IS/ISIL/ISIS/Daesh Study Notes

THE ISLAMIC STATE

IRAQ: THE ROAD TO WAR

  • International Opposition: President Bush’s plan to remove Saddam Hussein from power in Iraq faced widespread criticism from the international community.

  • Reasons for Opposition:

    • The ideology of neoconservatism was central to the push for regime change, promoting such actions as beneficial for American interests.

US INVASION AND INTELLIGENCE FAILURES

  • Lack of Evidence: The invasion did not reveal any links between Saddam Hussein, al-Qaeda, or weapons of mass destruction (WMD).

  • Criticism of Intelligence: Many international critics pointed out the poor quality of intelligence regarding Iraq’s WMD capabilities.

  • War for Oil Argument: From dissent regarding the invasion, the idea arose that the war aimed to secure oil-rich states into the US sphere of influence.

  • Reframing Objectives: The US shifted its narrative to frame the removal of Saddam as a necessary step toward liberating and democratizing Iraq.

INSURGENCY IN IRAQ

  • Sunni-Led Insurgency: A Sunni-led opposition arose in late 2003 against US forces and Shia authorities.

  • De-Baathification and Tensions: Policies like de-Baathification exacerbated sectarian tensions, pushing Iraq toward instability.

  • Military Walk-Off: Numerous former soldiers left with their weapons, leading to varied objectives among insurgents that differed from those of Islamist groups, such as AQI.

AL-QAEDA IN IRAQ (AQI)

  • Origins in Iraq: The rise of the Islamic State (IS) can be traced back to the US occupation of Iraq post-2003 invasion.

  • No Prior Presence: Before the invasion, al-Qaeda had no operational footholds in Iraq.

  • Sunni Insurgency: In response to marginalization, sections of Iraq’s Sunni community initiated an insurgency against both US occupation and the Shia-led government.

  • Formation of AQI: Al-Qaeda established AQI, presenting itself as a defender of Sunni interests and advocating for Sharia law.

  • Declaring Islamic State of Iraq: In 2006, AQI declared the formation of the Islamic State of Iraq.

  • Decline of AQI: By late 2007, AQI suffered considerable losses but remained present due to Sunni grievances and collusion with US forces.

AQI AND THE SYRIAN WAR

  • Underground Survival: Post-2008, AQI adapted to political grievances and the collapse of Sahwa militias, continuing to operate underground.

  • Leadership Shift: Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi assumed leadership in 2010, revitalizing networks in northern Iraq.

  • Syrian Civil War Impact: The outbreak of the Syrian civil war in 2011 created opportunities; Baghdadi's operatives formed Jabhat al-Nusra (JN), gaining local support as an anti-Assad force.

MERGER AND SPLIT WITH AL-QAEDA

  • Attempts to Merge: In 2013, Baghdadi announced a merger between ISIS (Islamic State of Iraq and al-Sham) and Jabhat al-Nusra, which was rejected by JN’s leader, who pledged loyalty to al-Qaeda.

  • Leadership Conflict: A conflict erupted as Zawahiri, leader of al-Qaeda, ordered Baghdadi to remain in Iraq. Baghdadi defied these orders, resulting in a permanent split from al-Qaeda and aggressive expansion in Syria/Iraq.

  • Establishment of Caliphate: By 2014, ISIS took control of key cities like Raqqa, Fallujah, and Mosul, declaring a Caliphate.

ISIS CHARACTERISTICS

  • Anti-Shia Stance: ISIS distinguished itself through staunch opposition to Shia Muslims and a lack of interest in toppling Assad.

  • Sharia Implementation: A primary goal was the establishment of a regime based on Sharia law.

  • Use of Technology: ISIS utilized social media effectively to boost recruitment and spread its message.

  • Foreign Recruitment: A continuous influx of foreign volunteers invigorated ISIS, whose narrative combined Sunni empowerment, sectarian grievance, and military success.

  • Military Success Against Iraqi Forces: The US-trained Iraqi army faced significant collapses in battles against ISIS, leading to questions about their allegiances (to the US or Sunni populace).

ISIS AS A CALIPHATE

  • Global Caliphate Declaration: In April 2014, ISIS declared al-Baghdadi as the global Caliph of all Muslims.

  • Rejection by Muslims: The overwhelming majority of Muslims worldwide rejected ISIS’s claim to leadership.

  • Attraction for Islamists: Despite rejection, ISIS’s universal claims attracted some international Islamists due to adventurous recruitment and ideological appeal.

  • Competitor to al-Qaeda: ISIS emerged as a major rival to al-Qaeda, which remained encapsulated mostly in regions like Pakistan and the Arabian Peninsula.

US RESPONSE TO ISIS

  • Initial Reluctance: Washington hesitated to intervene in Iraq, with Obama unwilling to deploy troops after previously withdrawing.

  • Lack of Support for Al-Maliki: The administration did not support the sectarian strategies of Iraqi Prime Minister Al-Maliki without significant reforms.

  • Misguided Perceptions: The US’s understanding of on-ground realities was limited, leading to underestimating the Iraqi Security Forces’ ability to confront ISIS.

  • Mosul Takeover: The IS takeover of Mosul in 2014 symbolized a pivotal shift; a third of the US-trained Iraqi Army disintegrated, exposing ‘ghost soldiers’ within the ranks.

  • Government Changes: Following Al-Maliki’s resignation, Haider al-Abadi formed a new government promising inclusivity, raising questions about the relationship between governance and ISIS’s rise.

IRAN’S RESPONSE

  • Threat Perception: Iran perceived ISIS's anti-Shia rhetoric as a direct threat to its interests.

  • Military Aid: Iran sent Qasem Soleimani, a commander from the Revolutionary Guard Corps, to bolster Iraqi forces.

  • Influence in Shia Defense: Iran became influential within the Popular Mobilization Units (PMU), aiming to protect Shia religious sites.

RUSSIA’S RESPONSE

  • National Security Threat: Russia viewed ISIS and similar groups as direct threats to its Muslim populace and neighboring Central Asian regions.

  • Request for Intervention: Russia intervened formally upon Syria's request in September 2015, prioritizing the preservation of Assad over combating ISIS.

  • 4+1 Coalition Formation: Russia, Iran, Syria, Iraq, and Hezbollah formed a coalition for intelligence sharing to confront ISIS.

TERRITORIAL DEMISE OF ISIS

  • Peak Control: At its zenith in 2015, ISIS controlled approximately 40% of Iraq and one-third of Syria, governing around 10 million civilians.

  • Foreign Involvement: Over 40,000 foreign recruits joined the ‘caliphate’ from more than 80 countries.

  • Battle of Mosul: The battle to reclaim Mosul (2016-2017) represented the largest international military intervention since the 2003 war in Iraq, culminating in the declaration of IS’s defeat in Mosul in June 2017.

  • Response to Syrian Sovereignty: The Syrian government, along with its allies, warned against military actions on their territory without consent, especially after the September 2015 attacks in Paris prompted wider international involvement in Syria.

TURKIYE'S RESPONSE

  • Conflict with Kurdish Forces: The emergence of Kurdish forces (YPG) as a primary opposition against ISIS prompted US support that alarmed Turkey.

  • Change in Priorities: Turkey’s strategic focus shifted from overthrowing Assad to containing Kurdish power within Syria.

  • Formation of Syrian Democratic Forces: The US helped establish the Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) in October 2015, combining YPG with other groups.

  • Defeat of IS in Raqqa: Backed by extensive air support, the SDF-combined forces expelled ISIS from Raqqa in October 2017, marking a significant military victory.

  • End of the Caliphate: The last territorial remnants of ISIS fell in Baghouz in March 2019, effectively concluding the era of the IS caliphate.

AL-QAEDA VS ISIS

  • Key Comparisons:

    • Al-Qaeda: Targets the US primarily; views killing Shia as counterproductive; engages in terrorism but prioritizes strategic attacks.

    • ISIS: Focuses on overthrowing regimes in Syria/Iraq; does not hesitate to kill Shia and Westerners; uses extreme violence and brutality to assert control.

  • Strategic Divergence: Al-Qaeda emphasizes proselytizing and building networks, while ISIS aims for territorial control and brutal demonstrations of power.