Oral Exam answer
“Why is the UK Constitution described as ‘uncodified not ‘codified’? Can you outline and critically analyse one argument in favour of codifying the UK Constitution?
A Codified constitution can be described as having the fundamental rules of a nation written down into one authoritative document. There are many benefits to a codified constitution for example, public accessibility or legal clarity ( for which a codified constitution can be used as a reference/base for constitutional disputes).
This is precisely what the UK Constitution lacks, there is no singular authoritative document. Compared to other countries, the UK as a whole lacked the systematic failure that made codification necessary. For America ,the failure of the Articles of Confederation were a primary catalyst in the downfall of the existing government in the 1780’s. This alongside other factors led to the 1787 Constitutional Convention that created a new codified document. Though there had been a revolution in England in 1649 it focused more on amending the structure of the constitution. Adam Tomkins suggests in his 2003 book, Public Law, “written constitutions are creatures of political fashion”. He expands on this point by explaining how Englands revolution predated the Enlightenment era when the fashion of written codes became the standard. As a result the UK settled its political disputes through evolution.
The entrenchment of fundamental human rights is a strong argument for the codification of the UK Constitution. Human rights would be placed in a superior legal category, by ensuring a citizens basic liberties are not subject to temporary “political fashion”. This creates a sense of security for citizens as they would have an authoritative document to turn to when their rights are at stake. Though some may argue that codification better protects rights, scholars like Richard Bellamy have made efforts to debate this point. In his work Political Constitutionalism‘, he argues that ‘democracy provides a form of political constitutionalism that is superior to’ legal constraints. Additionally the UK’s uncodified nature allows rights to evolve quickly without the need for constitutional amendment. this can be seen in shifts like devolution through ordinary legislation. Ultimately though entrenchment would protect the rights of citizens more tightly, the shift of power from Parliament can be argued as less democratically responsive. For these reasons the codification of the UK’s constitution seems undesirable.