceptional or emergency periods.
  • Historical Application During Martial Law (1972–1981):
    • In effect across the Philippines from 1972 to 1981.
    • Tried cases referred to them in an expedited legal manner.
    • Civilians who committed specific offenses not normally triable by standard courts-martial fell under the legal jurisdiction of these special military bodies.
    • All proceedings were conducted according to statutory procedural law.
  • Case Study Example:
    • A Chinese national charged with drug pushing and distribution was tried and convicted by a military commission.
    • The tribunal meted out the death penalty, which was executed via musketry.