Chapter 3 - Group Counseling Fundamentals Within a Multicultural Counseling Context (pg 82 - 108)

Group Dynamics

  • defined as the character and traits of the group, the changes that occur in the group and between the group members throughout the life of the group

  • Group dynamics include the movement, incidences, growth, and setbacks that happen over the course of the group’s life and how they impact the group leaders and group members

  • help us understand the core of racism, sexism, and other forms of social prejudice and discrimination that are mirrored within groups as microcosms of society

  • present in all types of groups, not just counseling groups

  • shift your attention from what is being said that might be based on the topic of the group (the content), to focusing on everything that may be bubbling under the surface (the process)

Norms

  • dynamics impacted by the unwritten or unspoken rules of the group

  • group norms are heavily influenced by the members that make up the group and, therefore, attending to race, culture, gender, and so forth is imperative

  • Fostering environments that facilitate an openness and acceptance of multiple viewpoints regarding difficult and sensitive topics while considering underlying cultural implications is imperative

    • ensure that group norms are explicitly negotiated and decided at the onset of the group and periodically referred to, to ensure that they continue to be acceptable

    • CONFIDENTIALITY

Member Roles

  • group roles and behaviors that come up in groups, including but not limited to, the silent member, the monopolizing member, the rescuer, the storyteller, and the help-rejecting complainer

  • the presence or absence of these types of roles and behaviors, as well as how group members intersect, greatly contributes to the overall group dynamic.

Member & Leader Identities

  • group dynamics are impacted by the different intersecting identities of the group leaders and members

  • identity is made up of a myriad of commonly accepted categorical factors that have two components: personal identity (self-concept, or the way in which one perceives oneself based on one’s identities) and social identity (collective self, or how one may be defined by one’s group membership and general characteristics in relation to social belonging

  • ADDRESSING Model

    • age

    • developmental

    • disabilities

    • religion

    • ethnicity

    • socioeconomic status

    • sexual orientation

    • indigenous heritage

    • national origin

    • gender

  • not uncommon that people identify with the plural form “identities,” simultaneously or as fluid due to the potentially shifting nature as people move through developmental stages in their lives

  • intersection of identities shape how group members communicate within the group settings

Group Models

  • group models serve as a road map to help group practitioners plan, implement, and evaluate groups.

    • phases help leaders have a sense of what they might be able to expect in the group

  • By understanding how the group phases impact how interactions in the group play out, the leader can have some ideas of what to expect, as well as intervene in a way that is appropriate for the phase of the group

  • group phases can recycle, where the group revisits a previous developmental stage. This might be a result of, for example, adding new members to the group

  • Tuckman Model

    • Forming, Storming, Norming, Performing, and Adjourning

  • Corey (2018) - pre-group phase, initial phase, transition phase, working phase, final phase

  • Steen (2014) - Assessment, Review, Acquaintance, Challenge, Empower, and Support

  • Conyne et  al. (2008), who describe in detail the Purposeful Group Techniques Model (PGTM), which includes five steps: Identify, Analyze, Review, Select, Implement, and Evaluate

  • Group phases are the general descriptions of the group that are noticed

  • Group curricula may be created to developmentally meet the needs of members and to assist in moving through group phases

  • emphasize the importance of the leader knowing the purpose of the group, and being able to communicate this purpose clearly

    • while also recognizing that the distinct power of the group process lies in members’ abilities to increase their awareness of how they relate to others interpersonally (process)

Type of Group

  • The ASGW (2000) and a myriad of other scholars (e.g., Conyne, Erford, Jacobs) identify four different types of groups: Task, Psychoeducation, Counseling, and Psychotherapy

    • the purpose of Task groups is typically to complete some type of short-term or long-term activity

    • Psychoeducation groups are generally very topic specific; for example, stress management, study skills, anger management, or social skills

      • purpose is usually to teach members some specific skills that will translate to enhanced efficacy out in the world

    • Counseling groups typically focus on interpersonal concerns among members who may be experiencing a period of increased adjustment difficulty

    • Psychotherapy groups allow for exploration at the deepest level, and are often used with members who may experience chronic difficulties or mental health concerns

Group Leadership Style

  • fluid, constantly in development

  • The more experience you have the better able you will be to determine your own style and what works best with the particular clients or students you are serving

  • group leader skills, dispositions, and experiences are what in turn make up a group leader’s style

  • level of structure

    • leader-directed

      • highly structured

      • planning sessions & fostering group environment to follow plan

      • less flexibility

      • more easily replicated, more easily able to be researched & studied

    • group-directed

      • unstructured

      • still plan sessions but the session will have much more flexibility in how they unfold

      • more willing to follow what is presented during the session

      • more at risk for going substantially off topic

      • greater opportunities that may emerge that could have not been known when plans were made

Basic Counseling Skills used for Group Counseling Leadership

  • Active listening—reflecting content and emotions

  • Questioning—emphasizing open-ended prompts

  • Challenging—confronting discrepancies, giving and receiving feedback

  • Silence—allowing the group space for reflection

  • Self-disclosure—sharing hidden parts of oneself by modeling and then encouraging others to do the same

  • Immediacy—bringing to light both verbal and nonverbal occurrences in the “here and now”


Dispositions

  • made up of personality characteristics and can include elements such as temperament, mentality, patience, humor, flexibility, and so on

  • likely those that you were born with

  • leader’s awareness of their natural dispositions and how they might need to adapt their dispositions to effectively serve the group is crucial for good leadership

  • pros and cons

  • humor can help to energize members or to shed light on another perspective if the mood has been overly serious. At other times, humor could be inappropriately timed or even harmful especially if coupled with sarcasm that is misunderstood

Group Experience

  • made up by the lessons learned from prior participation in groups as a member or leader

  • can be clinical groups but also personal groups (e.g., sports teams, work teams) or familial groups

  • over time your experience will continue to grow as you engage in more groups

  • can play a major role in how one adjusts to the unexpected, how one deals with the unknown, and how one anticipates what could happen over the life span of a group

  • Assessing one’s group leadership within the context of one’s multicultural awareness and competence will allow group leaders to know themselves and how their cultural competence can impact group development

Schools

  • a school setting could involve different group leaders from different disciplines with different training; therefore, the manner in which a group in a school could be set up may differ

  • there are a number of individuals apart from just the student participants who will be involved in the groups that you run

    • school admin

    • teachers

    • staff members

    • students

    • parents/guardians

    • mental health personnel

  • before the group begins you may be responsible for seeking approval to implement the group intervention

    • receiving approval from principle or mandate from central office administrators

  • teachers will be instrumental in helping with student selection and staff members such as a secretary or other support staff may help you find a secure location in which to run these groups

  • students may self-select for participation or be involved in anonymously referring their peers for participation

  • Parental and/or guardian permission will need to be solicited and these individuals are great resources for discovering what their child’s strengths and areas for improvement entail in regard to the goals and outcomes desired

  • setting up, running, and assessing a group is not something that you will do in isolation; however, you may be the only one who has a clear idea of what you would like to accomplish because of your solid knowledge and skills learned about groups

Clinical Mental Health Settings

  • many times the agency will have a focus or foci that they target to meet the needs of their clients

  • likely involve getting approval from the leadership

  • group format and structure as well as the type of group will need to be explored before its commencement

  • advertising and recruitment of members, screening members, and confirming the schedule for the sessions are necessary

  • will also need to decide the curriculum and the supplemental assessment and evaluation tools in addition to those used during intake to establish some tentative treatment goals

Group Assessment & Evaluation

  • evaluation - the extent to which the group as a whole accomplished its purpose, individual members met their goals, and examining any other indicators of either positive or negative experiences in the group

  • assessment - using a specific instrument, or measure

  • Professional Standards for the Training of Group Workers (Association for Specialists in Group Work, 2000) identify as a core training standard the ability of leaders to “identify and describe:

    • (a) methods for evaluating group process in group work

    • (b) methods for evaluating outcomes in group work”

  • leader must determine how they are going to evaluate the group prior to the start of the group

  • pre- and post-assessment of some variety are helpful in order to look at members’ change

  • what has been impactful or stood out to group members over the course of the session or over the course of the life of the group

    • e.g. critical incident questionnaire - members note interactions or experiences that have impacted them the most

  • measuring how members (and/or leaders) are experiencing the group environment

    • general sense of how members are feeling in the group, and the extent to which members feel connected to the group process as a whole

    • can encourage members to reflect on their experience in the group, as well as provide valuable data to the leader

  • considering assessment ideas and tools, the leader must take into consideration the cultural background of their group members

Ethical Considerations

  • Seeking supervision

  • Attending professional conferences

  • Engaging in reflective practice

  • Collaborating and consulting with others

  • Discovering cultural brokers

  • Engaging in self-care

  • Pursuing additional training