Study Notes on Oligopoly and Game Theory

Chapter 15: Oligopoly and Game Theory

Chapter Outline

  • Cartels

  • The Prisoner's Dilemma

  • Oligopolies

  • When Are Cartels and Oligopolies Most Successful?

  • Government Policy Toward Cartels and Oligopolies

  • Business Strategy and Changing the Game

  • Takeaway

  • Appendix: Nash Equilibrium

Introduction to Oligopoly and Game Theory

  • As oil prices neared a historic high in July 1979, President Jimmy Carter stated, “Our neck is stretched over the fence and OPEC has a knife.” This highlights OPEC's power to control oil prices.

  • OPEC (Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries): A cartel of suppliers that reduce supply, raise prices, and increase profits, acting similarly to a monopolist.

Key Points about Cartels and Oligopolies
  • Cartels: A group of suppliers aiming to act as a monopoly.

  • Oligopolies are markets dominated by a small number of firms, leading to higher prices than in highly competitive markets.

  • Game theory is introduced as a tool for analyzing strategic decision-making in interactive situations.

  • Strategic decision making: Decision-making in scenarios where the outcome depends on the choices of others.

Analyzing Cartels

OPEC Oil Prices
  • Analyzed fluctuations in oil prices from 1960 to 2016, highlighting a significant increase between 1970 and 1974 due to OPEC's production cuts.
      - Price Change Example: Oil price rose from 77 per barrel to almost 3838 per barrel due to OPEC actions.

  • Market Dynamics:
      - Competitive market vs monopolistic control illustrated in Figure 15.2, showcasing how cartels can attempt to decrease outputs and increase prices akin to monopolists.
      - Profit Maximization: A cartel seeks to maximize joint profits by coordinating reduced output.

  • Challenges for Cartels: Cartels face difficulties maintaining price controls because of:
      1. Cheating: Members of the cartel may not adhere to agreed-upon production limits to maximize individual profits.
      2. New Entrants: New competitors may enter the market when prices rise.
      3. Government Regulation: Legal actions and antitrust policies impact cartel stability.

Fate of Cartels
  • OPEC's failure to maintain high prices led to a drop in oil prices by 1986 (falling from 7575 per barrel to 2020 and sometimes as low as 1010 per barrel).
      - Incentive Structures: Unlike monopolists, cartel members benefit from present exceeding promised production, leading to inevitable cheating within the cartel.

  • Cheating Incentives: Illustrated in a comparison with monopolists and analyzed through Figures and payoff tables (Figure 15.3).

The Prisoner's Dilemma

  • The Prisoner's Dilemma: A prominent example of how self-interest can lead to suboptimal outcomes for all parties involved.

  • Explains why cooperation in cartels often fails and highlights the need for strategic interaction.

  • Example: Fish stock depletion due to the overfishing dilemma among nations highlights the collective negative outcome from competitive self-interest.

Repeated Interaction in the Prisoner's Dilemma

  • Repeated Engagement: Cooperation becomes more feasible with repeated interactions, drawing on Elinor Ostrom's studies showing successful management of common resources.

  • Tacit Collusion: Firms may engage in tacit collusion without explicit agreements, adapting strategies based on competitive observations (e.g., asphalt industry behavior).

Institutional Impacts on Cartels and Oligopolies

Barriers to Entry
  • Barriers to entry promote cartel formation and stability, with factors such as:
      - Control over essential resources.
      - Economies of scale yielding a preference for fewer firms.
      - Government-imposed restrictions that can either encourage or discourage competition.

Government Policy and Cartels

  • Antitrust Laws: The Sherman Antitrust Act made most cartels illegal in the U.S. to boost competition and limit monopolization (e.g., U.S. government’s action against lysine cartel in the early 1990s).

  • Government Support for Cartels: Some governments take measures to assist cartels (e.g., OPEC) by enforcing price controls and limiting market entry.

Business Strategy and Changing the Game

Price Matching Guarantees
  • Price matching guarantees introduced as a perceived competitive strategy but may foster collusion.

  • Example analyzed with Lowe's and Home Depot showing how such guarantees can lead to less competitive pricing outcomes despite their pro-consumer appearance.

Loyalty Programs
  • Loyalty programs (e.g., frequent flyer miles) serve to reduce competitive pricing pressures while locking in consumer behaviors and increasing firm price discrimination capabilities.

Takeaway

  • An oligopoly is defined as a market characterized by a small number of firms. Cartels are like oligopolies maximized profit through limiting competitive behavior.
      - Both cartels and oligopolies often struggle to maintain price and production control due to internal and external pressures.

  • Game Theory and Strategic Interaction: Dominant strategies may lead to outcomes unfavorable to collective goals, evidenced in scenarios like the prisoner's dilemma.

  • Successful cartels often depend on barriers to entry, continuous interaction, and sometimes government backing.

Appendix: Nash Equilibrium

  • Nash Equilibrium: Defined as a situation where no player can benefit by changing their strategy unilaterally.

  • Explored various game theory situations highlighting how equilibria function without dominant strategies, particularly through cooperative outcomes across repeated games.

  • Introduced concepts of coordination and strategic decision-making using various examples to demonstrate practical applications of Nash Equilibrium in economic contexts.