Module 8 PowerPoint :Technological Medicine (1940s to 1960s) Study Guide

Heart Disease and the Challenges of Cardiac Surgery

  • Emergence as a Leading Killer: Heart disease became the definitive leading cause of death in the United States during the mid-twentieth century.     * In 19401940, heart disease was responsible for 27%27\% of all deaths in America.     * By 19531953, this statistic rose significantly to 39%39\% of all American deaths.

  • The Problem of the Beating Heart: Operating on the heart presented a monumental challenge for surgeons because the organ was constantly in motion and the operative field was continuously filled with flowing blood.     * Early Failures (1920s1920s): In Boston, surgeons attempted to operate on beating hearts during the 1920s1920s. These experiments had a high mortality rate; out of seven patients, six died during the procedure, and the lone survivor lived for only a very brief period.

  • Intermediate Surgical Solutions (1930s1930s): To combat the blood flow issue, surgeons began tying off all blood vessels leading into the heart.     * Oxygen Deprivation Constraint: While this cleared the blood from the operating area, it left surgeons with only a few minutes to complete the surgery. Surpassing this time limit would result in permanent brain damage or the death of the patient.     * Hypothermia Technique: Physicians attempted to extend this window by immersing patients in ice-filled bathtubs to lower their body temperature to 85 ∘F85\,^{\circ}\text{F}. This reduction in body temperature lowered oxygen demand, granting surgeons a few additional minutes.

Dr. John (Jack) Gibbon and the Development of the Heart-Lung Machine

  • Medical Pedigree: Dr. John Gibbon came from a family deeply rooted in medicine; both his father and grandfather were physicians, and his father served as a professor of surgery.

  • Inspiration for Innovation (19311931): As a research fellow at Harvard, Gibbon witnessed the death of a young woman from a heart condition because her surgeons were unable to operate on a beating heart safely.

  • Conceptualizing the Heart-Lung Machine: Gibbon proposed a machine that would temporarily take over the functions of the heart and lungs, allowing surgeons to operate on a heart that had been stopped.

  • Early Prototypes and Animal Testing (1930s1930s):     * Construction Materials: Lacking federal funding, Gibbon built his first rudimentary machine using an air pump, rubber corks, and tubing made of glass and rubber.     * Trial Subjects: He initially tested the device on stray alley cats.     * Milestone (19401940): By 19401940, Gibbon successfully bypassed the heart and lung functions of a cat for a duration of 20 minutes20\,\text{minutes}.

  • Post-War Progress and Private Partnerships:     * War Service (19421942-19451945): Gibbon's research was paused while he served as a surgeon in the Pacific theater of the Second World War.     * IBM Collaboration (19461946): Upon becoming a professor of surgery at Jefferson Medical School in Philadelphia, Gibbon partnered with IBM. The corporation provided engineers and financial support for the research, though they explicitly refused to fund any experiments involving animals.     * Federal Funding (19491949): Gibbon eventually received a 30,000 dollar30,000\,\text{dollar} grant from the federal government to conduct animal trials. He successfully maintained the heart and lung functions of dogs for up to 45 minutes45\,\text{minutes}.

The First Successful Human Heart-Lung Procedure

  • Case Study: Cecelia Bavolek (19531953): An 18 year old18\,\text{year old} college freshman was admitted to Jefferson Medical College Hospital with a hole in the wall between the two upper chambers of her heart. The condition would lead to a heart attack and death if left untreated.

  • The Operation (May 6, 19531953):     * Gibbon used the heart-lung machine to keep Bavolek alive for 26 minutes26\,\text{minutes} while the heart was not beating.     * During this time, the surgeon successfully stitched the hole in her heart shut.     * Outcome: Bavolek suffered no brain damage, returned home after two weeks, and lived a normal life.

  • Legacy: This breakthrough paved the way for modern procedures, including "hearty bypass" and heart catheterization.

History and Mechanics of Organ Transplantation

  • Alexis Carrell (19121912): A French surgeon at the Rockefeller Institute for Medical Research who developed the foundational technique for suturing blood vessels together. He received the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine in 19121912 for this work.

  • The Primary Target: The Kidney: The kidney was the first organ targeted for transplantation due to its relatively simple connection points: the renal artery, the renal vein, and the ureter.

  • Physiological Role of the Kidney:     * Filters the body by removing excess water and waste (urea) from the blood.     * Regulates blood pressure.     * Produces red blood cells.     * Maintains levels of vital salts.

  • Symptoms of Kidney Failure: Lethargy, swelling of the hands and feet, coma, and ultimately death.

The Innovation of the Bridge Transplant and the Problem of Rejection

  • The Bridge Transplant (19461946): A woman in Boston suffered acute kidney failure following a botched abortion. To allow her kidneys time to recover from trauma, her physician performed a "bridge" transplant.     * Procedure: A donor kidney from a deceased crash victim was attached to the blood vessels in the patient's arm. The external kidney was taped to her skin, kept warm with a lamp, covered with a moist towel, and drained into a laboratory flask.     * Temporary Success: The donor kidney functioned for several days until the patient's own kidneys resumed function.

  • The Discovery of Organ Rejection: A microscopic analysis of the donor kidney showed that the patient's body began rejecting the foreign tissue at a cellular level within just 48 hours48\,\text{hours}.

  • Understanding Immunosuppression: Researchers in the mid-1940s1940s realized that each person's cells are biochemically unique. The immune system uses killer white blood cells and antibodies to destroy unfamiliar tissue, making immunosuppression necessary for successful transplantation.

The First Successful Long-Term Kidney Transplant

  • Collaboration at Peter Brent Brigham Hospital: Dr. Francis Moore (Chair of Surgery) and Dr. George Thorn (Chair of Internal Medicine) collaborated on the frontiers of transplantation.

  • Dialysis Innovation: In the late 1940s1940s, Dr. Thorn designed the first functional dialysis machine, which replaced the need for temporary bridge transplants by cleaning the blood mechanically.

  • The Herrick Case (19541954): Richard Herrick, aged 2424, was dying of end-stage kidney failure caused by glomerulonephritis.     * The Strategy: Because Richard had an identical twin, Ronald Herrick, the doctors realized the immune system would not reject the donor tissue.     * The Operation (December 23, 19541954): Moore and Thorn performed the first successful long-term kidney transplant.     * Outcome: Richard Herrick lived until 19621962, eventually dying when the original disease (glomerulonephritis) affected the new kidney. Ronald Herrick remained alive after the procedure.

Evolution of Immunosuppression: Radiation to Pharmacology

  • Total Body Irradiation (Late1950sLate 1950s):     * Physicians discovered that bone marrow, which produces immune-related lymphocytes, is highly sensitive to radiation.     * Dr. Moore attempted to suppress immune systems using full-body X-rays.     * High Failure Rates (19581958-19601960): Of six patients who received whole-body X-rays and kidney transplants, five died. The treatment left patients so vulnerable that they could die from minor infections like the common cold.

  • The Rise of Immunosuppressive Drugs (Early1960sEarly 1960s):     * Chemists developed drugs such as 6-mercaptopurine6\text{-mercaptopurine}, azathioprine, and cyclosporine.     * These were safer than radiation because they could be administered in small, adjustable daily doses.     * Clinical Success: In 19611961, surgical teams at Brigham hospital performed 1313 kidney transplants using these drugs with a success rate exceeding 50%50\%.     * Expansion: In 19681968, American physicians performed one of the world's first successful heart transplants using these pharmacological immunosuppressants.

Cancer Treatment and the Rise of Chemotherapy

  • Historical Context: Cancer is an ancient disease mentioned by Greek and Roman scholars. Modern medicine classifies it into four broad groups: carcinomas, sarcomas, leukemias, and lymphomas.

  • Surgical Limitations: Before the 1900s1900s, the only treatment was the surgical removal of visible tumors, which often saw the cancer return because microscopic cells remained.

  • Radiation Treatment (19001900-19461946): Early 20th-century20th\text{-century} physicians used radiation to shrink tumors. The standard protocol was surgery followed by radiation. However, because cancer was rarely detected early, it often metastasized (spread), making treatment ineffective.

  • Sidney Farber and Chemotherapy (19471947):     * A Harvard pathologist, Farber discovered that chemical agents could inhibit malignancy.     * He treated children with leukemia using the drug aminopteren, which blocked the production of abnormal white blood cells.     * By the second half of the twentieth century, chemotherapy became a standard cancer treatment.

Fundraising and the Rise of Specialized Cancer Institutes

  • The Jimmy Fund (19481948): To raise money for research, Dr. Farber featured a young patient known as "Jimmy" on the television program Truth or Consequences.

  • Impact: This became a massive grassroots fundraising campaign, leading to the establishment of the Dana-Farber Cancer Institute at Harvard University.

  • Advocacy: Farber was also a key member of the Citizens’ Committee for the Conquest of Cancer.

economics of Post-War Technological Medicine

  • Rising Costs: Healthcare expenditures grew rapidly during the 1950s1950s and 1960s1960s.

  • GNP Impact (19691969): By 19691969, health spending exceeded 7%7\% of the United States Gross National Product.

  • Government spending: The implementation of Medicare and Medicaid proved significantly more expensive for federal, state, and local governments than original projections anticipated.

Questions & Discussion

  • Citation: Sira, Ira. Seeking the Cure: A History of Medicine in America. New York: Scribner, 20102010.