Study Notes on Oligopoly and Game Theory
Chapter 15: Oligopoly and Game Theory
Chapter Outline
Cartels
The Prisoner's Dilemma
Oligopolies
When Are Cartels and Oligopolies Most Successful?
Government Policy Toward Cartels and Oligopolies
Business Strategy and Changing the Game
Takeaway
Appendix: Nash Equilibrium
Introduction to Oligopoly and Game Theory
As oil prices neared a historic high in July 1979, President Jimmy Carter stated, “Our neck is stretched over the fence and OPEC has a knife.” This highlights OPEC's power to control oil prices.
OPEC (Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries): A cartel of suppliers that reduce supply, raise prices, and increase profits, acting similarly to a monopolist.
Key Points about Cartels and Oligopolies
Cartels: A group of suppliers aiming to act as a monopoly.
Oligopolies are markets dominated by a small number of firms, leading to higher prices than in highly competitive markets.
Game theory is introduced as a tool for analyzing strategic decision-making in interactive situations.
Strategic decision making: Decision-making in scenarios where the outcome depends on the choices of others.
Analyzing Cartels
OPEC Oil Prices
Analyzed fluctuations in oil prices from 1960 to 2016, highlighting a significant increase between 1970 and 1974 due to OPEC's production cuts.
- Price Change Example: Oil price rose from per barrel to almost per barrel due to OPEC actions.Market Dynamics:
- Competitive market vs monopolistic control illustrated in Figure 15.2, showcasing how cartels can attempt to decrease outputs and increase prices akin to monopolists.
- Profit Maximization: A cartel seeks to maximize joint profits by coordinating reduced output.Challenges for Cartels: Cartels face difficulties maintaining price controls because of:
1. Cheating: Members of the cartel may not adhere to agreed-upon production limits to maximize individual profits.
2. New Entrants: New competitors may enter the market when prices rise.
3. Government Regulation: Legal actions and antitrust policies impact cartel stability.
Fate of Cartels
OPEC's failure to maintain high prices led to a drop in oil prices by 1986 (falling from per barrel to and sometimes as low as per barrel).
- Incentive Structures: Unlike monopolists, cartel members benefit from present exceeding promised production, leading to inevitable cheating within the cartel.Cheating Incentives: Illustrated in a comparison with monopolists and analyzed through Figures and payoff tables (Figure 15.3).
The Prisoner's Dilemma
The Prisoner's Dilemma: A prominent example of how self-interest can lead to suboptimal outcomes for all parties involved.
Explains why cooperation in cartels often fails and highlights the need for strategic interaction.
Example: Fish stock depletion due to the overfishing dilemma among nations highlights the collective negative outcome from competitive self-interest.
Repeated Interaction in the Prisoner's Dilemma
Repeated Engagement: Cooperation becomes more feasible with repeated interactions, drawing on Elinor Ostrom's studies showing successful management of common resources.
Tacit Collusion: Firms may engage in tacit collusion without explicit agreements, adapting strategies based on competitive observations (e.g., asphalt industry behavior).
Institutional Impacts on Cartels and Oligopolies
Barriers to Entry
Barriers to entry promote cartel formation and stability, with factors such as:
- Control over essential resources.
- Economies of scale yielding a preference for fewer firms.
- Government-imposed restrictions that can either encourage or discourage competition.
Government Policy and Cartels
Antitrust Laws: The Sherman Antitrust Act made most cartels illegal in the U.S. to boost competition and limit monopolization (e.g., U.S. government’s action against lysine cartel in the early 1990s).
Government Support for Cartels: Some governments take measures to assist cartels (e.g., OPEC) by enforcing price controls and limiting market entry.
Business Strategy and Changing the Game
Price Matching Guarantees
Price matching guarantees introduced as a perceived competitive strategy but may foster collusion.
Example analyzed with Lowe's and Home Depot showing how such guarantees can lead to less competitive pricing outcomes despite their pro-consumer appearance.
Loyalty Programs
Loyalty programs (e.g., frequent flyer miles) serve to reduce competitive pricing pressures while locking in consumer behaviors and increasing firm price discrimination capabilities.
Takeaway
An oligopoly is defined as a market characterized by a small number of firms. Cartels are like oligopolies maximized profit through limiting competitive behavior.
- Both cartels and oligopolies often struggle to maintain price and production control due to internal and external pressures.Game Theory and Strategic Interaction: Dominant strategies may lead to outcomes unfavorable to collective goals, evidenced in scenarios like the prisoner's dilemma.
Successful cartels often depend on barriers to entry, continuous interaction, and sometimes government backing.
Appendix: Nash Equilibrium
Nash Equilibrium: Defined as a situation where no player can benefit by changing their strategy unilaterally.
Explored various game theory situations highlighting how equilibria function without dominant strategies, particularly through cooperative outcomes across repeated games.
Introduced concepts of coordination and strategic decision-making using various examples to demonstrate practical applications of Nash Equilibrium in economic contexts.