March 17 bus orgs
Summary Statistics for Midterm Exam Results
Midterm exam results have been posted.
Strongly encourage students to:
Set up an exam review with the exam coordinator.
Review questions missed to understand mistakes.
Review correct answers to ensure understanding for the right reasons.
Discussion of Shareholder Voting
Overview of Shareholder Voting in Corporations
Shareholders use voting to exert power within corporations.
Important points include:
Voting on Directors: The most significant way shareholders participate in corporate governance.
Limited Voting Rights: Shareholders do not vote on every issue.
Collective Action Problem
Shareholder voting reflects a collective action problem:
Many shareholders act passively due to the size and complexity of large public companies.
Small stakeholders may lack enough incentive or influence to actively engage in governance.
Example: One share of Amazon does not justify attending annual meetings to advocate for directors.
Shareholder Activism
Definition and Context
Shareholder Activism: Active involvement by shareholders to influence corporate decisions, contrasting with passive investment.
Discussion primarily focuses on large public companies, as small private companies may have engaged shareholders due to significant ownership stakes.
Types of Shareholder Activism
**Economic Shareholder Activism:
Focus on changing corporate policies to improve profitability and corporate governance.
Traditional form of activism, often aimed at improving financial performance.
Non-Economic Activism (ESG):
Centers on environmental, social, and governance issues, gaining prominence in the recent decade.
Represents a shift from purely regulatory interests to broader social concerns.
Key Players in Shareholder Activism
Institutional Investors
Definition: Institutions that invest large amounts of capital on behalf of others, differing from individual retail investors.
Examples include:
Mutual Funds: Large firms that pool money from multiple investors for investing.
Pension Funds: Particularly large government pension plans, holding significant amounts of capital.
Insurance Companies: Invest premium money for returns until claims need to be paid.
Endowments: Funds held by academic institutions or charities.
Sovereign Wealth Funds: Government-owned investment funds, significant players in global finance.
Growth Trends in Institutional Investors
Historical increase from only 9% of U.S. public company shares owned by institutional investors in 1950 to over 80% today.
Reflects a significant consolidation of capital ownership.
Increase in Index Investing:
Defined as investing in a set of securities, like the S&P 500, based on their market capitalization.
Characterized by lower costs compared to actively managed funds.
Index Funds vs. Actively Managed Funds
Index Funds:
Automatically adjust to replicate performance of a specific index.
Cheaper to operate than active funds due to lower management fees.
Vanguard example: Focus on volume and lower costs without the desire for deep research or activism.
Hedge Funds:
Less regulated, privately pooled funds that can engage in shareholder activism.
Hedge funds are incentivized to increase value due to performance-based compensation (e.g., “two and twenty” model).
Shareholder Tools for Activism
Proxy Contests
Definition: Activist investors nominate their own candidates (a slate) to replace the company's board of directors during elections.
Proxy contests are expensive due to the need for regulated submission of voting materials to shareholders.
Ongoing debate about who should bear the costs of proxy contests:
Incumbent Directors: Can be reimbursed for campaign expenses if operating in good faith, regardless of outcome.
Insurgent Directors: Only reimbursed if successfully elected by shareholders.
Example Case: Rosenfeld v. Fairchild
Outcome: Incumbents get reimbursed if they act in good faith; insurgents only when they win.
Shareholder Proposals
Definition: Proposals made by shareholders that, if they meet certain thresholds, are included in the annual proxy materials sent to all shareholders.
Nonbinding, meaning that even if voted on, they do not compel action but signal shareholder sentiment.
Example Case: Trinity Wall Street v. Walmart
Court ruling emphasized that "ordinary business operations" pertain to day-to-day decisions, thus Walmart could exclude proposals focused on gun sales.
Rise of ESG Investing
Definition and Context of ESG
ESG (Environmental, Social, Governance): A movement focusing on corporate responsibility beyond profits.
Associated with social issues including climate change, board diversity, and workplace safety.
Growth due to increased focus from stakeholders and famous finance leaders like Larry Fink of BlackRock.
Challenges include backlash from regulators and politicians, especially from states like Texas.
Rebranding ESG as Risk Management
Argument for framing ESG decisions as necessary for risk management rather than solely social or ethical considerations.
Example: Climate risks affecting supply chains and avoiding litigation costs, potentially benefiting long-term profitability.
Arguments For and Against ESG
For ESG:
Addresses shareholder and societal interests, and can improve public perception and brand loyalty.
Against ESG:
Risk of diverting resources from core business functions and undercutting shareholder primacy; potential political risks.
Conclusion
The landscape of shareholder activism continues to evolve, with significant implications for corporate governance and the wider economic environment.
Agendas of institutional and activist investors, particularly hedge funds, remain pivotal in shaping corporate strategies and responses to both economic and social issues.
Ongoing discussions on ESG highlight the nuanced debate on balancing profitability with responsible corporate governance.
Questions and Discussion
Open floor for questions regarding institutional investors, shareholder activism, proxy contests, or ESG and its implications.