St. Augustine_C. Stephen Evans - A History otmodernism-IVP Academic (2018)

Gregory of Nyssa

  • Combined Aristotelian knowledge with Neoplatonic metaphysic.

  • Human knowledge emerges from sense experience.

  • God's essence cannot be comprehended through human intellect or senses.

  • We can acknowledge God's existence and some divine actions but rely on mystical contemplation for true knowledge.

  • Via Negativa (Way of Negation): Describes God without positive language, emphasizing the limits of human comprehension.

  • Our objective is unity with God, attainable only through divine grace.

Augustine of Hippo

  • Born in Tagaste, North Africa (354-430) to a pagan father and a Christian mother, Monica.

  • Monica greatly influenced Augustine's faith journey, dying content that her son converted to Christianity.

  • His studies in Carthage ignited a passion for philosophy through Cicero's works.

  • Initially adhered to Manichaeism, a dualistic belief system proposing competing divine beings.

    • Manichaeism explained evil's existence through two principles, one good and one evil, relying solely on reason.

  • Ultimately disillusioned with Manichaeism's inability to resolve moral struggles after nine years.

  • Briefly engaged with Skepticism before succumbing to a life of license and fathering a child.

Challenges in Faith

  • Chastity imposed by Christianity posed significant hurdles for Augustine’s faith commitment.

  • In Confessions, he describes a divided heart: wishing for chastity but not ready to commit.

  • In Milan, impressed by Bishop Ambrose’s sermons, particularly his Neoplatonic integration with Christianity and allegorical interpretations.

  • Ambrose helped Augustine perceive Christianity's answers to questions posed by Manicheism.

  • Influenced by Platonic philosophers (likely Plotinus and Porphyry) as he returned to Christianity.

Conversion Narrative

  • Augustinian conversion described in Confessions, where he hears a child's voice urging him to read the Scriptures.

  • Interpreting it as divine command, he reads Paul's epistle to the Romans (13:13-14).

  • This brings Augustine immense conviction regarding the truth of Christianity and its moral demands.

  • Ultimately ordained as a priest and later bishop in Hippo while producing prolific theological writings.

  • Key works include Confessions, City of God, and On the Trinity.

Epistemology and Response to Skepticism

  • Augustine's approach blurs the lines between philosophy and theology.

  • Works addressing Skepticism: De beata vita (On the Good Life) and Contra academicos (Against the Skeptics).

  • Emphasizes the significance of valuing knowledge in the pursuit of truth.

  • Argues true seekers of knowledge must possess the desire to find, contrasting with the argument of knowing without intention.

  • Famous phrase: "Believe in order to understand."

  • Responds to Carneades' claim that humans can only attain probability rather than knowledge, asserting knowledge inherently comes with understanding.

Divine Illumination Theory

  • Proposes that knowledge of Universals is possible through divine illumination, contrasting with Platonic recollection.

  • Humans are seen as made in the image of God, allowing some understanding of divine truths.

  • Sense perception acknowledged as a tool for grasping these truths.

Metaphysical Framework

  • Critiques the dualism of Manichaeism and its influence on the concept of evil.

  • Defines evil not as a corresponding force to good but as privation (the absence of good).

  • Creation as a deliberate act of God, out of nothing (ex nihilo), not as a reshaping of preexistent matter.

  • Posits that matter is created by God, hence considered good, rejecting the inherent evil of physical existence.

  • God is transcendent yet immanent, reflecting divine nature in the created order.

Ethical Thought

  • Ethics are discussed holistically; Augustine does not fit neatly into any one category of modern ethical theory.

  • Shares an eudaimonistic perspective where happiness is rooted in a relationship with God.

  • Emphasizes the necessity for love of God as the foundation for all moral actions, encapsulated in the idea: "Love and do what you will."

  • Critiques human love as disordered when prioritizing material over spiritual.

Pelagian Controversy

  • Engaged in dispute with Pelagius over the nature of original sin and human free will.

  • Defends the idea that post-Adam humans are naturally inclined to sin without divine grace.

  • Rejects human rationality as a basis for salvation, affirming that divine intervention is necessary.

  • Introduced concepts of predestination and the transmission of original sin, complicating the understanding of human nature.

Political and Historical Perspectives

  • Context of the declining Roman Empire and its impact on perception of Christianity.

  • In City of God, Augustine responds to critiques attributing Rome's fall to the rise of Christianity.

    • Describes a metanarrative of history’s purpose in God’s redemptive plan extending from creation to the eventual fulfillment.

  • Differentiates between the City of Man (earthly) and the City of God (heavenly), rooted in love for self versus love for God.

  • Although earthly systems are flawed, they are part of God’s overarching providence.

  • Advocates for justifiable warfare under specific moral conditions, beginning a dialogue on just war theory.

Significance of Augustine

  • Considered a pivotal figure bridging ancient philosophy and medieval thought.

  • Recognized as a saint and doctor of the church, significantly influencing both Catholic and Protestant traditions.

  • Prominent in discussions of original sin, love, ethics, and the relationship between faith and reason.

  • Remains relevant in contemporary philosophical debates, with a lasting fusion of Christian thought and Platonic philosophy.