CSR Exam Notes

Unit 5: Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR)

Definition of CSR

CSR, or Corporate Social Responsibility, is a self-regulating business model where a company is socially accountable to itself, its stakeholders, and the public. It involves ethical behavior and contributing to economic development while improving the quality of life for the workforce, their families, the local community, and society at large.

Definitions from various sources:

  • World Business Council for Sustainable Development (1999): "The continuing commitment by business to behave ethically and contribute to economic development while improving the quality of life of the workforce and their families as well as of the local community and society at large."

  • World Bank (2008): "CSR is the commitment of business to contribute to sustainable economic development - working with employees, their families, the local community and society at large to improve the quality of life in ways that are both good for business and good for development."

  • Kotler & Lee (2005): "CSR is a commitment to improve community well-being through discretionary business practices and contributions of corporate resources."

  • Carroll (1979): "Social responsibility of business is to encompass the economic, legal, ethical and discretionary expectations that society has of organizations at a given point in time."

CSR & Its Drivers
  • True Meaning of CSR

  • CSR, employer Branding & millennial (Social Identity theory, Signaling Theory, Social Exchange Theory )

  • Conscious Capitalism

  • CSR performance, Theory, & strategic CSR

  • CSR & Corporate Strategy

CSR Spending in India

CSR spending is broken down by state and company type (PSU vs. Non-PSU).

  • Top Spending States: Maharashtra, Gujarat, Karnataka, Tamil Nadu, Uttar Pradesh, Delhi, Andhra Pradesh, Rajasthan, Telangana.
    Amount Spent (INR Cr.)
    The exact amount for each state is not listed but represented visually.

  • PSU vs. Non-PSU Companies:

    • Non-PSU: Rs. 21705.4721705.47 Cr. (83%)

    • PSU: Rs. 4484.334484.33 Cr. (17%)

  • Top 10 Companies (Amount Spent in INR Cr.):

    • Reliance Industries Limited: 922922

    • Tata Consultancy Services Limited: 634.42634.42

    • HDFC Bank Limited: 674674

    • Tata Sons Private Limited: 531.45531.45

    • Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited: 545.83545.83

    • Indian Oil Corporation Limited: 418.87418.87

    • NTPC Limited: 445.09445.09

    • Infosys Limited: 361.82361.82

    • ITC Limited: 335.43335.43

    • Wipro Limited: 246.99246.99

  • CSR Compliance (Company-wise):

    • Zero Spent: 58775877

    • Exactly as Prescribed: 15071507

    • Less Than Prescribed: 34943494

    • More Than Prescribed: 99119911

CSR in India: Legal Framework

Section 135 of the Companies Act, 2013, along with Schedule VII and the Companies (CSR Policy) Rules, 2014, govern CSR in India. These provisions outline eligibility criteria, implementation, and reporting requirements.

Mandate for CSR in India

Effective from April 2014, the CSR mandate applies to companies meeting specific financial thresholds:

  • Net worth of Rupees 500500 crores or more.

  • Turnover of Rupees 10001000 crores or more.

  • Net profit of Rupees 55 crores or more during a financial year.

Companies meeting these criteria must spend at least 2% of their average net profit from the three immediately preceding financial years on CSR activities.

Importance of CSR
  • Enhances brand image and customer perception.

  • Attracts and retains employees.

  • Increases appeal to investors.

  • Integral part of corporate public relations.

Types of CSR Activities
  1. Donations and sponsorships.

  2. Operational initiatives (social, environmental, workplace).

  3. Strategic transformation (embedded impact or purpose into their business model).

CSR Activities as per Companies Act 2013 (Schedule 8)
  1. Eradicating Hunger, Poverty, and Malnutrition

  2. Promoting Education

  3. Promoting Gender Equality

  4. Environmental Sustainability

  5. Protection of national heritage, art, and culture

  6. Support for armed forces veterans, war widows, and families

  7. Contributions to the Prime Minister’s National Relief Fund or other central government funds for welfare, development, and relief

  8. Contributions to technology development in central government-approved academic institutions

  9. Rural development projects and slum area development

Impact and Implementation of CSR
  • Focus on environmental sustainability through renewable energy and carbon offsets.

  • Efforts to eliminate unethical labor practices in supply chains.

  • Both large corporations and small businesses participate.

  • Eligible companies must form a CSR Committee.

  • Activities are carried out through registered trusts, societies, or companies.

  • CSR activities should not solely benefit employees and their families.

  • Unspent CSR funds must be utilized within three years or transferred to the National CSR Fund.

True Meaning of CSR: The Pyramid of Social Responsibility

The pyramid illustrates a hierarchy of responsibilities:

  1. Economic Responsibilities: Be Profitable (Foundation).

  2. Legal Responsibilities: Obey the Law.

  3. Ethical Responsibilities: Be Ethical.

  4. Philanthropic Responsibilities: Be a good Corporate Citizen.

Drivers of CSR

Key drivers for firms becoming more socially responsible:

  • Government legislation

  • Customer expectations of firms

  • Consumer lobby groups

  • Extent of costs involved

  • Type of industry

  • Potential for competitive advantage

  • Top-level corporate culture

Conscious Capitalism vs. CSR

Conscious Capitalism:

  • Serves the needs and concerns of all stakeholders.

  • Focuses on impact maximization.

  • Incorporates higher purpose and a caring culture.

  • Reconciles caring and profitability.

  • Views business as a complex, adaptive system.

  • Emphasis on shared seeing and common will & citizen awareness.

CSR:

  • Views social responsibility as a trade-off between profit and social good.

  • Independent of corporate purpose or culture.

  • Adds an ethical burden to business.

  • Often grafted onto traditional business model, usually as a separate department or part of public relations.

  • Sees limited overlap between business and society.

Benefits of Conscious Capitalism:
  • Positive impact on the environment and good civil society relationships.

  • Strong reputation that attracts customers, employees, and investors.

  • Greater employee engagement, innovation, passion, and commitment.

  • Improved employee retention and loyalty.

  • Lower spend on recruiting.

  • Delighted and loyal customers who are advocates for the company.

  • Loyal and innovative suppliers.

  • Improved stock market performance.

  • Increased revenue.

Examples of Conscious Capitalism businesses: Whole Foods Market, Starbucks, Patagonia, Southwest Airlines, Costco, Google, Ben & Jerry’s. These are often Certified B Corporations (B Corps).

Corporate Social Performance (CSP)

CSP refers to the principles, practices, and outcomes of businesses’ relationships with stakeholders.

The corporate social performance model consists of three elements:

  1. Social responsibility categories

  2. Mode of social responsiveness

  3. Social issues of stakeholders

Strategic CSR

Strategic CSR incorporates a holistic CSR perspective within a firm's strategic planning and core operations.

  • Responsive CSR mitigates existing or potential adverse effects.

  • Strategic CSR directs resources to initiate CSR agendas aligned with firm strategies, strengthening strategic positions.

Strategic CSR involves rooting CSR in the strategies of specific companies and firms should engage only in eco-social activities related to its core business.

Strategic CSR VS CSR Strategy

Strategic CSR

  • Underpinned by ongoing communication

  • Integrated into the project

  • Sustainable

  • Aligned with country requirements

  • Benefits the community

  • Fair, ethical & transparent

  • Benefits the project owner

CSR Strategy

  • Integration in all structures of the firm.

  • Identification of stakeholders

  • Relation to mission, competitive strategy, and core activities

  • Measurement of Social Performance

  • Implementation of CSR Programs

CSR strategy is the comprehensive plan companies and funders use to design, execute, and analyze their corporate social responsibility initiatives.

Updating the Balanced Scorecard for Inclusive Growth Strategies

Amanco's Triple Bottom Line Strategy Map includes:

  • Financial Dimension: Sustainable profitable growth

  • Customer Dimension: Reinforce Brand Image

  • Process and Technology Dimension: Effective communication to selected targets

  • Learning & Human Resources Growth Dimension: To develop employees based on strategic competencies
    *Environmental and Social Dimension

CSR , Employer Branding & Millennial

Employer branding is a communication strategy focused on a company's employees and potential employees, that enhance the value of belonging to a company, with the ultimate goal of retaining and attracting talent.

Millennials in India constitute 34% (at 440440 million) of the country's total population.

Steps to follow in an employer branding strategy
  1. Definition of the target audience

  2. Analysis of the current situation

  3. Analysis of the desired situation

  4. Definition of the objectives

  5. Create an EVP

  6. Communication channels

  7. Internal actions

  8. External actions

  9. Monitoring and evaluation

Employee Value Proposition (EVP) - WIIFM (What's in it for me)?

Components:

  • Compensation (Salary, Benefits, Fairness)

  • Career (Ability and chance to progress and develop, Stability, Training and education at work, Collage education)

  • Work Environment (Recognition, Autonomy, Personal achievements, Work-life balance, Challenges)

  • Culture (Understanding of one's role and responsibility, Colleagues, Leaders and managers, Collaboration and team spirit, Social responsibility, Trust)

Social Identity Theory

Social identity is a person’s sense of who they are based on their group membership(s).

The central hypothesis of social identity theory is that group members of an in-group will seek to find negative aspects of an out-group, thus enhancing their self-image.

Signaling Theory

Signaling theory is useful for describing behavior when two parties have access to different information.

In emerging economies, firms that adopt CSR practices positively signal investors that their firms have superior capabilities for filling institutional voids.

Social Exchange Theory

According to the Social Exchange Theory, humans weigh the costs against benefits while forming relationships.

  • Behavior (profits) = Rewards of interaction – costs of interaction.

Social exchange theory is applied to help explore the decision that individual employees have towards their engagement with CSR activities, and to consider the implications of an implicit social, rather than explicit economic, contract between an organisation and its employees in their engagement with CSR.

Examples of CSR Programs
  • Tata CSR program

  • Nestle CSR Program

  • ITC eChopal CSR Program
    *DHL Tax Strategy
    *DHL GoGreen Program
    *DHL GoTeach Program

  • Godrej Consumer Products Limited

Conscious Capitalism Examples
  • Whole Foods Market

  • Southwest Airlines

  • Starbucks

  • LEGO

  • TOMS

  • Johnson & Johnson

  • Google

  • Pfizer

Sum Up

Soft Law