Introduction to Fluency, Disfluency, and Stuttering

Terminology and Fluency Foundations

Basic terminology in the field includes PWS (Person Who Stutters) and PWDS (People Who Don't Stutter). The term Disfluency is generally preferred to describe both normal and abnormal speech interruptions, though some authors reserve Dysfluency specifically for stuttering-like behaviors.

According to Starkweather (1987), fluent speech is defined by five dimensions:

  1. Continuity or smoothness

  2. Rate of speech

  3. Rhythmic structure

  4. Information load

  5. Physical and mental effort

Classification of Speech Disfluencies

Disfluencies occur in all speakers and are categorized based on their frequency, duration, and type.

Typical (Between Word) Disfluencies

These occur naturally in both PWS and PWDS:

  • Interjections: Fillers like "um," "uh," and "you know."

  • Phrase Repetitions: E.g., "If you want, if you want I can…"

  • Revisions: Correcting content or grammar errors.

  • Multisyllabic Whole Word Repetitions: Repeating a full word without tension.

Stuttering-Like Disfluencies

Also known as "within word" or "less typical" disfluencies, stuttering involves an abnormally high frequency or duration of stoppages in speech flow.

  • Monosyllabic Whole-Word Repetitions: E.g., "I-I-I want the ball." These are more indicative of stuttering in young children than multisyllabic repetitions.

  • Part-Word Repetitions: Repeating sounds or syllables (e.g., "C−c−canC-c-can"); occurs most frequently on consonants.

  • Prolongations: Audible extensions of sounds (e.g., "S−−−araS---ara"), most common on fricatives like /f//f/, /s//s/, and sh\text{sh}.

  • Blocks: Inaudible, tense prolongations or silent pauses before a sound; identified as the most severe disfluency type.

Yaruss & Reardon (2006) note that "normal" disfluencies can sometimes be used by PWS as a strategy to avoid or postpone actual moments of stuttering.

Core and Secondary Behaviors

Core Behaviors refer to the basic involuntary characteristics of stuttering, including repetitions, prolongations, and blocks that are not readily controllable.

Secondary Behaviors are learned over time and include:

  • Escape Behaviors: Actions taken to resume speech when currently "stuck."

  • Avoidance/Postponement Behaviors: Strategies like word substitutions, circumlocution, or withdrawal used when a speaker anticipates stuttering.

Feelings & Attitudes of Stuttering: The ABCs

The experience of stuttering is often categorized by the ABCs:

  • A (Affective): Emotional reactions like embarrassment, fear, shame, and frustration.

  • B (Behavioral): The physical speech disfluencies.

  • C (Cognitive): Attitudes and beliefs about oneself as a speaker and one's listeners.

Sheehan's Iceberg Analogy

Developed by Joseph Sheehan, the Iceberg Analogy posits that the core behaviors of stuttering are only the visible tip. Submerged "beneath the surface" are significant covert emotional and cognitive factors such as fear, guilt, isolation, and hopelessness. Clinical intervention must address both the overt behaviors and these covert affective components.