10.1

The Divisive Politics of Slavery

/

Overview of Slavery in U.S. Society

  • Issue of slavery remains divisive, grappling with fairness, equality, race, and class issues.

  • Notable events:

    • Wilmot Proviso, a significant political challenge.

    • Rising tensions leading to secession in the early 1850s.

Key Events and Figures

  • Compromise of 1850: Attempt to balance interests of free and slave states.

  • Popular Sovereignty: Concept introduced to address territorial status, allowing residents to decide on the legality of slavery.

  • Stephen A. Douglas: A key proponent of the compromise.

  • Millard Fillmore: The President who supported the Compromise after Taylor's death.

John C. Calhoun: A Prominent Advocate for the South

  • Calhoun's Illness: Missing four months of debate due to health; his address delivered through Senator James M. Mason.

  • Personal Voice: "I have, Senators, believed from the first that the agitation of the subject of slavery… end in disunion… the Union is in danger."

  • Calhoun's Views:

    • Claimed the North must provide the South with “justice, simple justice.”

    • Advocated for slavery's allowance in territories acquired from the Mexican War.

    • Warned of secession if demands were unmet.

Historical Context of Calhoun's Influence
  • Calhoun was Vice President under both John Quincy Adams and Andrew Jackson.

  • His last words: "The South. The poor South."

  • Signified the deepening political crisis spurred by slavery debates.

Regional Differences: North vs. South

Economic and Social Structures
  • North:

    • Rapid industrialization; factories produced textiles, sewing machines, and more.

    • Development of extensive railroad systems (~20,000 miles in the 1850s).

    • Urbanization of small towns into cities (e.g., Chicago).

    • Vast immigration from Europe contributed to labor force with anti-slavery sentiments.

    • Major fears regarding competition between free and slave labor, maintaining status of white workers.

  • South:

    • Predominantly rural; economy reliant on cotton and other staple crops.

    • Approximately one-third of the U.S. population but under 10% of manufactured goods produced.

    • Transport mainly via rivers, limited immigrant settlement; African Americans, whether enslaved or free, filled most labor roles.

    • Immigrants showed significant opposition to slavery, advocating for rights.

Social Tensions Due to Slavery
  • In some Southern states, African Americans outnumbered white populations (e.g., Mississippi, Louisiana, South Carolina).

  • Fears among Southern whites of societal upheaval if slavery was challenged; Calhoun warned against the disastrous consequences of abolition.

  • Contrasting List: The North focused on industrial growth while the South relied on agricultural output and slavery.

Architectural Influence: Greek Revival

  • Greek Revival Architecture:

    • Became widespread in the U.S. (1825-1860).

    • Characterized by columns resembling ancient Greek temples.

    • Adaptations in the South for climate suitability (high porches for cooling).

The Wilmot Proviso

  • Proposed by David Wilmot on August 8, 1846, aimed at preventing slavery in territories acquired from Mexico.

  • Stipulations of the Proviso:

    • Closed territories of California, Utah, and New Mexico to slavery permanently.

  • The Proviso divided Congress along regional lines, with Northerners supporting it due to concerns over slave labor.

  • Southern opposition, viewing slaves as property protected by constitutional rights.

Congressional Reactions
  • House approved the Proviso but the Senate rejected it.

  • Alexander H. Stephens of Georgia predicted dire political turmoil should the Proviso pass.

California's Statehood and its Ramifications

  • Population surge from the Gold Rush allowed California to skip the territorial phase and apply directly for statehood.

  • California's constitution forbidding slavery raised alarms among Southerners, who believed it should be a slave state based on its geographical location.

  • General Zachary Taylor's support for California as a free state angered many in the South; fears grew over losing power in Congress.

The Senate Debates and Compromise of 1850

  • The debates were heated; tensions escalated over statehood for California and conflicting claims between Texas and New Mexico.

  • Henry Clay proposed a compromise containing elements for both the North (California as a free state) and the South (stricter fugitive slave laws).

Terms of the Compromise
  • Admittance of California as a free state.

  • New fugitive slave law proposed, appeasing southern interests.

  • Popular sovereignty for New Mexico and Utah territories regarding slavery.

  • Federal payment to Texas for relinquishing claims to parts of New Mexico.

Responses to the Compromise

  • Calhoun vs. Webster:

    • Calhoun presented a Southern perspective defending slavery.

    • Webster urged for national unity and compromise, highlighting the dangers of secession.

  • Clay's speech focused on the potential for devastating conflict and implored both sides to seek unity.

Legislative Process of the Compromise

  • Though rejected initially in July, Douglas's strategy of unbundling resolutions allowed the individual measures to be reconsidered.

  • The death of President Taylor facilitated support for the compromise from his successor, Fillmore.

  • Southern leaders eventually embraced compromise, approving individual proposals that were perceived as beneficial.

Conclusion

  • The Compromise of 1850 was eventually passed into law, viewed as a temporary solution to the slavery crisis.

  • However, tensions regarding the enforcement of the new fugitive slave law posed further complications, indicating that the resolution may only be fleeting.

Key Players and Historical Constituents

  • Stephen A. Douglas: Known as the "Little Giant"; pivotal in passage of the Compromise of 1850; became prominent due to his oratorial skills and political maneuvers.