Military Justice Lecture Flashcards
Overview and Purpose of Military Justice
- Primary Purpose: The military justice system is designed to enable military commanders to dispose of personnel problems within their units in the most expeditious manner possible.
- Benefits of Speedy Case Disposition:
- Preserves Discipline: Ensures prompt accountability and maintains order among troops.
- Promotes Justice: Guarantees fair and structured legal processes within military ranks.
- Enhances Mission Attainment: Prevents administrative delays from hindering the Commander's operational mission.
- System Concept: The military justice system is structurally formulated to enforce discipline and administer justice across the entire military service.
Components of the Military Justice System
- The military justice system consists of four (4) distinct operational components:
- 1. Investigation: The formal process of looking into and examining the specific circumstances of a case for the purpose of verifying and establishing factual evidence.
- 2. Prosecution: The formal accusation of a crime brought before a legally constituted tribunal.
- 3. Trial or Adjudication: A formal legal action or proceeding conducted before a judge and jury (or court-martial panel).
- 4. Judgment or Decision: The official punishment or sanction meted out to an accused individual who is proven to have committed a crime.
Divisions of the Military Justice System
- The four operational components operate across two (2) distinct legal divisions within the military justice framework:
- 1. Administrative Cases: Proceedings that yield decisions not involving penal sanctions. Corrective outcomes take mild disciplinary or instructive forms, such as admonitions, reprimands, and similar non-penal measures.
- 2. Punitive Cases: Legal proceedings that result in severe judicial judgments upon proof of guilt. Penalties include fines, hard labor, deprivation of liberty (confinement/imprisonment), or a combination of these sanctions.
Standards of Proof and Types of Evidence
- Punitive Cases Requirement: Requires the highest standard of proof, where guilt must be established beyond reasonable doubt to yield a penal conviction.
- Administrative Cases Requirement: Requires a lower standard of proof, relying only on a preponderance of evidence (proof showing an event or occurrence is more likely true than not) to achieve a positive legal adjudication.
Sources of Military Law
- Commonwealth Act No. 408 (Articles of War):
- Enacted by the Philippine National Assembly on September 14, 1938.
- Serves as the foundational statutory code guiding the operations and conduct of the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP).
- Contains 120 Articles in total.
- Defines specific military offenses punishable under law and prescribes their corresponding penalties.
- Historical and Substantive Influence:
- Most articles were directly adapted and lifted from the United States Uniform Code of Military Justice (American Military Code of 1928).
- The 1928 American Military Code was adopted because its substance was found to be fully applicable to Philippine military conditions.
- Scope of Guidance: Establishes mandatory rules governing the conduct of military personnel and provides precise procedures for punishing offenders.
Military Jurisdiction and Administering Agencies

- Legal Sources of Jurisdiction: Military jurisdiction originates primarily from the Constitution of the Philippines and principles of International Law.
- General Rule of Jurisdiction: Courts-martial maintain exclusive jurisdiction over all persons subject to military law who commit any offense penalized under the punitive articles of war.
- Agencies Carrying Out Military Jurisdiction:
- 1. Courts-Martial: General, Special, and Summary Courts-Martial.
- 2. Commanding Officers: Exercising disciplinary powers and summary punishments under Article of War 105 (AW 105).
- 3. Courts of Inquiry: Formal investigative bodies convened to examine complex matters.
- 4. Military Tribunals or Commissions: Special judicial bodies created under martial law or extraordinary circumstances.
Persons Subject to Military Law
- Military jurisdiction explicitly applies to six (6) designated categories of individuals:
- 1. Regular Force Personnel: All active duty officers and enlisted personnel within the regular force of the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP).
- 2. Reservists: All military reservists, effective from the exact date of their official call to active duty and throughout the full duration of such active service.
- 3. Cadets and Probationary Officers: All cadets of the Philippine Military Academy (PMA) and the Philippine Air Force (PAF) Flying School, as well as Probationary Lieutenants undergoing actual military training.
- 4. Trainees: All military trainees undergoing official military instructions.
- 5. Camp Retainers and Accompanying Personnel: Retainers to camp and all civilians accompanying or serving with the AFP in the field during times of war or when martial law is declared.
- 6. Sentenced Persons: All individuals serving sentences adjudged by a court-martial or military tribunal.
Selective Punitive Articles of War
- The Articles of War outline specific military offenses and violations categorized under key Punitive Articles:
- Article 54: Fraudulent Enlistment
- Article 55: Officer Making Unlawful Enlistment
- Article 56: False Muster
- Article 57: False Returns or Omission to Render Returns
- Article 58: Acts to Constitute Desertion
- Article 59: Punishment for Desertion
- Article 60: Advising or Aiding Another to Desert
- Article 61: Entertaining a Deserter
- Article 62: Absence Without Leave (AWOL)
- Article 63: Disrespect Toward the President, Vice President, Prime Minister, Chairman of the National Assembly, or Minister of National Defense
- Article 64: Disrespect Toward Superior Officer
- Article 65: Assaulting or Willfully Disobeying Superior Officer
- Article 66: Insubordinate Conduct Toward Non-Commissioned Officer
- Article 67: Mutiny or Sedition
- Article 68: Failure to Suppress Mutiny or Sedition
- Article 69: Quarrels, Frays, and Disorders
- Article 70: Arrest or Confinement
- Article 71: Charges, Action Upon
- Article 72: Refusal to Receive and Keep Prisoners
- Article 73: Report of Prisoners Received
- Article 74: Releasing Prisoner Without Proper Authority
- Article 75: Delivery of Offenders to Civil Authorities
- Article 76: Misbehavior Before the Enemy
- Article 77: Subordinate Compelling Commander to Surrender
- Article 78: Improper Use of Countersign
- Article 79: Forcing A Safeguard
- Article 80: Captured Property to be Secured for Public Service
- Article 81: Dealing in Captured or Abandoned Property
- Article 82: Relieving, Corresponding with, or Aiding the Enemy
- Article 83: Spies
- Article 84: Military Property, Willful or Negligent Loss
- Article 85: Waste or Unlawful Disposition of Military Property Issued to Soldiers
- Article 86: Drunk on Duty
- Article 87: Misbehavior of Sentinel
- Article 88: Personal Interest in Sale of Provisions
- Article 88A: Unlawfully Influencing Action of Court
- Article 89: Intimidating of Persons Bringing Provisions
- Article 90: Good Order to be Maintained and Wrong Redressed
Courts-Martial Structure and Types

- Purpose of Courts-Martial: Established to assist commanders in enforcing discipline within the military establishment and serving as active deterrents against military crimes.
- 1. General Court Martial (GCM):
- Composition: Consists of any number of members, provided there are not less than five (5) members.
- Appointing Authorities:
- The President of the Philippines.
- The Chief of Staff of the AFP.
- When authorized by the President: Commanding Officers of major commands or task forces, division regional commands, the Superintendent of the Philippine Military Academy (PMA), and Commanding Officers of separate brigades or separate bodies of troops.
- 2. Special Court Martial (SCM):
- Composition: Consists of any number of members, provided there are not less than three (3) members.
- Appointing Authorities:
- Commanding Officers of major commands, task forces, regional commands, or divisions.
- When authorized by the President: Commanding Officers of a garrison, camp, brigade, regiment, detached battalion, other detached command, or a commissioned vessel.
- 3. Summary Court Martial (SCM):
- Composition: Consists of at least one (1) member who concurrently acts as President, Trial Judge Advocate (TJA), and Defense Counsel.
- Operational Efficiency: Proceedings are much faster than General or Special Courts-Martial.
- Jurisdiction and Speed: Possesses strictly limited jurisdiction over persons, offenses, and punishments, enabling it to dispose of minor cases in the most expeditious manner.
Military Commissions and Tribunals

- Role: Serves an identical judicial role to courts-martial during exceptional or emergency periods.
- Historical Application During Martial Law (1972–1981):
- In effect across the Philippines from 1972 to 1981.
- Tried cases referred to them in an expedited legal manner.
- Civilians who committed specific offenses not normally triable by standard courts-martial fell under the legal jurisdiction of these special military bodies.
- All proceedings were conducted according to statutory procedural law.
- Case Study Example:
- A Chinese national charged with drug pushing and distribution was tried and convicted by a military commission.
- The tribunal meted out the death penalty, which was executed via musketry.