Introduction to Employment Law and Workers' Compensation

Introduction to Employment Relationships

  • Discussion on the duties owed by employers to employees and contractors.

  • Overview of federal employment laws pertinent for the test:
      - Workers' Compensation
      - Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)
      - Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA)
      - Title VII of the Civil Rights Act (discrimination claims)

Employment vs. Independent Contracting

  • Definition of Independent Contractors:
      - Individuals who take on specific projects and retain control over how to complete them.
      - No control over their schedule or tasks directed by employers. Examples include:
        - Uber drivers
        - Grocery delivery workers (e.g., Instacart)
        - Freelance professionals (e.g., lawyers, real estate agents)

  • Characteristics Distinguishing Employees from Independent Contractors:
      - Control and direction:
        - Employees are often told how, when, and where to work.
        - Independent contractors manage their own workload.
      - Financial relationship:
        - Employees often receive regular paychecks; independent contractors might be paid per project.
      - Skills required:
        - Specific skills or certifications needed often point towards an employee.
      - Duration and permanence of position:
        - Employees may have long-term roles; independent contractors are generally hired for temporary projects.

Duties of Employers towards Employees

  • Safety:
      - Employers owe a duty to ensure safe working conditions for employees.
      - Historical context stemming from the Industrial Revolution and sweatshop conditions.
      - Recent emphasis on safety and training:
        - Mandatory safety equipment (e.g., hard hats and certifications).

  • Training and Supervision:
      - Employers must provide adequate training for tasks expected to be performed.
      - Orientation is a key duty to ensure understanding of responsibilities.

  • Compliance with Laws:
      - Employers must adhere to all applicable federal, state, and local employment laws.

  • Compensation:
      - Employees expect to be reimbursed according to the agreed-upon terms.
      - Breach of these duties may lead to tort claims or civil lawsuits against employers.

Duties of Employees towards Employers

  • Adherence to Policies and Procedures:
      - Employees must follow rules and regulations set by the employer.
      - Examples of expectations include:
        - Confidentiality and non-disclosure of trade secrets.
        - Maintenance of professional competence.

  • Avoiding Conflicts of Interest:
      - Employees must be careful to avoid situations that may lead to conflicts of interest (e.g., teaching at two competing institutions).

Employment at Will Doctrine

  • Definition:
      - Employment can be terminated by either side at any time, for any lawful reason, unless otherwise specified in an employment contract.

  • Legal exceptions:
      - Discriminatory terminations are prohibited (e.g., pregnancy discrimination, retaliatory firings).
      - Terminations contrary to the terms outlined in written contracts are also not permitted.

Workers' Compensation Overview

  • Definition:
      - Workers' compensation is an insurance system that compensates employees who are injured on the job, funded by employers.

  • Eligibility:
      - Only employees are covered; independent contractors and third parties are excluded.
      - Workers must show they were injured while performing job-related duties.

  • Scope of Employment Issues:
      - Complications arising from remote work:
        - Ex. A remote employee injured while getting coffee during work hours.
        - Determining "scope of employment" can be challenging (examples include going downstairs for coffee).

Proof of Injury and Claims

  • Employees must document injuries to claim workers' compensation.

  • Types of documents may include:
      - Medical records
      - Onsite injury reports

Benefits Covered by Workers' Compensation

  • Covers:
      - Medical expenses related to not just the immediate injury but also rehabilitation.
      - Lost wages due to injuries sustained on the job.
      - Disability ratings for prolonged injuries.
      - A statutory schedule delineating compensation for specific kinds of injuries.

  • Exclusions:
      - Emotional distress claims and punitive damages are typically not covered.
      - Claims for pain and suffering are also excluded.

  • Death benefits:
      - Dependents may claim benefits if an employee dies due to a work-related incident.

Conclusion on Workers' Compensation

  • Key Takeaways:
      - Evidence of being within the scope of employment when an injury occurs is crucial.
      - The burden of proof lies with the employee.
      - Robust documentation is essential for a successful workers' compensation claim.
      - As employment laws continue to evolve, particularly with remote work trends, clarity on liability and coverage will remain integral for both employees and employers.