Treaty of Versailles Notes
Chapter 1: Introduction
- Walter Siemens, a lawyer for the German delegation, corresponded with his wife during the treaty negotiations.
- Melkir, a Jewish banker, was part of the German delegation, accompanied by bankers Warburg and Wassermann.
- Germany included Jewish bankers in their delegation, believing their expertise would help secure a favorable treaty.
- The train carrying the delegation was stopped several times.
- Verdun saw immense destruction with 420,000 deaths and the obliteration of nine villages.
- Rakdov Ransal, the foreign minister, led the German delegation with a tough stance.
- Doug Eisbertz was the postmaster general with little known information about him.
- Walter Simons, from the German foreign office, specialized in law and was expected to be the delegation's writer.
- Clemenceau believed the Germans were beaten but not crushed and wanted to ensure they could not cause further harm.
- Clemenceau wanted to complete the job for those who died and those yet to be born.
- The idea that if Germany felt unjustly treated, it would seek retribution.
- Clemenceau had been anticipating this day since witnessing Germany's invasion of France 45 years prior.
- During the war, there was a belief France was dead.
- French authorities directed the German delegation's train to an isolated area near Versailles.
- The German delegation was described as sad and dejected.
- The German delegation was housed in the Hotel des Reservoir in Versailles, establishing their headquarters in the basement.
- The Germans were certain there were listening devices and tapped phones, and they were correct.
- Wilson received cables from the U.S. warning him that the League of Nations was in trouble.
- The Germans played music loudly, such as Tannhauser, to mask their conversations.
- The Kaiser was under house arrest in Holland.
- The Germans feared humiliation if prosecuted.
- The conference was creating small states as potential protection for France if peace failed.
- Troops were returning home with stories of German atrocities.
- Wilson faced an uneasy standoff with old-school politicians who favored alliances.
Chapter 2: Called Pro German
- Wilson's approach was contrasted with that of seasoned politicians.
- French newspapers criticized Wilson, despite previously praising him, due to editorials ordered by the French government.
- Wilson threatened to leave Paris due to press criticism.
- Lloyd George and Clemenceau were more accustomed to press criticism than Wilson.
- Hungary succumbed to communism, and much of the world was facing starvation and unemployment.
- Strikes occurred in Europe and North America due to pent-up anger from the war.
- Paris was tense.
- The Allies turned off the heat in the Germans' hotel.
- The Allies delayed the presentation of the treaty to the Germans.
- Parisians maintained a vigil in front of the German hotel.
- Each of the major powers wanted a different kind of peace.
- Britain wanted to maintain naval dominance.
- Italy sought territorial gains.
- France desired protection against future German aggression.
- The US wanted global influence and repayment of loans.
- The Allies were assessing Germany's financial worth for reparations.
- The German merchant marine was estimated to be worth 600,000,000.
- Estimates for foreign securities ranged from 500,000,000 to 1,250,000,000.
- German owned private property might raise 500,000,000.
- The total estimate was 300,000,000,000 maximum, but Germany needed most of that to survive.
- Politicians had unrealistic expectations for reparations.
- Everyone in Paris kept their own financial records.
- Keynes was diverging from the enormous numbers that the leaders had promised.
- Putting a price on a world war was difficult.
- The Germans waited without information.
- Broktow Ransow instructed Walter Siemens to prepare two responses to the treaty, one conciliatory and one harsh.
- The Germans were informed they would receive the draft treaty at 3:00 PM.
Chapter 3: Sign The Treaty
- The treaty's terms were harsher than the Germans anticipated.
- Germany would be paralyzed for generations.
- Brokthorf Randsau knew which speech to use.
- Brokthorf Ransow caused a sensation due to his directness with the victors.
- The young diplomats worried about pushing Germany too far.
- Andrei Chardieu believed that Germany's defeat had already provoked nationalist feelings.
- The Germans had three weeks to respond.
- They stopped playing music and ceased caring about eavesdroppers.
- Life in Paris was returning to normal.
- Harold Nicholson positioned himself close to the inner circle.
- Wilson discussed the people's desires regarding the treaty.
- Wilson's pronouncements had a touch of revivalism and arrogance.
- Mapmakers were instructed to create Iraq from Shia, Sunni, Kurds, and Jews.
- There were massive protests in Berlin.
- German Chancellor Philipp Scheidemann protested the draft treaty.
- The Germans requested moderation of the peace terms.
- America asked for no reparations.
- The US lost a little less than Australia in lives.
- The speaker had problems with socialists and botulists.
- The treaty had to be accepted or rejected as is.
- Fascist leaders Donuncio and Mussolini were rising in Rome.
- Orlando was failing to achieve anything in Paris.
- Orlando and the Italian delegation left Paris in protest.
- Belgium, Japan, and China were also unhappy.
- Wilson was gambling.
- Allied listening devices revealed frequent long-distance calls from Berlin to Brachto Franco.
- It was important to convince the Germans they were defeated.
- The Supreme War Council was ordered to prepare for potential renewed fighting and an invasion of Berlin if the Germans refused to sign the treaty.
Chapter 4: The German Treaty
- War was a real possibility.
- Many younger people were unhappy with the treaty's terms.
- The British treasury man, Keynes, considered the treaty immoral and incompetent.
- Keynes believed Germany could pay no more than 10,000,000,000.
- Lloyd George had promised Britain thirty times that amount.
- The conference was in its fifth month, and a just peace remained elusive.
- Fewer calls were being intercepted between Brokdorf, Ransau, and Berlin.
- The Allies feared the Germans might seek allies elsewhere.
- Nicholson wrote that a bad treaty today was better than a good treaty months later, but later regretted this.
- Brockdorf Ransau was informed Berlin expected war to resume if the treaty wasn't ratified.
- There was significant pressure to accept the treaty.
- Wilson had been out of America for a long time and had been advised against personally negotiating.
- Germans were beginning to understand the hatred felt towards them.
- Paris was the center of power.
- Communism, starvation, and workers' revolutions were overtaking Europe.
- Republicans were gaining ground in the US, and there were labor issues in Texas and rumors about China.
- The Chinese were going to lose Shantong to the Japanese and were unhappy.
- Lloyd George unexpectedly switched his stance and feared a weak Germany.
- He believed a weak Germany would be susceptible to demagogues and unable to buy British goods.
- Lloyd George wanted to trade with Germany but Wilson refused to compromise.
Chapter 5: Treaty Of Versailles
- Lloyd George could not change Wilson's mind.
- Keynes would not endorse Lloyd George's demand for 300,000,000,000.
- John Maynard Keynes resigned.
- Rocdorf Hansau, Simons, and Scheidemann resigned.
- Orlando's government fell.
- Fascists were becoming violent in Italy.
- Mapmakers had redrawn the borders of Europe, the Middle East, the Far East, and Africa.
- Wilson believed Germany would eventually join the League of Nations and redeem itself.
- Two days before the signing, the Germans scuttled their fleet.
- A new German government took power.
- Two reluctant German officials, Muller and Bell, were found to sign the peace agreement.
- The Great War started 1,797 days prior.
- The Treaty of Versailles would be signed.
- Harold Nicholson witnessed the signing.
- Walter Siemens was in Germany with his wife.
- Keynes was in London, and his estimate of 10,000,000,000 was close to what Germany eventually paid.
- The Chinese chose not to sign the treaty.
- Orlando was not at the signing, and Mussolini promised to improve things.
- Britain did not receive much German gold and lost its naval dominance.
- Clemenceau came closest to achieving his aims, but the promised protection for France was not guaranteed.
Chapter 6: Conclusion
- Claremont was rejected by the French people and died a bitter man.
- Woodrow Wilson advocated for the League of Nations but his health suffered.
- The treaty was signed in the Hall of Mirrors.
- The signing was announced with gunfire.
- Clemenceau, Wilson, and Lloyd George emerged to cheering crowds.
- Germany never forgave the West for the Treaty of Versailles.
- America rejected the League of Nations.
- Woodrow Wilson died two years later.
- The peace negotiators in Paris were convinced they would avoid the mistakes of the Congress of Vienna, but all generations believe they can avoid the pitfalls of previous negotiators.
- The Treaty of Versailles failed to give meaning to the war's casualties.
- It taught that military conquest does not ensure lasting safety.
- Another world war was needed for the world to learn how to make peace.