Comprehensive Study Notes on Unconscionable Conduct and Unfair Contract Terms in Commercial Law

Administrative Notes & Course Information

  • Course evaluation and student feedback forms are available online for a duration of 10 days10\text{ days} for students to submit course feedback.
  • The upcoming lecture schedule involves completing specific law under the Fair Trading Act followed by revision using problem scenarios.
  • Course examination summary permissions permit students a maximum of 4 sides4\text{ sides} (equivalent to 2 sheets2\text{ sheets} of A4 paper, front and back).

Statutory Prohibition on Unconscionable Conduct (Fair Trading Act)

  • Section 7 of the Fair Trading Act prohibits a person in trade from engaging in conduct that is unconscionable.
    • The prohibition applies regardless of whether there is an established system or pattern of unconscionable conduct.
    • The prohibition applies regardless of whether a specific individual is identified as disadvantaged.
    • The prohibition applies regardless of whether a contract is actually entered into.
    • Section 7(3) explicitly provides that the statutory prohibition is not limited by any rule of law or equity relating to unconscionable conduct.
  • Section 8 of the Fair Trading Act outlines the matters to which the court may have regard when determining unconscionable conduct:
    • Section 8(1) General Matters: Relates to relative bargaining powers, the extent to which parties acted in good faith, and whether parties were able to understand the documents.
    • Section 8(2) Contractual Circumstances: Relates to the circumstances under which a contract was entered into, whether a party was induced to enter into it, and whether a party was able to negotiate their own terms.

Legislative Reform & Background

  • Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment (MBIE) Law Reform Process:
    • MBIE issued a discussion document noting that existing prohibitions (such as misleading or deceptive conduct) do not cover all unfair commercial behavior, making it difficult to fit certain unfair practices into established statutory frameworks.
    • MBIE evaluated three options for statutory reform:
    • Option 1: Prohibit unconscionable conduct.
    • Option 2: Prohibit oppressive conduct.
    • Option 3: Prohibit unfair practices.
    • MBIE favored Option 2 (prohibiting oppressive conduct) because a similar standard already exists under consumer credit law in the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act (CCCFA), which gives courts the power to reopen oppressive credit contracts based on established New Zealand case law.
    • Other submitters, including the Commerce Commission, favored Option 1 (prohibiting unconscionable conduct) to align New Zealand law with Australian Consumer Law and leverage Australian case law precedents.
    • Option 3 (prohibiting unfair practices) was rejected due to concerns over uncertainty, despite being modeled on European commercial law regimes.
  • Australian Legislative Developments:
    • Following regulator advocacy, the Australian Government conducted consultations and decided in October 2024 to introduce statutory legislation prohibiting general unfair trading practices.
    • Australian legislation prohibiting unfair trading practices takes full effect in the year 20272027

Equitable Doctrine of Unconscionable Bargain

  • The equitable doctrine allows courts to set aside a contract where a defendant's conduct is so unconscionable that upholding the bargain is contrary to equity.
  • Three essential elements required to invoke the equitable doctrine of unconscionable bargain:
    • The weaker party must suffer from a qualifying disability or disadvantage (e.g., advanced age, infirmity, or illiteracy/language barriers in English).
    • The stronger party must have actual or constructive knowledge of that disability or disadvantage.
    • The stronger party must take unconscionable advantage of that disability or disadvantage to secure the benefit of the bargain.
  • Exemplary New Zealand Equitable Cases:
    • Willis v Thompson:
    • Involved the transfer of investments for no consideration to a caregiver of a terminally ill patient during the final weeks of the patient's life.
    • The patient's son sought to set aside the transaction following the patient's death.
    • The court found the patient suffered from a special disadvantage due to being frail and elderly.
    • The court ruled the caregiver unconscionably took advantage of the disability by either actively extortionate behavior or passively accepting a benefit when she had an obligation in good conscience to decline it absent full and independent advice.
    • Centimeters v PP:
    • Involved an emotionally and financially vulnerable plaintiff with diagnosed mental illness who entered into a 1-year1\text{-year} relationship with the defendant.
    • The plaintiff paid substantial sums of money to the defendant purportedly for business ventures, later suing for compensation.
    • The court granted compensation because the plaintiff's diagnosed mental illness impaired her rational decision-making in her own self-interest, the defendant knew of this special disadvantage, and he exploited it to his personal financial gain.
  • Interplay Between Equity and Section 7:
    • Statutory unconscionability rests upon equitable principles, but section 7(3) dictates that statutory unconscionability is broader and not restricted by equitable prerequisites.
    • Courts require evidence that conduct was deliberate, serious, and involved clearly unfair or unreasonable commercial behavior evaluated against a normative standard of conscience infused with community values.

Australian Jurisprudence on Statutory Unconscionability

  • Lux Distributors (20132013):
    • Australian regulator brought action after sales representatives cold-called elderly homeowners offering "free maintenance checks" on vacuum cleaners.
    • Representatives used access to homes to perform maintenance and then produce a new vacuum cleaner from their vehicles to conduct comparative efficiency tests and aggressively push sales.
    • The court held the conduct was unconscionable, defining unconscionability as conduct against conscience evaluated against commercial honesty, fairness, and freedom from deception.
  • Pacheco:
    • Involved a challenge to ANZ Bank charging certain bank fees.
    • Although the claim failed, the court held that unconscionability must be given its ordinary meaning—acting not in good conscience, or conduct irreconcilable with what is right or reasonable—and warned against fixed rules or deductive reasoning.
  • Cobalt (20192019):
    • High Court of Australia decision regarding a storekeeper in a remote Australian region offering a credit system ("book up") to 117117 Aboriginal customers.
    • Customers handed over debit cards and PIN numbers; the storekeeper withdrew funds directly from customer bank accounts on payday to satisfy store debts and supply goods.
    • The High Court split 4 to 34\text{ to }3, holding by majority that the conduct was not unconscionable because the system was used in good faith, without dishonesty, was widely accepted in the community, and did not exploit the customers' lack of financial acumen.
    • Justice Edelman dissented, arguing that statutory unconscionability was enacted specifically to lower the threshold below equity standards, and that imposing harsh terms on vulnerable consumers in isolated areas who had no alternative credit options was unconscionable.
  • JCO:
    • Court confirmed that evaluating statutory unconscionability requires a single correct answer reached through reasoned evaluation of statutory norms, structural context, fairness, equality, lack of understanding, and fair dealing.
  • Quantum (Quantum Housing):
    • Demonstrates that statutory unconscionability does not require a pre-existing vulnerability, disability, or disadvantage.
    • Quantum Housing systematically misused its superior bargaining position to dishonestly mislead investors, extract undisclosed financial benefits, and impose unjustified requirements.
  • Smart Corporation (20212021):
    • Action against a 4WD vehicle rental firm that targeted customers who returned hired vehicles.
    • Example Case of Mr. Hitchcock: Hired a 4WD vehicle, paying a 1,600 NZD1,600\,\text{NZD} rental fee and a 5,000 NZD5,000\,\text{NZD} security bond (bonds typically ranged between 1,500 NZD1,500\,\text{NZD} and 5,000 NZD5,000\,\text{NZD}). Drove 1,400 km1,400\,\text{km} in Western Australia and returned the vehicle with no issues noted at drop-off.
    • Company later sent intimidating emails under the fictitious staff persona "Christine Burgess," claiming GPS data showed 299 speeding violations299\text{ speeding violations}, suspended differential damage, and severe wear, subsequently refusing refunds and retaining the 5,000 NZD5,000\,\text{NZD} bond.
    • The court found the conduct unconscionable, citing bad faith, false allegations, deceptive tactics, and unjustified legal threats; 30 other customers30\text{ other customers} suffered identical treatment.

New Zealand Case Law on Unconscionable Conduct

  • TV Shop (Brand Developers Limited) — December 20252025:
    • Commerce Commission filed section 7 charges for high-pressure sales of expensive products to vulnerable consumers on unaffordable, long-term payment plans combined with aggressive debt collection and repossession tactics.
    • Parallel litigation under sections 10 and 13 (misleading conduct) resulted in a District Court fine of 1,100,000 NZD1,100,000\,\text{NZD} against TV Shop for manipulating online business reviews and misrepresenting consumer rights under the Consumer Guarantees Act.
  • Tech Vault Enterprises:
    • Ordered to pay a 60,000 NZD60,000\,\text{NZD} fine under section 7 for making repeated, unsolicited sales calls targeting an elderly woman suffering from dementia, which the court categorized as egregious conduct against a vulnerable consumer.

Unfair Contract Terms (UCT) Framework

  • Legislative Basis:
    • Sections 26A–E and 46H–M of the Fair Trading Act, enacted in March 20152015.
    • Modeled on Australian Consumer Law (20102010) and UK Unfair Contract Terms legislation (19771977).
  • Extensions of Scope:
    • 20192019 Expansion: Applied UCT provisions to small trade contracts.
    • Grocery Supply Contracts Expansion: Applied specific UCT rules to grocery contracts between regulated retailers and suppliers.
  • Jurisdictional Enforcement Mechanism:
    • Unlike Australian law, New Zealand consumers and small businesses cannot directly initiate court actions to declare a term unfair.
    • All consumer complaints must be submitted to the Commerce Commission. Only the Commerce Commission can apply to the court for an official declaration that a term is unfair.
    • Exception: Grocery suppliers can directly apply to the High Court for an unfair term declaration under standard form grocery supply contracts.

Standard Form Contracts & Excluded Terms

  • Standard Form Contract Definition (Section 46J):
    • A contract where terms have not been subject to effective negotiation between parties.
    • Statutory evaluation factors: Imbalance in bargaining power, terms drafted prior to discussion, "take-it-or-leave-it" presentation, and lack of opportunity to negotiate details.
    • Onus of Proof: If a party alleges a contract is standard form, the opposing party bears the legal burden of proving that it is not.
  • Excluded Terms (Section 46K):
    • Terms that define the main subject matter of the contract.
    • Terms setting the upfront price payable (including contingent amounts payable upon specified events that form part of the consideration, excluding contractual penalties).
    • Terms expressly permitted by another statutory enactment.

Statutory Test for Unfairness (Section 46L)

  • A term in a standard form contract is declared unfair if it meets three cumulative requirements:
    • It causes a significant imbalance in the parties' rights and obligations under the contract.
    • It is not reasonably necessary to protect the legitimate interests of the party advantaged by the term.
    • It would cause financial or non-financial detriment to a party if relied upon or applied.
  • Assessment Factors:
    • Courts must evaluate the transparency of the term and the balance of the contract taken as a whole (e.g., a unilateral variation clause might be permissible if balanced by an absolute right for the consumer to exit without penalty).

Specific Categories of Potentially Unfair Terms (Section 46M)

  • Section 46M(a): Terms permitting one party (but not the other) to avoid or limit contract performance (e.g., delivery clauses permitting a firm to unilaterally store goods at a customer's expense if no one is present at delivery).
  • Section 46M(b): Terms permitting one party (but not the other) to terminate the contract (e.g., clauses barring customer cancellation while allowing the seller to cancel orders at will subject to an administrative deduction).
  • Section 46M(c): Terms penalizing one party (but not the other) for breach or termination (e.g., charging reconnection fees after service suspensions for unpaid balances).
  • Section 46M(d): Terms permitting one party (but not the other) to vary contractual terms (e.g., clause stating the supplier may vary any term at any time in writing).
  • Section 46M(e): Terms permitting one party to unilaterally renew or non-renew (e.g., automatic conversion from free trials to recurring paid monthly subscriptions unless canceled by the user).
  • Section 46M(f): Terms permitting price variations without a corresponding customer right to terminate (e.g., passing on extra loading or time costs due to inaccurate initial quotes).
  • Section 46M(g): Terms permitting unilateral variation of goods or services characteristics (e.g., reservation of total discretion over carriage route, method, or delivery timing).
  • Section 46M(h): Terms permitting one party unilaterally to determine whether a contract has been breached or to interpret its meaning.
  • Section 46M(i): Terms limiting vicarious liability for agents or representatives (e.g., gym terms declaring all facility usage is at member's sole risk and excluding liability for staff directions).
  • Section 46M(j): Terms permitting assignment of the contract to the detriment of the other party without consent (e.g., assignment of debt collection rights to a third-party contractor).
  • Section 46M(k): Terms limiting a party's right to sue (e.g., forcing overseas dispute jurisdiction, such as requiring New Zealand consumers to litigate exclusively in the Australian Capital Territory or Switzerland).
  • Section 46M(l): Terms limiting admissible evidence in legal proceedings (e.g., entire agreement clauses overriding prior oral or written representations).
  • Section 46M(m): Terms imposing an evidential burden on one party (e.g., clauses barring seller liability for lost/delayed freight unless the customer proves the goods were delivered to the firm).
  • Terms Outside Section 46M: Non-listed terms can still be declared unfair under Section 46L (Spreadex v Cochrane, where a term making account holders automatically liable for unauthorized trades executed using their password was held unfair).

Empirical Studies on Contractual Compliance

  • Post-2015 Standard Form Contract Review:
    • An initial University of Auckland study analyzed standard form terms across 119 businesses119\text{ businesses} (including parking facilities, pizza delivery outlets, and telecommunications firms).
    • A follow-up study commissioned by MBIE 3 years3\text{ years} later evaluated the exact same 119 contracts119\text{ contracts} to measure compliance.
    • Results:
    • 40 contracts40\text{ contracts} showed zero structural changes.
    • 79 contracts79\text{ contracts} showed alterations, but many introduced new or additional unfair terms.
    • 100%100\% of all reviewed contracts continued to contain terms deemed potentially unfair under section 46M.

New Zealand Case Law & Enforcement Actions on Unfair Contract Terms

  • Viagogo:
    • Viagogo (ticket reseller) included terms requiring all consumer disputes to be litigated exclusively in Geneva, Switzerland under Swiss law.
    • High Court held the clause caused a substantial imbalance because Viagogo could sue consumers in their home jurisdiction or Geneva, whereas consumers could only sue in Geneva, effectively denying dispute tribunal access.
  • Home Direct:
    • Home Direct operated mobile payment plans using a "Lifestyle Account" voucher system.
    • Customers made continuous direct debit payments; credit balances could only be spent on Home Direct goods and were forfeited if unused.
    • 644,000 NZD644,000\,\text{NZD} was forfeited by over 14,000 customers14,000\text{ customers}, with individual credit balances reaching up to 4,500 NZD4,500\,\text{NZD}.
    • High Court declared the forfeiture terms unfair due to lack of transparency, lack of counterbalancing benefits, and charging for unrendered services.
  • Ace Marketing:
    • Targeted low socioeconomic buyers with high prices on deferred payment terms.
    • A single missed payment resulted in product delivery being delayed by up to 7 weeks7\text{ weeks}.
    • Court held terms were non-transparent, unbalanced, and not reasonably necessary to protect commercial interests.
  • Bachcare (April 20232023):
    • Accommodation booking platform retained 100%100\% of customer booking fees and service charges if cancellation occurred due to severe weather events outside customer control.
    • Terms declared unfair under section 46L and ordered changed.
  • Vector:
    • Commerce Commission issued formal compliance advice regarding standard electricity connection contracts.
    • Vector agreed to amend/remove terms governing upfront fees, unilateral variation powers, and liability exclusions.

Standard Form Contracts Classification Summary

  • Standard Form Consumer Contracts:
    • Parties: Supplier and Consumer (goods/services ordinarily acquired for personal, domestic, or household use).
    • Direct Court Right: None (Enforcement exclusive to Commerce Commission).
  • Standard Form Small Trade Contracts:
    • Parties: Both parties in trade (B2B), non-consumer contract.
    • Monetary Cap: Annual trading value does not exceed 250,000 NZD250,000\,\text{NZD} at contract inception.
    • Direct Court Right: None (Enforcement exclusive to Commerce Commission).
  • Standard Form Grocery Supply Contracts:
    • Parties: Regulated grocery retailer (e.g., Foodstuffs, Woolworths) and a supplier.
    • Monetary Cap: Annual trading relationship value does not exceed 1,000,000 NZD1,000,000\,\text{NZD} at contract inception.
    • Direct Court Right: Yes (Grocery suppliers possess direct statutory right to apply to court for unfair term declarations).

Specific Contractual Applications & Questions

  • Digital Licensing Contracts (Video Game Digital Storefronts):
    • Example: Consumers purchase a digital video game on a storefront for 120 NZD120\,\text{NZD} under standard form terms establishing that the fee purchases a revocable license rather than property ownership.
    • If a company revokes the license or removes the title from libraries after 2 years2\text{ years} due to lack of market traction, the legality under UCT depends on evaluating whether the termination clause is non-transparent, creates a significant imbalance, or is counterbalanced by rights of access.