Glass Evidence Notes
FORENSIC SCIENCE FUNDAMENTALS & INVESTIGATIONS - Chapter 15: Glass Evidence
Introduction
Glass is commonly found in various environments and is notable for its:
Inexpensiveness in production.
Clarity and strength.
Nonreactivity with environmental elements.
Durability; does not deteriorate over time.
Ease of recycling, making glass evidence prevalent in crime scenes.
The Importance of Glass Evidence
Characteristics of Glass Evidence
Glass is durable and abundant, making it essential for forensic investigations.
It serves as trace evidence, allowing other forms of evidence to adhere, such as:
Blood
Fingerprints
Hair
Fibers
Production of Glass
Most modern glass is mass-produced and is often considered class evidence.
Glass Analysts
Functions of Glass Analysts
Assess various properties of glass, which include:
Type
Thickness
Density
Chemical composition
They may ascertain the manufacturer's identity based on elemental analysis.
Utilize advanced technology to analyze trace elements, leading to more objective comparisons between glass samples.
The History of Glass
Creation of Glass
Can occur through natural processes such as:
Sand being exposed to lightning strikes.
Volcanic explosions.
Early Human Production
Ancient Egypt & Mesopotamia: Production began around 3500 B.C.
Assyrians advanced glassblowing techniques around 650 B.C.
Romans further innovated with ornamental glass by the 1st century A.D.
Development of Specialty Glass
During the Industrial Revolution, window glass began mass production.
Significant advancements included:
1903: Accidental discovery of safety glass.
1920s: Introduction of laminated safety glass for vehicles.
1930s: Development of tempered glass for automotive use.
1956: Invention of bulletproof glass to protect artwork, such as the Mona Lisa.
Advances in Glass Analysis
Key inventions include:
1937: Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM)
1950: X-ray fluorescence spectrometers (XRF)
1983: Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (ICP-MS)
2004: Introduction of guidelines for forensic glass examination by the Scientific Working Group on Material Analysis.
Glass Composition and Properties
Definition of Glass
Hard, transparent, amorphous solid, made by heating a silica and other materials mixture.
Natural Formation
Occurs at extremely high temperatures (approximately 3,090°F) during lightning strikes or volcanic activity.
Modern Production
Glass is primarily produced from silica sand, heated until liquefied, then cooled to form an amorphous solid.
The amorphous nature causes various fracture patterns.
The Science of Glass
Basic Glass Composition
Common type: Soda-lime-silica (used in windowpanes and glass containers).
Characteristics:
Inexpensive
Chemically stable
Reasonably hard
Easily recyclable
Variations in Glass Composition
Lead glass: Used for decorative purposes and has reflective properties.
Heat-resistant glass: Pyrex, composed of borosilicate.
Colored glass: Enhanced visual effects.
Laminated glass: Two or more glass panes bonded with a plastic layer.
Tempered glass: Strengthened through heat or chemical processes.
Bullet-resistant glass: Composite of laminated and tempered layers varying in thickness from ¾ inches to 3 inches.
Characteristics of Glass
Properties
Color: Derived from various additives during manufacturing.
Thickness: Related to the intended function of the glass.
Density: Each glass type possesses a specific density value.
Refraction
Each substance has a unique refractive index, calculated as the ratio of the speed of light in a vacuum to the speed of light through the substance.
Example values:
Pure water: 1.33
Most window glass: 1.49
Refractive Index of Liquids and Glass
Glass and liquid refractive indices include:
Methanol: 1.33
Water: 1.33
Isopropyl Alcohol: 1.37
Various types of glass:
Automotive headlight glass: 1.47 to 1.49
Bottle glass: 1.51 to 1.52
Lead glass (crystal): 1.56 to 1.61
Becke Lines
Definition of Becke Line:
A phenomenon observed under microscopic examination at 100X magnification, aiding in glass identification.
Modern analysis enhances objectivity, utilizing tools like the Glass Reflective Index Measurement (GRIM 2).
Fracture Patterns
Types of Fracture Patterns
Radial Fractures: Cracks that extend outward from the impact point.
Concentric Fractures: Circles that appear around the impact site, forming on the side opposite to where the impact occurred.
Conchoidal Fractures: Curved fracture marks on the edges of glass, indicating how the glass was fractured.
Impact effects:
When glass is struck, it undergoes stress and forms radial fractures on the tension side, followed by concentric fractures.
Collecting and Documenting Glass Evidence
Crime Scene Analysis
Identify window orientations: inside vs. outside.
Investigate entrance and exit holes in glass.
Identify what caused the glass breakage and document eyewitness accounts that correlate with physical evidence.
Documentation Procedures
Photograph evidence in situ.
Maintain a log and note the presence of additional evidence like debris within the glass.
Carefully document the chain of custody for the evidence.
Collection Techniques
Utilize tools like forceps and gloves for handling glass.
Air dry any wet evidence.
Collect fragments by size, color, and texture for analysis.
Standards for Comparison
Separate samples from potential glass sources for comparative analysis, not mixing them with evidence samples.
Analysis of Glass Evidence
Preparation of Glass Fragments
Cleanglass to remove trace evidence using solvents or ultrasound cleaning methods.
Types of Analysis
Physical Analysis: Determines the specific characteristics of the glass.
Chemical Analysis: Identifies the composition and additives within the glass.
Microscopic Analysis: Utilizes techniques like phase contrast or scanning electron microscopy for detailed characterization.
Bullet Fracture Evidence
Assesses bullet trajectory and characteristics through glass:
Estimate bullet caliber.
Determine the direction and velocity of the bullet.
Assess the angle to approximate the shooter's positioning.
Fracture Match Analysis
Only method yielding individual evidence; relies on fitting pieces together, akin to a jigsaw puzzle, ensuring unique stress fractures align.
Advances in Glass Production and Analysis
Common Analysis Techniques
GRIM: Used to measure refractive index for glass fragments.
XRP Spectrometry: Conducts chemical analysis on trace elements, utilizing emission of X-rays from irradiated glass samples.
Additional Methods
Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry: Analyzes trace levels to distinguish fragments that cannot be differentiated by standard measures.
Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM): Provides detailed analysis, for instance, in examining components like filaments in car headlights.
Summary of Glass Evidence
Glass is an amorphous solid composed typically of silica, calcium oxide, and sodium oxide.
Forms naturally under high temperature from sand.
Laminated and tempered glass serve specific functions in safety (used in windshields and vehicle windows).
The refractive index indicates light's speed through materials, with differences delineating among media.
Glass fracture types provide insights into impact characteristics and bullet analysis, with established techniques for forensic evaluation of glass evidence, including chemical and physical analyses.