March 17 bus orgs

Summary Statistics for Midterm Exam Results

  • Midterm exam results have been posted.

  • Strongly encourage students to:

    • Set up an exam review with the exam coordinator.

    • Review questions missed to understand mistakes.

    • Review correct answers to ensure understanding for the right reasons.

Discussion of Shareholder Voting

Overview of Shareholder Voting in Corporations

  • Shareholders use voting to exert power within corporations.

  • Important points include:

    • Voting on Directors: The most significant way shareholders participate in corporate governance.

    • Limited Voting Rights: Shareholders do not vote on every issue.

Collective Action Problem

  • Shareholder voting reflects a collective action problem:

    • Many shareholders act passively due to the size and complexity of large public companies.

    • Small stakeholders may lack enough incentive or influence to actively engage in governance.

    • Example: One share of Amazon does not justify attending annual meetings to advocate for directors.

Shareholder Activism

Definition and Context

  • Shareholder Activism: Active involvement by shareholders to influence corporate decisions, contrasting with passive investment.

  • Discussion primarily focuses on large public companies, as small private companies may have engaged shareholders due to significant ownership stakes.

Types of Shareholder Activism

  1. **Economic Shareholder Activism:

    • Focus on changing corporate policies to improve profitability and corporate governance.

    • Traditional form of activism, often aimed at improving financial performance.

  2. Non-Economic Activism (ESG):

    • Centers on environmental, social, and governance issues, gaining prominence in the recent decade.

    • Represents a shift from purely regulatory interests to broader social concerns.

Key Players in Shareholder Activism

Institutional Investors

  • Definition: Institutions that invest large amounts of capital on behalf of others, differing from individual retail investors.

  • Examples include:

    • Mutual Funds: Large firms that pool money from multiple investors for investing.

    • Pension Funds: Particularly large government pension plans, holding significant amounts of capital.

    • Insurance Companies: Invest premium money for returns until claims need to be paid.

    • Endowments: Funds held by academic institutions or charities.

    • Sovereign Wealth Funds: Government-owned investment funds, significant players in global finance.

Growth Trends in Institutional Investors

  • Historical increase from only 9% of U.S. public company shares owned by institutional investors in 1950 to over 80% today.

    • Reflects a significant consolidation of capital ownership.

  • Increase in Index Investing:

    • Defined as investing in a set of securities, like the S&P 500, based on their market capitalization.

    • Characterized by lower costs compared to actively managed funds.

Index Funds vs. Actively Managed Funds

  • Index Funds:

    • Automatically adjust to replicate performance of a specific index.

    • Cheaper to operate than active funds due to lower management fees.

    • Vanguard example: Focus on volume and lower costs without the desire for deep research or activism.

  • Hedge Funds:

    • Less regulated, privately pooled funds that can engage in shareholder activism.

    • Hedge funds are incentivized to increase value due to performance-based compensation (e.g., “two and twenty” model).

Shareholder Tools for Activism

Proxy Contests

  • Definition: Activist investors nominate their own candidates (a slate) to replace the company's board of directors during elections.

  • Proxy contests are expensive due to the need for regulated submission of voting materials to shareholders.

  • Ongoing debate about who should bear the costs of proxy contests:

    • Incumbent Directors: Can be reimbursed for campaign expenses if operating in good faith, regardless of outcome.

    • Insurgent Directors: Only reimbursed if successfully elected by shareholders.

  • Example Case: Rosenfeld v. Fairchild

    • Outcome: Incumbents get reimbursed if they act in good faith; insurgents only when they win.

Shareholder Proposals

  • Definition: Proposals made by shareholders that, if they meet certain thresholds, are included in the annual proxy materials sent to all shareholders.

  • Nonbinding, meaning that even if voted on, they do not compel action but signal shareholder sentiment.

  • Example Case: Trinity Wall Street v. Walmart

    • Court ruling emphasized that "ordinary business operations" pertain to day-to-day decisions, thus Walmart could exclude proposals focused on gun sales.

Rise of ESG Investing

Definition and Context of ESG

  • ESG (Environmental, Social, Governance): A movement focusing on corporate responsibility beyond profits.

    • Associated with social issues including climate change, board diversity, and workplace safety.

  • Growth due to increased focus from stakeholders and famous finance leaders like Larry Fink of BlackRock.

  • Challenges include backlash from regulators and politicians, especially from states like Texas.

Rebranding ESG as Risk Management

  • Argument for framing ESG decisions as necessary for risk management rather than solely social or ethical considerations.

  • Example: Climate risks affecting supply chains and avoiding litigation costs, potentially benefiting long-term profitability.

Arguments For and Against ESG

  • For ESG:

    • Addresses shareholder and societal interests, and can improve public perception and brand loyalty.

  • Against ESG:

    • Risk of diverting resources from core business functions and undercutting shareholder primacy; potential political risks.

Conclusion

  • The landscape of shareholder activism continues to evolve, with significant implications for corporate governance and the wider economic environment.

  • Agendas of institutional and activist investors, particularly hedge funds, remain pivotal in shaping corporate strategies and responses to both economic and social issues.

  • Ongoing discussions on ESG highlight the nuanced debate on balancing profitability with responsible corporate governance.

Questions and Discussion

  • Open floor for questions regarding institutional investors, shareholder activism, proxy contests, or ESG and its implications.