FOO D, IDEN TITY, AND CULTURE
Food, Identity, and Culture
Introduction to Cultural Ontologies
Humans are a diverse species with biological and physiological variations.
To understand these differences, people have created cultural ontologies or taxonomies—systems of classification and evaluation.
Key areas of variation explored in this chapter are kinship, gender, race, and ethnicity.
These categories offer insights into power dynamics, access to resources, and social relations.
They form crucial parts of social identities, shaping how individuals perceive the world and how they are perceived by others.
Discussions are not just about defining these terms but understanding the power and privilege they carry.
Food serves as a critical framework for understanding these classification systems and provides evidence of their impact on daily life.
Anthropologist Audrey Richards (1932) highlighted food's profound influence on social groupings and activities.
Food and beverages are coded with messages about identity, origin, and gender.
Food can foster ties and belonging or reinforce divisions and designate outsiders.
Kinship and Commensality
Humans are social beings, and families are primary agents of socialization.
Families provide basic needs (food, clothing, shelter) and nurture individuals.
A family is defined as a group related by:
Ancestry or "blood" (consanguine)
Marriage (affine)
Family members can include parents, stepparents, children, stepchildren, siblings, grandparents, grandchildren, uncles, aunts, nephews, nieces, cousins, spouses, and in-laws.
Nuclear family: Composed of parents and their children (possibly stepparents and stepchildren), common in Western societies.
Extended family: Grandparents, parents, and children often share a home in many non-Western cultures.
Fictive kin: Individuals without consanguinal or affinal ties but who are important to the family (e.g., a family friend like an uncle).
Anthropologists study kinship to understand how relationships form and persist, recognizing their essential role in human survival by establishing networks for support and access to necessities.
Kinship is socially constructed, meaning it is learned and varies culturally, reflecting cultural values.
Commensality: The act of eating and sharing food together, which is crucial for strengthening social bonds and creating unity, especially during holidays and celebrations.
Activity: Cooking Stone Soup
Concept: Illustrates commensality through an old folktale where travelers encourage villagers to contribute to a communal soup, turning individual reluctance into shared bounty.
Process: A cleaned stone is placed in a pot with water, and villagers are invited to add garnishes and vegetables, culminating in a shared meal.
Instructor's Note: This activity emphasizes group effort and contributions, can be a homework assignment, and recommends a meatless version for sanitary and cultural reasons.
Discussion Questions:
Explain how the story illustrates commensality.
What ingredients were featured, where did they come from, and what stories do they tell?
Who contributed and who dined from the communal pot, and what does this suggest about social networks?
Idealization and Complexities of Family Commensality
Idealized Vision: Popular culture, such as Norman Rockwell's 1943 painting "Freedom from Want," romanticizes family meals with extended kin, fine china, and a matriarch serving a perfect turkey.
This ideal is parodied in shows like "Modern Family" and "The Simpsons" and recreated with various characters.
This pervasive image reflects an aspirational fantasy rather than everyday reality.
Societal Value: Family dinners are championed as thej