(Suburban Patterns - Unit 7)

Urban Patterns

Suburban Challenges

Defining Urban Areas

  • Municipality Definition
        - “The city” as a political entity.
        - Common government, services, and laws.
        - Growth through annexation, defined as adding adjacent territory to a political entity.

  • Urban Areas
        - Metropolitan Statistical Areas (MSAs) represent areas of influence with local government fragmentation.
        - MSA includes the city and its suburbs.

  • Population Statistics
        - Chicago city population: 2.7 million in 2010, down from 3.6 million in 1950.
        - Chicagoland population (MSA): 9.5 million in 2010, up from 5.5 million in 1950.

  • LDCs and Urban Area Definitions
        - Less Developed Countries (LDCs) have unclear distinctions between “the city” and “metro area”.
        - It is important to ensure comparisons are made accurately (i.e., compare apples to apples).

Local Government Fragmentation

  • Characteristics
        - Existence of multiple layers of local government.
            - City government.
            - Township government.
            - County government.
            - Special districts (e.g., Health, Library, Parks/Nature, Public Safety, Water/Sanitary services).
        - Illinois has the highest number of government units of any state, approximately 7,000.

  • Disadvantages
        - Duplicative and costly administration.
        - Lack of economies of scale leading to inequitable spending.
        - Zoning decisions can influence urban sprawl; if zoning is too lenient it may promote urban sprawl and if too strict it can exclude certain groups.

  • Advantages
        - More local control and decision-making opportunities.

Intraregional Migration in the United States

  • Trends
        - Migration patterns show movement from “city” to suburban areas known as suburbanization.
        - This trend accelerated significantly post-World War II and represents the largest migration flow in the U.S.

Density Gradient

  • Population Density Distribution
        - Represents the number of persons per square mile:
            - 15,000 and above
            - 10,000 - 14,999
            - 5,000 - 9,999
            - Below 5,000
        - Temporal changes can be shown on maps across decades like from 1900 to 1960, with visual representations of density gradients.

Chicago Metropolitan Region: 1900-2010

  • Population Change Over Time
        - The share of population by sector shows growth from 1900 to 2010.
            - The population reached 10 million as shown in census data.
            - 2000 and 2010 show specific demographics and changes in the population sectors.

Suburbanization (Review)

  • Push Factors Leading to Suburbanization
        - Urban decay and associated problems in inner cities.
        - Perceptions of “the other,” including racism towards new immigrants (Mexicans, Asians, Puerto Ricans, Appalachians, and African-Americans).
        - Blockbusting techniques influencing suburban migration.

  • Pull Factors for Moving to Suburbs
        - Government policies favoring suburban living.
        - Automotive development and freeway construction that facilitate long-distance commuting.

Government Policies and Suburban Living

  • Post-War Initiatives
        - Suburbanization acceleration due to government initiatives, particularly during the post-World War II era.
        - Mortgage Tax Deductions
            - Incentives favoring homeownership over renting.
        - Programs targeted towards returning veterans to ease housing shortages.
            - FHA (Federal Housing Administration): Lower down payments, longer mortgage terms.
            - GI Bill: Low-interest loans and coverage for education costs, benefiting primarily white suburbanites due to redlining practices that excluded minorities.

Peripheral/Galactic Model (1997)

  • Characteristics of the Model
        - Introduces the concept of ring highways around central cities, facilitating access to suburban areas while avoiding traffic congestion in the CBD (Central Business District).
        - This model reflects the decentralization of traditional city layouts.
        - Industrial shifts from central locations to the periphery (as exemplified by Detroit).
        - Emergence of edge cities, which exhibit higher job density than bedroom capacity, clustering retail and services that rival those in CBDs (examples include Schaumburg and Oakbrook).
        - Edge cities experience distinct urban problems such as poverty and crime while grappling with the legacy of past economic restructuring.

Edge Cities

  • Functional Characteristics
        - Areas that offer various urban services similar to central cities but often developed as stand-alone entities.
        - The population dynamics shift: day population may exceed night population due to job clustering.
        - Some edge cities now embody urban challenges such as low-paying industrial jobs and associated social issues.

New Urbanism as a Solution to Suburban Challenges

  • Design and Environmental Benefits
        - Promotes walkable suburban areas with higher density housing.
        - Anti-automobile infrastructure encourages diverse, connected, and community-oriented neighborhoods.
        - Mixed-use zoning facilitates integration of residential and commercial spaces, reducing reliance on cars and the carbon footprint of suburbia.
        - Enhanced accommodations for mass transit to connect suburban developments with CBDs.

Distinctive Challenges Facing Suburbs

  • Automobile Dependency
        - Suburbs exhibit high reliance on cars, necessitating substantial infrastructure for roads and highways, leading to congestion issues.

  • Public Transit Deficiency
        - Lack of effective public transportation diminishes attractiveness of suburban living compared to urban settings.

  • Urban Sprawl Issues
        - Competition for valuable agricultural land, loss of vegetation, elevated carbon emissions.
        - Efforts like “smart growth” aim to counteract negative implications of urban sprawl.

  • Emerging Poverty
        - As industry relocates to suburbs, they bring urban challenges (e.g., poverty, crime) into these areas.

  • Cultural Aspects
        - Issues with placelessness lead to homogeneity in suburban landscapes, reducing cultural diversity.

Two Views of Cities and CO2 Emissions

  • Traditional perspective suggests cities generate significant greenhouse gases due to high automobile use.

  • Emerging perception posits that cities, with their dense populations, produce relatively lower levels of GHGs because of their efficiency in space utilization.

Urban Sprawl vs Smart Growth

  • Comparison of Development
        - The U.S and UK city layouts showcasing urban expansion—smart growth principles are highlighted.
        - Visual representation emphasizes the need to distinguish between sustainable and sprawling urban growth styles.
        - Greenbelts represent smart growth strategies aimed at limiting unnecessary urban sprawl.

Conclusion

  • Suburbanization remains a complex issue marked by various contributing factors, both push and pull, alongside the repercussions of local government fragmentation and urban planning.

  • The emergence of theories such as New Urbanism provides frameworks to address these challenges facing suburban regions while considering sustainability and livability.