Income Statement Review

Purpose of the Income Statement

  • Provides performance overview for a specific period (year, quarter).

  • Helps assess operating risk by examining the stability of sales and operating income.

Elements of the Income Statement

  • Revenues

  • Expenses

  • Gains

  • Losses

Users of the Income Statement

  • External Users:

    • Investors (stockholders):

      • Concerned with profitability (drives value).

      • Focus on operating income, return on equity, and earnings per share.

    • Lenders (short-term and long-term):

      • Concerned with creditworthiness.

      • Assess credit rating based on profit margin and EBIT (earnings before interest and tax).

      • The more EBIT, the higher the credit rating due to the ability to cover interest expenses.

  • Internal Users (managers):

    • Concerned with return on assets for specific product lines.

  • All users are concerned with risk:

    • Volatility in sales and operating income.

    • Measured by standard deviation in sales and operating income.

Revenues and Expenses (Operating)

  • Most revenues and expenses are from normal operating activities.

  • Revenue and expense items are shown separately (gross).

  • Exceptions:

    • Interest revenue and interest expense (if not a bank) are non-operating.

    • Other revenue and other expense are non-operating.

Gains and Losses (Non-Operating)

  • Non-operating items.

  • Show net result of the transaction (net gain or loss).

Cost vs. Expense

  • Cost: What you pay for something.

  • Expense: When a cost is recognized on the income statement.

  • Period Cost:

    • Expensed immediately because it won't provide future benefit.

    • Examples: recurring selling, general, administrative, research costs.

  • Capitalized Cost:

    • Booked as an asset if it's expected to generate revenue in the future.

    • Unexpired cost = asset (on the balance sheet).

    • Expensed in future periods based on the matching principle.

    • Examples:

      • Inventory costs are capitalized and expensed as cost of goods sold when sold.

      • Prepaid insurance is capitalized and expensed over the policy period.

      • PP&E (property, plant, and equipment) costs are capitalized and depreciated over their useful lives.

      • Intangibles (patents, copyrights, trademarks, franchises, licenses) are capitalized and amortized.

      • Natural resources are depleted.

Operating vs. Non-Operating Items

  • Most revenues/expenses are core business (operating) vs. unusual/infrequent (non-operating).

  • Non-operating items:

    • Selling something other than inventory (PP&E, investments).

    • Write-downs or write-offs.

  • Extraordinary Items:

    • Previously a separate line item but no longer exists.

    • Now reported under non-operating, like losses from natural disasters.

  • Income from continuing operations:

    • Sum of normal operating and non-operating items.

  • Disclosure Requirement:

    • Unusual or infrequent items need to be disclosed in the financial statements or footnotes.

Non-Operating Items Reporting

  • Report the net result of the transaction (gain or loss), not the gross selling price and cost.

  • Quantification:

    • Selling price (if sold) or net realizable value (if impaired)

    • Subtract book or carrying value to get net gain or loss.

  • Income from continuing operations:

    • Operating revenues and expenses

    • Plus or minus non-operating gains and losses, other revenue, other expenses.

  • Discontinued Operations:

    • Reported separately after income from continuing operations, net of tax.

Components of the Income Statement

  • Single-Step Income Statement:

    • Total revenues and gains minus total expenses and losses (except taxes) equals pre-tax income, then subtract income tax expense for net income.

    • Alternatively, total revenues and gains minus all expenses and losses (including income tax expense) equals net income.

    • Problem: Doesn't distinguish between core business and incidental activities.

  • Multiple-Step Income Statement:

    • Enhances user information, separates operating and non-operating activities, aids in ratio analysis.

    • Sales - Cost of Goods Sold = Gross Profit

    • Gross Profit - Operating Expenses (SG&A, depreciation, amortization, R&D) = Operating Income

    • Operating Income +/- Non-Operating Items (other revenues, other expenses, gains/losses from sale of non-inventory, write-downs/offs) = Pre-Tax Income

    • If no discontinued operations: Pre-Tax Income - Tax Expense = Net Income

    • If discontinued operations: Income from Continuing Operations Before Tax - Income Tax Expense = Income from Continuing Operations (after tax) +/- Discontinued Operation (net of tax) = Net Income

    • Multiple-step format allows assessment of what's driving the bottom line.

Subjectivity of the Income Statement

  • Numbers are determined by accounting methods and estimates (accrual basis, not cash basis).

  • Accrual basis:

    • Revenues and expenses are booked when earned/incurred, not when cash is received/paid.

  • Susceptible to management bias through assumptions and estimates (legal or illegal manipulation).

  • Aggressive vs. Conservative Accounting:

    • Aggressive: Higher revenue now, lower expense now (higher profit today).

    • Conservative: Lower revenue now, higher expense now (lower profit today).

    • Examples:

      • Depreciation: Straight-line vs. double-declining balance (double-declining is more conservative initially).

      • Useful life and salvage value: Higher useful life/salvage value leads to lower expenses (aggressive).

      • Bad debts and warranty expense: Higher percentage/expense is more conservative.

Income Smoothing

  • Accrual basis and matching principle lead to income smoothing.

  • Better assessment of annual performance than cash basis.

  • Downside: Subjective and can be manipulated.

  • Example: Long-term construction contracts

    • Without income smoothing: No revenue/expense recognized until project completion (volatile).

    • With income smoothing: Revenue/expense recognized each year based on percentage of completion (stable).

  • Detriment: Management can disguise risk and alter performance.

  • Companies may defer revenue or shift classification to reduce volatility.

Classification Shifting

  • Companies want to put good news in operating income and bad news in non-operating.

  • Pushing up the good news and pushing down the bad news is a type of fraud