Marshall

Sexual Medicine, Sexual Bodies and the 'Pharmaceutical Imagination'

Abstract

  • Analyzes clinical research on sexual dysfunctions.

  • Explores the biomedical construction of sexual bodies.

  • Highlights increased search for biomedical explanations and solutions after Viagra's success.

  • Discusses shifts in narratives surrounding sexual problems.

  • Argues for a 'pharmaceutical imagination' that frames narratives about sexual dysfunctions.

  • Drugs like PDE-5 inhibitors, hormones, and SSRIs are highlighted as actants in sexual health discourse.

Introduction: The 'Nature of the Body'

  • Quote by Hippocrates at the entrance of Indiana’s medical school:

    • "The nature of the body is the beginning of medical science."

  • Implies a common understanding of science leading to medical advancements.

  • Suggests that medical discourses construct rather than discover truths about the body.

  • Focus on the role of drugs in constructing (hetero)sexual bodies post-Viagra.

  • Critique of the 'pharmaceutical imagination' guiding sexual medicine.

Medicalization and the Pharmaceutical Imagination

  • Medicalization has a political history with early critiques viewing it as a force imposed by professionals.

  • Recent approaches highlight the complexity of medicalization, focusing on context and agency.

  • Peter Conrad posits that medicalization is now driven by commercial interests.

  • Shift from clinical to biomedicalization emphasizes transformation of bodies.

  • The concept of 'pharmaceutical imagination' analyzes the production of knowledge about sexual function and bodies.

  • Asserts that the pharmaceutical narrative often overlooks the cultural context of biological issues.

Before and After Viagra: The Shift in Perspectives

  • Review of historical changes in the perception of erectile dysfunction (previously seen as psychogenic).

  • Introduction of Viagra redefined the understanding of impotence (now known as erectile dysfunction).

  • Highlights a trend towards disease specificity shaped by pharmacological treatments.

  • Viagra's success has led to broader disease models that now include younger men.

  • Female sexual dysfunction is framed differently, with efforts to connect it to logical medical treatments.

Old Drugs, New Diseases

  • The pharmaceutical market for sexual dysfunction remains significant.

  • Off-label prescribing allows for new definitions of existing drugs as treatments for various sexual disorders.

  • Testosterone and SSRIs play major roles in this market expansion.

  • Focus on 'androgen deficiency in the aging male' (ADAM) and 'female androgen insufficiency syndrome' (FAIS) as new disease categories.

  • Off-label usage of testosterone prescriptions is growing despite disagreements on normal levels.

Functional/Dysfunctional Paradigm Shift

  • Contrasts previous notions of normal/abnormal with functional/dysfunctional.

  • This shift links individuals to new standards of sexual function and encourages self-monitoring.

  • Pharmaceutical interventions are positioned as solutions to create 'functional' bodies.

  • Emphasizes the necessity for diagnostics and re-evaluation in light of drug effects.

Conclusion

  • The 'pharmaceutical imagination' frames understanding of sexual problems as biochemical in nature.

  • Explores how narratives constructed around drugs and sexual dysfunctions interact to reshape individual experiences of sexuality.

  • Highlights feminist critiques of how this reduces diverse sexual experiences within biomedical contexts.

  • Calls for continued critical examination of the interplay of drugs and the biomedicalization of sexuality to ensure more nuanced understandings.