Study Notes for Chapter 8: Liquid–Liquid Extraction with Ternary Systems
Chapter 8: Liquid–Liquid Extraction with Ternary Systems
§8.0 Instructional Objectives
After completing this chapter, you should be able to:
List situations where liquid-liquid extraction might be preferred to distillation.
Explain why only certain types of equipment are suitable for extraction in bioprocesses.
Define the distribution coefficient and show its relationship to activity coefficients and selectivity of a solute between carrier and solvent.
Make a preliminary selection of a solvent using group-interaction rules.
Distinguish between Type I and Type II systems for ternary mixtures.
For a specified recovery of a solute, calculate the minimum solvent requirement using the Hunter and Nash method and triangular diagrams for liquid-liquid extraction in a cascade.
Design a cascade of mixer-settler units based on mass-transfer considerations.
Size a multicompartment extraction column, including consideration of axial dispersion.
Compare organic-solvent, aqueous two-phase, and supercritical-fluid extraction for the recovery of bioproducts.
Determine the effects of pH, temperature, salt, and solute valence on partitioning of bioproducts in organic-solvent and aqueous two-phase extraction.
Evaluate mass transfer in liquid-liquid extraction using Maxwell-Stefan relations.
Liquid–Liquid Extraction Overview
Liquid-liquid extraction, also known as solvent extraction, involves contacting a liquid feed containing multiple components with a second immiscible liquid called the solvent.
The solvent dissolves certain species of the feed components, resulting in a partial separation.
Common practice includes:
Aqueous solutions using organic solvents.
Organic feeds often require water as a solvent.
Exceptions occur in metallurgy and bioseparations:
Aqueous two-phase extraction is used to avoid degradation of sensitive proteins.
Historical Context
Extraction has existed since ancient Roman times, where molten lead was used for metal separation.
The first large-scale extraction process was developed in the 1930s (L. Edeleanu):
This process removed aromatic and sulfur compounds from kerosene using liquid sulfur dioxide at low temperatures.
Importance of Liquid–Liquid Extraction
Increased demand for sensitive products and higher purity levels.
Availability of selective solvents has made liquid-liquid extraction critical in bioprocessing.
Basics of Ternary Systems
A ternary system consists of two miscible components (carrier C and solute A) plus a solvent S.
Solvent S: Pure compound that is either partially or completely miscible with solute A.
Mass transfer typically occurs with the highest transfer rates for solute A.
Multiple stages in countercurrent cascades are generally required for effective extraction.
Industrial Example: Acetic Acid Extraction
Produced via methanol carbonylation or acetaldehyde oxidation.
Utilizing extraction is economically beneficial when:
Mixture contains <50% acetic acid (expensive distillation otherwise).
Process overview:
A feed of 30,260 lb/h of 22 wt% acetic acid mixed with a solvent (ethyl acetate) to achieve high purity (99.8 wt%) acetic acid.
Additional distillation steps occur for solvent recovery.
The system operates under specific metrics:
A solvent-to-feed ratio of 2.35.
Six equilibrium stages transfer 99.8% of acetic acid with proper plant designs in place.
Equipment Overview for Liquid-Liquid Extraction
Special equipment considerations are critical for optimizing solvent extraction processes.
Device selection depends on phase density differences and operational conditions.
Mixer-Settler Units
Function by mixing liquid phases and allowing separation by gravity settling.
Multiple units can be connected to form cascades.
Mixing can involve various methods (e.g., jet mixing, turbulence).
Settling needs to occur without emulsification affecting efficiency.
Spray Columns
Efficient for certain extraction processes but limited by axial dispersion issues.
Packed and Plate Columns
Packed Columns: Reduces axial dispersion, improving mass transfer by disrupting large droplet formation.
Plate Columns: Excellent for effective mass transfer with sieve plates.
Mechanically Agitated Columns
Agitation improves extraction under conditions of high viscosity or interfacial tension, ensuring efficient extraction.
Numerous types are characterized, including:
Scheibel column: Two-phase system with interspersed baffles.
Rotating-disk contactors: Widely utilized with controlled agitation.
Design Considerations in Liquid–Liquid Extraction
Flow rates, phase densities, viscosity, and pressure affect equipment sizing and design, emphasizing laboratory-scale data for initial models.
Extraction processes require careful assessment of these varied parameters to ensure optimal performances.
§8.3: Hunter-Nash Graphical Equilibrium-Stage Method
Procedures for calculating extraction stages utilize triangular diagrams for ease of analysis, accommodating scenarios with varying solute concentrations.
The method maps out the composition flow through stages:
Defines material balances for each extraction phase, allowing for determination of solvent compositions needed for efficient phases.
Calculations consider a range of equilibria and are adjusted depending on the feed components' concentrations.
Example Calculations
Determining the number of equilibrium stages needed for structured extraction approaches.
Resolving the maximum and minimum solvent-to-feed ratios to prevent excessive phase mixing or inefficiencies.
Practical Implications and Regulatory Considerations
Solvent selection is crucial and should align with environmental standards ensuring minimal toxicity.
Proper equipment handling and safety procedures must be in place throughout the extraction process.
Conclusion
Curriculum emphasizes the technical considerations in extraction processes, from equipment selection through detailed computational methodologies, highlighting both theoretical and practical ramifications in modern bioprocessing.