Interpersonal Attraction, Attachment Theory, and the Science of Influence
Upcoming Schedule and Cialdini Assignment Details
- Finish discussion on the topics of interpersonal attraction and romantic relationships.
- Introduction and transition to the Robert Cialdini book, "Influence: Science and Practice."
- Required reading dates:
- April 28 (4/28): Chapters 1 through 4.
- April 30 (4/30): Chapters 5 through 7.
- The Critical Evaluation (CE) assignment based on the Cialdini book is due on Wednesday, April 29 (4/29).
Evolutionary Perspectives on Partner Selection
- Core Definition: The evolutionary approach suggests that men and women are attracted to different characteristics in each other based on traits that maximize reproductive success.
- Selection Logic for Women:
- Women are typically attracted by a man's resources.
- Reproductive success is defined by successfully raising offspring to maturity.
- Theory: Access to greater resources increases the offspring's chances of survival.
- Selection Logic for Men:
- Men are typically attracted by a woman's appearance.
- Reproductive success is defined by maximizing the total number of offspring.
- Theory: A symmetrical face is a trigger feature indicating positive health and "good genes."
- Cross-Cultural Evidence:
- A study asked thousands of adults in 37 different countries to identify desirable characteristics in a marriage partner.
- Shared values: Both men and women valued honesty, trustworthiness, and a pleasant personality.
- Distinctive values for women: Women valued ambition, industriousness, and earning capacity more than men did.
- Distinctive values for men: Men valued physical attractiveness more than women did.
Critiques and Alternate Perspectives on Sex Differences in Attraction
- Limit of Evolutionary Theory: The theory struggles to account for people who cannot or do not want to reproduce.
- Status Differences: An alternate perspective suggests gender differences are actually status differences. Women historically have less power and wealth, making it difficult to separate "nature" from "nurture."
- Dating Paradigms: Allegedly "evolved" gender differences may be results of social dating paradigms where men are the ones who approach and women are the ones who are approached.
- Example: Speed dating studies illustrate how behavior changes based on which group is stationary versus which group is approaching.
Attachment Theory: Key Concepts and Functions
- John Bowlby (1907−1990):
- Formally recognized as the "Father of Attachment Theory."
- Author of the influential "Attachment and Loss" trilogy.
- Three Functions of Attachment:
1. Proximity Seeking: The drive to stay near a caregiver for protection.
2. Safe Haven: Turning to a caregiver for comfort and soothing in times of distress.
3. Secure Base: Using the caregiver as a foundation of security from which to explore the environment.
The Strange Situation: Behavioral Observations of Infants
- Methodology: Developed by Mary Ainsworth to test reactions of infants when separated from their mothers.
- Steps of the "Strange Situation" Procedure:
1. Caregiver (CG) and infant (I) enter the playroom; the infant is between 12 and 18 months old.
2. The infant is allowed to play while the caregiver is present.
3. A stranger enters the room and the caregiver leaves.
4. The caregiver returns and the stranger leaves.
5. The caregiver leaves the room again, leaving the infant alone.
6. The stranger returns.
7. The caregiver returns for a final reunion.
- Classification of Infants:
- Secure Style: Explores during the initial phases; becomes upset when the CG leaves; shows confidence that the CG will return; accepts some comfort from the stranger; upon CG return, seeks comfort and is easily soothed.
- Anxious/Ambivalent Style: Exploration is unlikely; shows extreme separation distress; the stranger is of no comfort; upon CG return, the infant may seek comfort but simultaneously and angrily reject the soothing.
- Avoidant Style: Treats the caregiver and the stranger essentially the same; unlikely to show distress when the CG leaves; does not seek comfort upon the CG's return.
Adult Attachment Styles and Relationship Stability
- Hazan & Shaver (1987) Application: Applied attachment styles to adult romantic relationships with the following estimated distributions:
- Secure: 56%
- Avoidant: 25%
- Anxious/Ambivalent: 19%
- Malleability of Attachment: Attachment styles are not fixed. One study by Davila et al. found that 30% of people changed their attachment category over a two-year period, a rate consistent with other studies.
- Relationship-Specific Attachment: Cook performed a study of 208 four-person families (mother, father, older sibling, younger sibling).
- Findings: Attachment security is relationship-specific rather than just a personality trait. Partner characteristics affect security, and security itself is reciprocal.
Cialdini’s Science of Influence: Core Arguments
- Fundamental Questions:
- What factors cause one person to say "yes" to another?
- What specific techniques bring about compliance?
- Scientific Premise: Gaining compliance is not magic or luck; it is a science. While nothing is 100% effective, there are specific principles to increase influence across domains like business, PR, advertising, and fundraising.
- The Seven Principles of Influence:
1. Reciprocity
2. Consistency & Commitment
3. Social Proof
4. Liking
5. Authority
6. Scarcity
7. Unity (The newest addition to Cialdini's framework).
The Click-Whirr Mechanism and Automaticity
- Mental Shortcuts: Humans rely on shortcuts (heuristics and stereotyping) due to the overwhelming volume of information they process daily. These shortcuts make people vulnerable to influence.
- Automaticity in Nature: A mother turkey will initiate mothering behaviors based solely on the "cheep-cheep" sound of a chick.
- Fixed Action Patterns: Built-in automatic responses to stimuli that are activated by "trigger features."
- Click-Whirr Process:
- Mimics a tape recorder.
- "Click": The trigger feature activates the appropriate behavioral tape.
- "Whirr": The standard sequence of behavior is rolled out automatically in the same order every time.
- Human Application: Culture has programmed humans with "trigger features" for compliance, which act as information bits telling us when saying "yes" is generally correct or beneficial.
Compliance Triggers: The Library Copy Machine Study
- Researcher: Ellen Langer.
- Objective: To determine how the structure of a request for a small favor (using a Xerox machine) affects compliance.
- Experimental Conditions and Outcomes:
- No Reason Given: "Excuse me, I have five pages. May I use the Xerox machine?" resulted in a 60% compliance rate.
- Rational Reason Given: "Excuse me, I have five pages. May I use the Xerox machine because I’m in a rush?" resulted in a 94% compliance rate.
- Redundant/Placebo Reason Given: "Excuse me, I have five pages. May I use the Xerox machine because I have to make copies?" resulted in a 93% compliance rate.
- Conclusion: The use of the trigger word "because" followed by any reason—even an obvious or redundant one—activates an automatic "click-whirr" compliance response.