The Death of the Author
The Death of the Author by Roland Barthes
Introduction
- Balzac's Sarrasine example of a sentence with multiple possible speakers: the hero, Balzac (the man), Balzac (the author), universal wisdom, or romantic psychology.
- It's impossible to know the true speaker because all writing is a confluence of voices.
- Literature creates a voice without a specific origin, a neuter space where identity is lost, including the author's.
- Once a story is told for its own sake, separate from direct action on reality, the author's voice loses its origin, and writing commences.
The Author as a Modern Construct
- In primitive societies, narratives are delivered by mediators (shamans, speakers) admired for their skill, not personal genius.
- The author is a modern concept arising from English empiricism, French rationalism, the Reformation, and the rise of the individual.
- Positivism and capitalist ideology have further emphasized the author's person.
- The author dominates literary history, biographies, interviews, and the personal connections writers make between their lives and works.
- Criticism often explains works through the author's personal failings (e.g., Baudelaire's work as his failure, Van Gogh's as his madness).
Challenging the Author's Authority
- Some writers have attempted to subvert the author's role.
- Mallarmé: Language should replace the author; language speaks, not the person. Writing accesses a pre-existing impersonality.
- Valéry: Questioned and mocked the Author, emphasized the linguistic, almost random, nature of writing, and championed the verbal condition of literature.
- Proust: Blurred the lines between the writer and characters.
- The narrator isn't who saw, felt, or writes, but who will write. His life became a work modeled after his book.
- Example: Montesquiou is derived from Charlus, not the other way around.
- Surrealism: Sought direct subversion of codes through violating expected meanings and automatic/collective writing, which helped secularize the image of the Author.
Linguistics and the Deconstruction of the Author
- Linguistics provides an analytical tool for the destruction of the Author.
- Utterance is a void process that doesn't require a specific person.
- The author is merely the one who writes, like