Exhaustive Notes on Social Structure, Anomie, and Differential Association
Structural Causes of Deviance and Anomie
Root causes of crime and deviant behavior reside within the structure of society rather than in individual psychological or biological abnormalities.
Broader patterns of criminal behavior characterize specific groups of people due to the social strain experienced between culturally encouraged aspirations and a structural inability to attain them legitimately.
This structural barrier is defined as a blocked opportunity structure, wherein individuals face a disjuncture between culturally defined goals and the institutionalized means available to reach those goals.
A sociological perspective focuses on explanations for variations in the rates of deviant behavior across social groups, rather than the individual incidence of deviance.
Deviant behavior can be as psychologically normal as conformist behavior, functioning as a normal human response to specific social situations and structural pressures.
Two Core Elements of Social and Cultural Structures
Social and cultural structures consist of two analytically separable components that merge in concrete situations:
Culturally Defined Goals: These comprise the goals, purposes, and interests held out as legitimate objectives for all or diversely located members of a society. They are ordered in a hierarchy of value, involve varying degrees of sentiment, and form an aspirational frame of reference (the things "worth striving for"). They constitute a basic component of what Ralph Linton termed "designs for group living." Although some goals relate to biological drives, they are not determined by them.
Institutional Norms: These define, regulate, and control the acceptable modes and procedures for reaching cultural goals. Every social group couples its cultural objectives with regulatory norms rooted in institutions or mores. Regulatory norms are distinct from technical efficiency norms; many procedures that are technically efficient for an individual (such as force, fraud, or power) are prohibited within the institutional framework of permitted conduct.
The criterion for acceptable conduct is grounded in value-laden sentiments rather than technical efficiency. Group-efficient procedures are frequently disallowed due to these sentiments, as demonstrated by historical taboos on:
Vivisection.
Medical experimentation.
Sociological analysis of "sacred" norms.
The choice of expedients for striving toward cultural goals is strictly constrained by institutionalized norms.
Anomie and the Attenuation of Institutional Norms
Societies differ in the degree to which institutional controls, mores, and folkways are integrated with high-ranking cultural goals.
When a society places an exceptionally strong emphasis on specific success goals without a corresponding emphasis on institutional procedures, institutional rules become vitiated.
Under extreme imbalance, behavior becomes governed solely by technical expediency, where the primary consideration is identifying which available procedure is most effective in securing the culturally approved value.
The technically most effective procedure—whether culturally legitimate or illegitimate—is preferred over institutionally prescribed conduct.
The progressive attenuation of institutional norms results in social instability and the state of normlessness defined by Émile Durkheim as anomie.
Illustrative Microcosmic Examples:
Competitive Athletics: When the goal of victory is detached from institutional rules ("winning under the rules") and reduced purely to "winning the game," illegitimate but efficient means are prioritized. Examples include surreptitiously slugging an opposing star football player, a wrestler using illicit techniques to incapacitate an opponent, or university alumni covertly subsidizing talented athletes.
Games of Chance: Stress generated by a desire to win in poker is illegitimately relieved by dealing oneself four aces, or in solitaire by sagaciously shuffling the cards. Public delicts and subtle feelings of uneasiness demonstrate that rule-breakers are aware of the institutional rules they evade, but cultural exaggeration of the goal leads to the withdrawal of emotional support from those rules.
Contemporary American Culture and the American Dream
Contemporary American culture represents a polar type of social structure characterized by an extreme emphasis on monetary success goals without an equivalent emphasis on institutionalized means.
Money is consecrated as a value in itself, extending beyond its direct utility for consumption or power enhancement.
According to Georg Simmel, money is abstract and impersonal; regardless of whether it is acquired fraudulently or legitimately, it purchases the same goods and services.
In urban societies, social anonymity combined with the nature of money allows wealth—even wealth from unknown or dubious sources—to become purified over time, serving as a symbol of high status.
The American Dream sets no final stopping point for achievement; the measure of monetary success is indefinite and relative:
H. F. Clark found that at every income level, Americans consistently desire approximately more income, a standard that shifts upward as soon as it is achieved.
In high-income communities where annual six-figure salaries are common, individuals report intense social stress due to relative evaluation (e.g., a community member expressing distress over being socially snubbed for earning only \\$1,000 per week).
Agencies of Socialization and Goal Maintenance:
Family: Functions as a transmission belt for the values and goals of specific social classes or target reference classes.
School: Acts as the official agency for transmitting prevailing values, with urban school textbooks routinely asserting that education leads to intelligence, which leads to job and financial success.
Workplace: Continues the intensive disciplining required to maintain unfulfilled aspirations.
Culture enforces the continuous pursuit of success through ubiquitous slogans and precepts ("not to be a quitter", "there is no such word as 'fail'", and "not failure, but low aim, is crime").
Three Cultural Axioms of American Success
Contemporary American culture enjoins three explicit cultural axioms:
All individuals should strive for the same lofty goals, as these goals are open to everyone.
Present apparent failure is merely a temporary way-station to ultimate success.
Genuine failure consists solely in the lessening or complete withdrawal of ambition.
Psychological Paraphrase of the Axioms:
First axiom: Operates as a symbolic secondary reinforcement of incentive.
Second axiom: Curbs the threatened extinction of a response through an associated stimulus.
Third axiom: Increases motive-strength to evoke continued responses despite a persistent absence of reward.
Sociological Paraphrase of the Axioms:
First axiom: Deflects criticism away from the social structure and onto the self among individuals who lack equal access to opportunity.
Second axiom: Preserves the structure of social power by inducing individuals in lower social strata to identify with those at the top rather than with their peers.
Third axiom: Exerts pressure for continuous conformity to cultural dictates by threatening individuals who lower their ambitions with less than full membership in society.
Merton's Typology of Modes of Individual Adaptation
Individuals situated in different structural positions adapt to the strain between cultural goals and institutionalized means in five distinct ways.
Mode of Adaptation | Cultural Goals | Institutionalized Means |
|---|---|---|
I. Conformity | ||
II. Innovation | ||
III. Ritualism | ||
IV. Retreatism | ||
V. Rebellion |
(Note: signifies acceptance, signifies rejection, and signifies rejection of prevailing values and substitution of new values.)
I. Conformity
Accepts both culturally defined success goals ( ) and institutionalized means ( ).
Represents the most common and widely diffused adaptation in stable societies, ensuring societal continuity and stability.
II. Innovation
Accepts cultural success goals ( ) while rejecting institutionalized means ( ), utilizing institutionally proscribed but effective avenues to attain wealth and power.
Occurs when individuals assimilate the cultural emphasis on success without equal internalization of institutional norms.
Structural pressure toward innovation is highest in the lower social strata:
Occupational options in lower strata are largely restricted to manual labor and lower-level white-collar jobs.
Given the social stigmatization of manual labor across all classes and the lack of realistic opportunities for advancement, individuals face heavy structural pressure toward deviance.
Low income from unskilled labor cannot compete with the high income and power promised by organized crime, rackets, and vice.
III. Ritualism
Rejects or scales down lofty cultural success goals ( ) while compulsively abiding by institutionalized regulatory norms ( ).
Arises as a response to status anxiety and intense competitive pressure in a society where status depends on personal achievement; lowering aspirations permanently serves as a safety mechanism against frustration and defeat.
Common among lower-middle-class employees, frightened workers, and zealously conformist bureaucrats in public or private enterprises.
Characterized by cultural clichés: "I'm not sticking my neck out," "I'm playing safe," "I'm satisfied with what I've got," and "Don't aim high and you won't be disappointed."
IV. Retreatism
Rejects both cultural goals ( ) and institutionalized means ( ).
Represents the least common adaptation; individuals in this category are strictly in society but not of it, functioning as sociologically true aliens.
Includes adaptive behaviors seen in psychotics, autists, pariahs, outcasts, vagrants, vagabonds, tramps, chronic drunkards, and drug addicts.
Occurs when an individual experiences continued failure to reach goals through legitimate means, yet cannot utilize illegitimate means due to internalized moral prohibitions; defeatism and resignation produce escape mechanisms from societal requirements.
V. Rebellion
Rejects prevailing cultural goals and institutionalized means while substituting new goals and new means ( ).
Leads individuals outside the surrounding social structure to conceptualize and build a modified social structure.
Presupposes alienation from reigning goals and standards, viewing them as arbitrary constructs lacking legitimacy.
Organized rebellion movements aim to modify cultural standards of success to establish a direct correspondence between merit, effort, and reward.
Differential Association Theory
Edwin H. Sutherland and Donald R. Cressey reject explanations of crime and deviance that rely on individual biological/psychological pathology or general social pathology.
Criminal and deviant behavior is learned through the same basic processes as conventional behavior and reflects identical behavioral needs and values.
Learning occurs primarily within intimate personal groups (families and peer groups) through direct interaction and communication, rather than from frightening outsiders or impersonal mass media.
Individuals turn to deviance by watching others model criminal acts, acquiring technical skills to perform those acts, and internalizing rationalizations and neutralizations that justify the conduct.
Formal Propositions of Differential Association:
Criminal behavior is learned. It is not inherited biologically, nor is it invented independently by an untrained individual, just as mechanical inventions require prior training in mechanics.
Criminal behavior is learned in interaction with other persons in a process of communication. This process includes both direct verbal communication and the "communication of gestures."
The principal part of the learning of criminal behavior occurs within intimate personal groups. Impersonal agencies of communication, such as movies and newspapers, play a relatively unimportant role in the genesis of criminal behavior.