Lecture 09: '

Lecture 09: The Modal Model of Memory

1. Introduction to Memory

  • Definition of memory: Record of past experiences retained for future use.

  • Learning: The process by which memories are established.

    • Behaviorists: Focused on learning processes and principles; often labeled as learning theorists.

    • Cognitive Psychologists: Emphasized memory, studying factors influencing memory, and proposing theories explaining memory variations.

  • Memory's significance in introductory cognitive psychology courses.

2. Memory Accessibility

  • Memory varies in accessibility over time.

    • Primary Memory (William James): Equivalent to modern short-term memory (STM).

    • Secondary Memory (William James): Equivalent to modern long-term memory (LTM).

  • Main question: Why are some memories accessible long term while others are not?

3. The Modal Model of Memory

  • Proposed by Atkinson and Shiffrin (1968).

  • Term “modal model” signifies its historical acceptance as the standard theory of memory.

  • Reasons for studying the modal model:

    • Influential in psychological theories, still referenced.

    • Provides context for understanding later theories distinguishing STM from LTM.

    • Offers insight into the scientific process of theory acceptance and revision.

4. Memory Stores vs. Memory Performance

  • Distinction between memory stores and memory performance:

    • Short-term Memory (STM): Observable phenomenon of brief memory retention.

    • Short-term Store (STS): Hypothetical construct explaining STM; its validity may be debated.

    • Long-term Memory (LTM): Observable retention of information over extended periods.

    • Long-term Store (LTS): Hypothetical construct for long-term memories; also a subject for debate.

5. Characteristics of Memory Stores

5.1 Short-term Memory Trace Duration
  • The STS holds information briefly; LTS holds it indefinitely.

  • Memory trace decay in STS is linked to time passage:

    • Loss of information follows a gradual decay similar to sensory memories.

  • Empirical findings:

    • Brown-Peterson Paradigm (Brown, 1958; Peterson & Peterson, 1959): Recall declines sharply after 3 seconds of interference (50% accuracy) and 18 seconds (5% accuracy).

    • Suggests STM trace duration is approximately 15 seconds.

5.2 Capacity of the Short-term Store
  • Atkinson and Shiffrin (1968) posited:

    • STS has a limited capacity (5-9 items).

    • LTS has a virtually limitless capacity.

  • Miller's Magic Number (1956):

    • Span of apprehension quantified as 7 ± 2 items through digit span tasks.

5.3 Representational Format
  • STS uses phonological/acoustic coding; LTS uses semantic/meaning-based coding.

    • Conrad (1964): Participants had more errors recalling acoustically similar letters than visually similar ones.

    • Wickelgren (1965): Tasks promoting sound-based processing led to poorer STM recall.

    • Baddeley (1966): Short list recall reflects STS; longer list recall supports LTS.

    • Manipulated list types, revealing the effects of phonological vs. semantic similarity on recall accuracy.

5.4 Maintenance Rehearsal
  • Rote rehearsal maintains STM trace:

    • Refreshes memory and counters decay.

    • Transfers information from STS to LTS, transforming phonological code to semantic code.

  • Supports findings from Bennett Murdock (1962) using serial position curves in memory recalls.

6. Serial Position Curves

  • Murdock's experiment utilized word lists:

    • Recency Effect: Better recall for items at the end due to availability in STS.

    • Primacy Effect: Better recall at the beginning linked to rehearsal and transfer to LTS.

  • Glanzer and Cunitz (1966): Experimented with rehearsal prevention affecting recency and primacy effects.

7. Summary of the Modal Model

  • Two memory stores (STS and LTS) explain variation in memory retention:

    • STS: Brief retention, limited capacity, and acoustic representation.

    • LTS: Indefinite retention, virtually limitless capacity, and semantic representation.

    • Forgetting in LTS due to interference; STS forgetting linked to decay.