Comprehensive Study Notes on Aesthetics: Theories of Art and Beauty
The Metaphysics of Creation and the Essence of Art
According to the philosopher María Zambrano in her work Filosofía y poesía, art holds a central and definitive place within the "metaphysics of creation." She posits that the act of creation is fundamentally an aesthetic act—the act of giving form. Within this perspective, art is not merely an addition to reality but is the very mechanism through which creation manifests itself. This leads to the ontological conclusion that the notion of art is the central pillar of how we understand the process of bringing something into existence.
Fundamental Theories of Artistic Value
There are three primary theories used to describe the artistic value of a work, each focusing on a different locus of meaning: the form, the emotion, or the symbol.
Formalism
Formalism is an aesthetic theory that asserts the artistic essence of a work resides exclusively in its material characteristics and the objective organization of its formal components. Driven by theories of "pure visibility" at the end of the century and the beginning of the century, formalism emerged as modernity sought to grant autonomy to the artwork, moving away from the subjective representation of the creator. The core concept is "significant form." Proponents argue that a specific combination of lines and colors, and the relationships between these forms, are what awaken aesthetic emotions. For example, in the paintings of Giotto or Velázquez, the specific narrative or subject matter is secondary; the true aesthetic value is carried by the form itself, which signifies independently of any hypothetical content.
Paul Klee refined this view by suggesting that the artist does not merely reproduce the visible but "makes visible." By penetrating the things of nature, the artist moves from a finished image to a vision of creation as genesis, expanding the limits of ordinary life through a secret vision.
Expressionism
Expressionism defines art through a subjective and emotional vision of the world. Dominant in the first quarter of the century, particularly in the atmosphere of malaise and revolt surrounding World War I, it is characterized by a violent and tormented aesthetic. Common traits include heavy impasto, violent colors, and a distorted or exaggerated reality designed to communicate sensations of pathos and exacerbated feelings. As Leo Tolstoy wrote in What is Art?, art is a means of communicating emotions between humans. Any expression—be it musical, pictorial, or written—that allows a spectator to feel an emotion experienced and transmitted by the artist is a work of art. This faculty allows us to access feelings experienced by others, even those from a thousand years ago.
Symbolism
Symbolism places artistic value in the meaning or significance of the work. Throughout history, various civilizations and religions have developed symbolic vocabularies to express sacred concepts, collective identities, and abstract theories. Symbolism suggests that the human spirit is programmed for symbolic communication, utilizing archetypes that transcend space and time. Oscar Wilde, in The Picture of Dorian Gray, noted that all art is simultaneously surface and symbol. He argued that art reflects the spectator rather than life itself, and the diversity of opinions on a work proves its complexity and vitality.
Theories Regarding Art and Reality
The following theories explore how art relates to nature and society, ranging from direct imitation to total independence.
Naturalism
Naturalism (often used synonymously with Realism) describes a mimetic representation of nature. It attempts to record the subject without deliberate idealization or stylization. This can manifest as the documentation of immediate visual experience or as scientific inquiry, such as Leonardo da Vinci’s anatomical drawings. Aristotle, in his Poetics, argued that imitation is inherent to human nature from childhood. Humans are the most imitative of animals, acquiring their first knowledge through imitation. There is a natural pleasure in viewing representations because the act of learning and reasoning about what things are (e.g., recognizing "this man is so-and-so") is deeply agreeable to the human mind.
Aestheticism
Aestheticism belongs to the "art for art's sake" movement, prioritizing art over nature and life. It considers the art object to be self-justifying; its importance stems from its aesthetic characteristics rather than any social or natural utility. Artistic beauty is seen as independent of natural beauty, granting the artist freedom to invent worlds different from reality. Novalis described the act of making a poem as "engendering" a living individual, utilizing an inexhaustible supply of materials to create unique compositions.
Interactionism
Interactionism seeks a balanced relationship between reality and the artist's imagination. It posits that art cannot be dissociated from nature and society because the artist is a social being. While the work is a product of a singular individual, it is nonetheless communal. Ernesto Sabato, in The Writer and His Ghosts, argued that art is versioned or translated from external events through the artist's consciousness. Since living is "living together" (convivir), the artistic cycle is only completed when the work reintegrates with the community, producing a shared emotional commotion. Thus, art exists not just in the human being but between them.
The Philosophical Evolution of Beauty
Beauty as Order and Proportion (The Classical View)
Plato (IV century B.C.) established that the idea of Beauty-in-itself is far greater than the satisfaction derived from beautiful objects. In The Banquet, he describes a hierarchy of beauty: one must rise from the beauty of one body to two, then to all beautiful bodies, then to beautiful occupations, then to sciences, and finally to the unique science of Beauty itself. In this Greek classical thought, beauty equals harmony, balance, and symmetry. Plato famously identified the beautiful with the good: "what is beautiful is good, and what is good is necessarily beautiful."
Polyclitus ( century B.C.) codified these rules in his Treatise on Proportions. He created the Doryphoros (the Spear-Bearer), also known as the "Canon" or the rule. The statue followed perfect proportions: the head is contained exactly times in the total height of the body, and the head itself is as long as it is high and wide, approximating the form of a sphere. Beauty here is the harmonious proportion between all parts.
Beauty as Pleasure and Subjective Judgment
With the shift from Realism to Idealism, philosophers began to see beauty as a representation of the subject. In , Descartes defined beauty as that which pleases the greatest number of people. Diderot, in the Encyclopédie, argued that beauty is defined by the relationship to the object rather than qualities inherent in the object itself. There is no absolute beauty independent of human judgment.
David Hume ( century) claimed that beauty is not a quality inherent in things but exists only in the mind that contemplates them. Our sense of beauty is tied to the principle of pleasure: objects that give pleasure to the possessor are regarded as beautiful, while those causing pain are ugly. Thus, pleasure and pain are not just companions to beauty and ugliness; they are their essence. Beauty is discerned through taste and sensation rather than objective rules.
The Distinction Between the Beautiful and the Sublime
Edmund Burke and Immanuel Kant distinguished the "Beautiful" from the "Sublime." While both involve pleasure, they differ significantly:
- The Beautiful: Relates to the form of the object, which consists of limitation, order, and harmony. It is associated with serenity, smallness, and delicate traits.
- The Sublime: Found in formless objects or instances of illimitation. It is triggered by feelings of terror and violent passion, often involving nature’s destructive power—such as storm clouds, volcanoes, hurricanes, or the vast ocean.
Kant noted that these terrifying things are attractive only when we are in a state of safety. The Sublime elevates the soul by revealing an internal power of resistance that allows us to measure ourselves against the apparent omnipotence of nature. The pleasure of the beautiful comes from order; the pleasure of the sublime comes from the resistance to the limitless.
Beauty as a Human and Temporary Creation
Friedrich Nietzsche rejected the Platonic "Beauty-in-itself," calling it a word without a concept. He argued that beauty is a value created by humans, who place themselves as the measure of perfection. Humans have given the world the "gift" of beauty—a beauty that is "human, all too human." Following Nietzsche, the Avant-garde movements of the century rejected traditional notions of order and proportion. Apollinaire declared that "Beauty, that monster, is not eternal." The Avant-garde ended the search for a universal, atemporal definition of beauty, favoring personal language and the individual spirit of the artist over objective aesthetic categories.
Contemporary Art and the Ready-Made
Contemporary art, as illustrated by Marcel Duchamp, introduced the "ready-made"—an ordinary object elevated to the status of art through the artist's choice and the context of the gallery. For example, the "Fountain" (a urinal) challenged classical conceptions of beauty. Michel Onfray notes that contemporary art requires the "active participation of the viewer." No longer a passive receiver, the spectator must engage with the work's conceptual framework, as the focus has shifted from the object's physical beauty to its intellectual and social provocation.