Glass Evidence Notes

FORENSIC SCIENCE FUNDAMENTALS & INVESTIGATIONS - Chapter 15: Glass Evidence

Introduction

  • Glass is commonly found in various environments and is notable for its:

    • Inexpensiveness in production.

    • Clarity and strength.

    • Nonreactivity with environmental elements.

    • Durability; does not deteriorate over time.

    • Ease of recycling, making glass evidence prevalent in crime scenes.

The Importance of Glass Evidence

  • Characteristics of Glass Evidence

    • Glass is durable and abundant, making it essential for forensic investigations.

    • It serves as trace evidence, allowing other forms of evidence to adhere, such as:

    • Blood

    • Fingerprints

    • Hair

    • Fibers

  • Production of Glass

    • Most modern glass is mass-produced and is often considered class evidence.

Glass Analysts

  • Functions of Glass Analysts

    • Assess various properties of glass, which include:

    • Type

    • Thickness

    • Density

    • Chemical composition

    • They may ascertain the manufacturer's identity based on elemental analysis.

    • Utilize advanced technology to analyze trace elements, leading to more objective comparisons between glass samples.

The History of Glass

  • Creation of Glass

    • Can occur through natural processes such as:

    • Sand being exposed to lightning strikes.

    • Volcanic explosions.

  • Early Human Production

    • Ancient Egypt & Mesopotamia: Production began around 3500 B.C.

    • Assyrians advanced glassblowing techniques around 650 B.C.

    • Romans further innovated with ornamental glass by the 1st century A.D.

  • Development of Specialty Glass

    • During the Industrial Revolution, window glass began mass production.

    • Significant advancements included:

    • 1903: Accidental discovery of safety glass.

    • 1920s: Introduction of laminated safety glass for vehicles.

    • 1930s: Development of tempered glass for automotive use.

    • 1956: Invention of bulletproof glass to protect artwork, such as the Mona Lisa.

  • Advances in Glass Analysis

    • Key inventions include:

    • 1937: Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM)

    • 1950: X-ray fluorescence spectrometers (XRF)

    • 1983: Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (ICP-MS)

    • 2004: Introduction of guidelines for forensic glass examination by the Scientific Working Group on Material Analysis.

Glass Composition and Properties

  • Definition of Glass

    • Hard, transparent, amorphous solid, made by heating a silica and other materials mixture.

  • Natural Formation

    • Occurs at extremely high temperatures (approximately 3,090°F) during lightning strikes or volcanic activity.

  • Modern Production

    • Glass is primarily produced from silica sand, heated until liquefied, then cooled to form an amorphous solid.

    • The amorphous nature causes various fracture patterns.

The Science of Glass

  • Basic Glass Composition

    • Common type: Soda-lime-silica (used in windowpanes and glass containers).

    • Characteristics:

    • Inexpensive

    • Chemically stable

    • Reasonably hard

    • Easily recyclable

  • Variations in Glass Composition

    • Lead glass: Used for decorative purposes and has reflective properties.

    • Heat-resistant glass: Pyrex, composed of borosilicate.

    • Colored glass: Enhanced visual effects.

    • Laminated glass: Two or more glass panes bonded with a plastic layer.

    • Tempered glass: Strengthened through heat or chemical processes.

    • Bullet-resistant glass: Composite of laminated and tempered layers varying in thickness from ¾ inches to 3 inches.

Characteristics of Glass

  • Properties

    • Color: Derived from various additives during manufacturing.

    • Thickness: Related to the intended function of the glass.

    • Density: Each glass type possesses a specific density value.

  • Refraction

    • Each substance has a unique refractive index, calculated as the ratio of the speed of light in a vacuum to the speed of light through the substance.

    • Example values:

    • Pure water: 1.33

    • Most window glass: 1.49

Refractive Index of Liquids and Glass

  • Glass and liquid refractive indices include:

    • Methanol: 1.33

    • Water: 1.33

    • Isopropyl Alcohol: 1.37

    • Various types of glass:

    • Automotive headlight glass: 1.47 to 1.49

    • Bottle glass: 1.51 to 1.52

    • Lead glass (crystal): 1.56 to 1.61

Becke Lines

  • Definition of Becke Line:

    • A phenomenon observed under microscopic examination at 100X magnification, aiding in glass identification.

    • Modern analysis enhances objectivity, utilizing tools like the Glass Reflective Index Measurement (GRIM 2).

Fracture Patterns

  • Types of Fracture Patterns

    • Radial Fractures: Cracks that extend outward from the impact point.

    • Concentric Fractures: Circles that appear around the impact site, forming on the side opposite to where the impact occurred.

    • Conchoidal Fractures: Curved fracture marks on the edges of glass, indicating how the glass was fractured.

  • Impact effects:

    • When glass is struck, it undergoes stress and forms radial fractures on the tension side, followed by concentric fractures.

Collecting and Documenting Glass Evidence

  • Crime Scene Analysis

    • Identify window orientations: inside vs. outside.

    • Investigate entrance and exit holes in glass.

    • Identify what caused the glass breakage and document eyewitness accounts that correlate with physical evidence.

  • Documentation Procedures

    • Photograph evidence in situ.

    • Maintain a log and note the presence of additional evidence like debris within the glass.

    • Carefully document the chain of custody for the evidence.

  • Collection Techniques

    • Utilize tools like forceps and gloves for handling glass.

    • Air dry any wet evidence.

    • Collect fragments by size, color, and texture for analysis.

  • Standards for Comparison

    • Separate samples from potential glass sources for comparative analysis, not mixing them with evidence samples.

Analysis of Glass Evidence

  • Preparation of Glass Fragments

    • Cleanglass to remove trace evidence using solvents or ultrasound cleaning methods.

  • Types of Analysis

    • Physical Analysis: Determines the specific characteristics of the glass.

    • Chemical Analysis: Identifies the composition and additives within the glass.

    • Microscopic Analysis: Utilizes techniques like phase contrast or scanning electron microscopy for detailed characterization.

  • Bullet Fracture Evidence

    • Assesses bullet trajectory and characteristics through glass:

    • Estimate bullet caliber.

    • Determine the direction and velocity of the bullet.

    • Assess the angle to approximate the shooter's positioning.

  • Fracture Match Analysis

    • Only method yielding individual evidence; relies on fitting pieces together, akin to a jigsaw puzzle, ensuring unique stress fractures align.

Advances in Glass Production and Analysis

  • Common Analysis Techniques

    • GRIM: Used to measure refractive index for glass fragments.

    • XRP Spectrometry: Conducts chemical analysis on trace elements, utilizing emission of X-rays from irradiated glass samples.

  • Additional Methods

    • Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry: Analyzes trace levels to distinguish fragments that cannot be differentiated by standard measures.

    • Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM): Provides detailed analysis, for instance, in examining components like filaments in car headlights.

Summary of Glass Evidence

  • Glass is an amorphous solid composed typically of silica, calcium oxide, and sodium oxide.

  • Forms naturally under high temperature from sand.

  • Laminated and tempered glass serve specific functions in safety (used in windshields and vehicle windows).

  • The refractive index indicates light's speed through materials, with differences delineating among media.

  • Glass fracture types provide insights into impact characteristics and bullet analysis, with established techniques for forensic evaluation of glass evidence, including chemical and physical analyses.