Deep Water Study Notes
About the Author and Origin
William Douglas (-) was a graduate of English and Economics who pursued a legal career after teaching in Yakima. He became an advisor to Franklin D. Roosevelt and served for thirty-six years as the longest-serving Justice in the history of the court. The text, an excerpt from Of Men and Mountains, provides an autobiographical account of Douglas nearly drowning as a young boy and his subsequent struggle to overcome a deep-seated fear of water.
The Near-Drowning Incident
Douglas's aversion to water began at age three or four when he was knocked down by waves at a California beach. This fear was compounded at age ten or eleven when a large boy at the Y.M.C.A. pool in Yakima tossed him into the nine-foot deep end. Despite attempting a strategy to spring from the bottom and "bob to the surface like a cork," he experienced suffocation, paralysis, and stark terror. He ultimately lost consciousness, describing the experience as the moment the "curtain of life fell."
Lingering Fear and its Consequences
Following the "misadventure," Douglas suffered from a haunting fear that paralyzed him whenever he was near water. This handicap ruined his adult fishing trips for landlocked salmon in Maine, bass in New Hampshire, and trout on the Deschutes and Metolius in Oregon. It also deprived him of the joy of canoeing and boating on the Columbia River and the waters of the Cascades. The terror remained so intense that it would take physical possession of him, making his legs feel paralyzed and his heart seize with icy horror.
The Process of Rehabilitation
In October, Douglas hired an instructor to help him learn to swim. He practiced five days a week, one hour each day, using a belt and rope system attached to an overhead cable. Over several months, the instructor taught him to breathe properly and coordinate his limbs. By April, the instructor had successfully "built a swimmer." To prove his conquest over fear, Douglas swam two miles across Lake Wentworth in New Hampshire and later swam across Warm Lake near Meade Glacier, shouting with joy as Gilbert Peak returned the echo.
Ultimate Conquest and Reflection
Douglas concluded that his experience with the sensation of dying and the terror of fear itself intensified his will to live. He drew upon the words of Roosevelt, who stated, "All we have to fear is fear itself." By facing the terror that had held him in its grip for decades, he felt finally released and free to walk the trails and brush aside his fears. He suggests that only those who have experienced such stark terror can truly appreciate the peace found in its conquest.
Questions & Discussion
What is the “misadventure” that William Douglas speaks about? This refers to the incident where he was thrown into the deep end of the Y.M.C.A. pool by an eighteen-year-old boy.
What were the series of emotions and fears that Douglas experienced when he was thrown into the pool? What plans did he make to come to the surface? He felt suffocated and paralyzed but planned to jump from the bottom to reach the surface.
How did this experience affect him? It left him with a physical and psychological handicap that prevented him from enjoying water-based activities for years.
How did the instructor “build a swimmer” out of Douglas? The instructor broke down the skill into pieces—breathing, kicking, and strokes—and eventually integrated them into a whole.
How did Douglas make sure that he conquered the old terror? He swam alone in different environments, including Lake Wentworth and Warm Lake, to test his reactions to the "old sensation."