Reconstruction Era: Presidential Reconstruction, Johnson, and the Amendments

Freedmen's Bureau

  • Government aid for newly freed Black people (freedmen and freedwomen).

  • Provided education, food, clothing, medicine.

  • Addressed their dire post-emancipation conditions (no housing, money, property, safety net).

  • Signaled federal intervention in Black American lives during Reconstruction.

The 40 Acres and a Mule Promise

  • Promise to Black families: 40 acres of land and two mules for economic independence.

  • Mostly unfulfilled; became a symbol for land reform and Black economic opportunity debates.

Lincoln's 10% Plan

  • Lincoln's view: Southern states never legally left the Union, just took a 'time out'.

  • Plan (10% Plan): A state could rejoin if 10% of its 1860 voters swore allegiance to the U.S. and accepted emancipation.

  • Criticism: Many (especially Radical Republicans) found 10% too lenient given the war's toll.

  • Lincoln's Stance: A Republican supporting fast readmission, but faced opposition.

The Wade-Davis Bill

  • Republican counter-proposal: Required 50% of voters to swear allegiance for readmission (much stricter than Lincoln's 10%).

  • Lincoln's action: Used a pocket veto to prevent it from becoming law.

  • Result: Different approaches to Reconstruction continued.

Andrew Johnson: Background & Presidency

  • Lincoln's VP and successor. A self-made Democrat from the South, championed poor whites.

  • Beliefs: Strong proponent of states' rights, opposed federal enforcement of civil rights/Reconstruction measures. Distrusted Northern elites.

  • Presidency: Often seen as tactless and ineffective in handling Reconstruction policies, despite populist aims.

  • Inherited a nation in crisis, opposed by Republicans wanting stronger federal action for freedpeople's rights.

Lincoln vs. Johnson: Party Alignment

  • Lincoln: Republican (1860s).

  • Johnson: Democrat.

  • Historical context: 19th-century Democrats often linked to states' rights/slavery; Republicans to federal power/ending slavery. A major party realignment occurred later in the 20th century, reversing many of these positions.

The Reconstruction Amendments

  • 13th Amendment: Abolished slavery.

  • 14th Amendment: Granted birthright citizenship, equal protection, and due process for all.

  • 15th Amendment: Prohibited denying the right to vote based on race, color, or previous servitude (for men).

  • Note: Women gained suffrage with the 19th Amendment (1920).

  • Johnson resisted federal efforts to enforce these rights.

Moderates vs. Radicals in the Republican Party

  • Moderates: Favored gradual readmission and a more lenient approach (e.g., Lincoln's 10% plan).

  • Radicals: Pushed for broader rights for freedpeople and stronger federal enforcement (e.g., Wade-Davis Bill, 14th/15th Amendments, Civil Rights Acts).

Presidential vs. Radical Reconstruction

  • Presidential Reconstruction (Lincoln, then Johnson): Aimed for quick, lenient reunification.

  • Radical Reconstruction (Radical Republicans in Congress): Sought extensive civil rights protections and federal enforcement (e.g., 14th/15th Amendments, Civil Rights Acts).

The Impeachment of Andrew Johnson

  • Johnson was impeached (first U.S. president) and narrowly avoided removal from office.

  • Quote: "a Reconstruction policy devised by angels might well have failed in his tactless hands" reflects his poor execution.

The Black Codes (1865-1866)

  • Laws passed in Southern states (1865-1866) to control newly freed Black people and restrict their rights, echoing pre-war slavery laws.

  • Purpose: Ensure a stable, subservient labor force (penalties for 'jumping' contracts, forced labor) and restore pre-emancipation race relations.

  • Restrictions: Forbade Black people from serving on juries, voting, and sometimes renting land (though recognizing rights like marriage).

  • Impact: Mocked freedom, led to virtual peonage (sharecropping), and angered the North, fueling criticism of Johnson's policies.

Key Connections, Implications & Themes

  • Key Themes: Tension between federal vs. state power. Emancipation as a political condition. Early federal social welfare (Freedmen's Bureau) and land reform debates (40 acres). Political party shifts. Ethical questions about federal duty.

  • Numbers/Dates: Lincoln's 10% plan: 10%×N<em>state voters10\% \times N<em>{\text{state voters}}, Wade-Davis: 50%×N</em>state voters50\% \times N</em>{\text{state voters}}. Notable: 1863 (Lincoln's plan); 1865 (Lincoln's assassination, Johnson's rise); 1865-1868 (13th, 14th, 15th Amendments); 19th Amendment for women's suffrage (1920).

  • Exam Prep: Understand Lincoln's 10% vs. Wade-Davis. Johnson's stances/impeachment. Moderates vs. Radicals. Presidential vs. Radical Reconstruction. Freedmen's Bureau & 40 acres. Black Codes.

Quick Reference Timeline (Highlights)

  • 1863: Lincoln's 10% plan proposed.

  • 1863-1865: Lincoln's presidency; Wade-Davis debate.

  • 1865: Lincoln assassinated; Andrew Johnson becomes President; Reconstruction conflicts escalate.

  • 1865-1866: Johnson faces Radical Republican opposition; Black Codes emerge.

  • 1865-1868: 13th, 14th, 15th Amendments passed.

  • 1860s-1870s: Shift from Presidential to Radical Reconstruction.

Homework Prompts Recap

  • Review Presidential Reconstruction.

  • Study Black Codes: purpose, impact on freedpeople.

  • Understand federal vs. state power in postwar era and civil rights.