Dynamics of Faith

I. What Faith Is

A. Faith as Ultimate Concern

  • Definition: Faith is described as the state of being ultimately concerned, representing the dynamics of man's ultimate concerns.

  • Human Concerns: Besides vital necessities such as food and shelter, humans have spiritual concerns.

    • These include cognitive, aesthetic, social, and political aspects.

  • Claim of Ultimacy: Any concern that claims ultimacy demands total surrender, promising total fulfillment, often requiring the sacrifice of other concerns.

    • Example: Nationalism may require prioritizing national growth over economic wellbeing, health, or justice.

B. The Implications of Ultimate Concern

  • Total Surrender: Accepting any ultimate concern entails complete devotion to it.

  • Consequences: Strong implications in religious contexts where surrender yields both threats and promises.

    • Exclusion from fulfillment may result from failing to comply with ultimate concerns.

  • Old Testament Example: Illustrates faith as ultimate concern directed towards Yahweh, showcasing unconditional demands in return for promises of fulfillment.

II. The Dynamics of Faith

A. Understanding Faith

  • Faith as a Centered Act: Faith transcends specific functions of personality, uniting cognitive, emotional, and volitional elements.

  • Impact on Personality: The relationship between faith and the dynamics of personal life varies with the inclusion of subconscious factors.

  • Polarity in Analysis: Examining the tension between Freud's concepts of ego and superego highlights faith's potential role in transcending personal conflicts.

B. Faith’s Relationship with Rationality

  • Cognitive Element: Each faith act encompasses cognitive affirmations that involve accepting substantive truths—not merely driven by will or emotion.

  • Ecstasy of Faith: Faith is an ecstatic experience that involves awareness of truth and ethical values, while also drawing from emotional and unconscious motivations.

III. The Nature of Faith

A. Faith as a Centered Act of Personality

  • Ecstatic Nature: True faith engages all aspects of a person’s being, incorporating both rational and non-rational elements.

  • Freedom of Faith: Faith embodies a choice rooted in freedom, synthesizing various aspects of personality into a centered act.

  • Cognitive & Non-Cognitive Elements: Faith integrates all faculties of the person but does not reduce itself to being solely rational or emotional.

IV. Faith and Ultimate Concern

A. Dual Character of Faith

  • Ultimate Concern: The act of faith presupposes a concern for something that is experienced as ultimate.

  • Human Restlessness: This potentially infinite concern drives humans toward faith, representing a restlessness of the heart.

B. Sources of Faith

  • Defining the Divine: The divine relates to that which embodies the unconditional, absolute quality, often expressed as God or a god.

  • Ultimate vs. Preliminary: The ongoing struggle within faith is distinguishing between what is truly ultimate and what threatens to become merely idolatrous.

V. The Dynamics of the Holy

A. Holiness in Relation to Faith

  • Understanding Holiness: Holiness signifies the transcendent, the entirely other, apart from mundane existence.

  • Ambiguous Character: The dynamics of holiness include both creative and destructive potentials, often associated with idolatrous beliefs.

B. The Spectrum of Faith

  • Idolatrous Faith: Although still faith, idolatries relate to finite concerns elevated to ultimacy, leading to eventual true faith disappointment.

  • True Faith: Genuine faith focuses on a truly ultimate concern and encourages a search for deeper fulfillment beyond mere worldly attachments.

VI. Faith, Doubt, and Risk

A. Courageous Acceptance of Risk

  • Courage in Faith: Accepting faith entails embracing uncertainty and potential failure regarding its concrete expressions, such as national identity or personal aspirations.

  • Element of Doubt: Inherent to every act of faith is a form of existential doubt, signifying awareness of insecurity in our ultimate concerns.

B. The Role of Skeptical Doubt

  • Skeptical Doubt vs. Faith: Skepticism complicates matters for faith but underscores the genuine nature of concern for ultimate truths.

  • Status of Doubt: Rather than being negative, doubt serves a functional purpose, affirming the seriousness of ultimate concern.

VII. Faith and Community

A. Community's Role in Faith

  • Language and Faith: Faith necessitates a communal language, stemming from shared experiences among believers, shaping the expression of individual faith.

  • Need for Creedal Statements: While creeds create community, the potential for doubt must remain a part of their understanding and articulation.

B. Balancing Faith and Autonomy

  • Autonomy and Critique: The community must recognize and allow critical elements and doubts within expressions of faith to avoid becoming static.

  • Dynamic Faith: The essence of faith must embrace the dialectical tension between certainty and doubt, asserting that creedal expressions point beyond themselves to the ultimate concern.