Agency Formation and Termination
AGENCY FORMATION AND TERMINATION
This section explores various aspects of agency relationships, their formation, and the conditions under which they can be terminated. Agency relationships are essential in business and law, defining the roles and responsibilities of the parties involved.
CHAPTER 29: AGENCY FORMATION AND TERMINATION
1. Duty of Loyalty
Definition: The duty of loyalty is an obligation that mandates individuals, specifically corporate directors, to remain loyal to the interests of the corporation.
Example: Betty, a Certified Public Accountant (CPA), sits on the boards of three corporations. She does not violate her duty of loyalty if she refrains from voting on issues that affect more than one of the corporations, ensuring she does not have conflicting interests.
2. AGENCY and Employment Relationships
2.1 Types of Employment Relationships
Agency (Principal & Agent): Involves one party acting on behalf of another.
Employer-Employee (Master-Servant): The employer has control and responsibility over the employee's actions.
Employer-Independent Contractor: The contractor operates independently, and the employer has limited control over how tasks are performed.
Importance: Understanding the type of relationship is crucial in determining liability for torts committed by the employee or agent.
2.2 Importance of Employment Relationships
Defining employer-employee relationships clarifies the obligations and duties owed by both parties.
Establishes the rights vested in employees, distinguishing them from independent contractors.
3. The Doctrine of Respondeat Superior
Definition: A legal doctrine that holds a principal or employer liable for the negligent actions of an agent or employee that occur within the scope of their employment or agency.
Vicarious liability: The principal or employer may be held liable for losses caused by the negligent acts of the agent or servant.
4. Formation of Agency Relationships
4.1 Definition
Agency: A fiduciary relationship formed by the mutual consent of a principal and an agent. The agent agrees to act on behalf of the principal and under the principal's control.
4.2 Key Terminology
Principal: The party who employs another to act on their behalf.
Agent: The party who agrees to act on behalf of another.
4.3 Principal-Agent Relationship
A principal engages an agent, permitting the agent to conduct transactions and create obligations on behalf of the principal. The authority to act for the principal arises from agency contracts, and the principal must fulfill obligations arising from these contracts.
4.4 Who Can Initiate Agency Relationship
Any individual with the capacity to contract can appoint an agent.
Persons lacking contractual capacity (e.g., minors, insane individuals) cannot appoint agents. However, a court may appoint a guardian who can act on behalf of such persons.
4.5 Purpose of Agency Relationship
An agency may only be created to achieve lawful objectives. Contracts made for illegal purposes or against public policy are void and unenforceable, such as hiring an agent to commit a crime.
5. Kinds of Employment Relationships
Employer-Employee Relationship: Involves mutual consent and respect, but employees are not considered agents unless explicitly empowered to contract on behalf of the employer.
Principal-Agent Relationship: The agent acts on behalf of the principal to fulfill fiduciary duties.
Principal-Independent Contractor: Involves the hiring of independent contractors (e.g., lawyers, architects) to perform specific tasks without detailed oversight by the principal.
6. Authority in Agency Relationships
6.1 Types of Authority
Express Authority: Clearly defined in contracts or agreement, can be oral or written.
Implied Authority: Arises from the conduct of the parties; requires an understanding of the duties expected.
Apparent Authority: Formed when a principal creates the impression that an agent has authority, leading third parties to believe in the agent's authority.
Agency by Ratification: Occurs when a principal accepts an unauthorized action performed by someone claiming to be their agent.
6.2 Elements of Implied Agency
Consent: Implied from the conduct of both parties, even without explicit agreement.
Control: General understanding of the agent's actions being under the principal’s control or direction.
Benefit: Actions must further the principal's interests meaningfully.
7. Principal’s Duties to Agent
Compensation: Principal must compensate agents for their services unless the agent is performing gratuitously.
Indemnification: The principal must indemnify the agent for authorized expenses or losses incurred while performing duties.
Cooperation: The principal must provide necessary assistance for the completion of the agent’s responsibilities.
8. Agent’s Duties to Principal
Performance: Lawfully performing the duties as stated in the contract, demonstrating reasonable care, skill, and diligence.
Notification: Keeping the principal informed of relevant information and developments.
Accounting: Maintaining accurate records of all transactions, ensuring that money and benefits are reported appropriately and treated as the principal's property.
9. Termination of Agency
9.1 Termination by Act of Parties
Termination can occur via: mutual agreement, lapse of time, completion of purpose, or occurrence of a specified event.
9.2 Notification Requirements
Upon termination, it is essential for the principal to notify third parties about the termination, especially those who previously engaged with the agent. Individuals with knowledge of the agency require either direct or constructive notice.
9.3 Agency Coupled with an Interest
Definition: An agency established to benefit the agent, such as authorizing the agent to sell a debtor's property if the debtor defaults.
Characteristics: Irrevocable by the principal, does not terminate with death or incapacity but only when the agent's obligations are fulfilled.
9.4 Employment Contracts
Contracts without a specified termination time may be terminated at will by either party with no liability.
9.5 Wrongful Termination
Occurs when an agency contract is terminated in violation of its terms.
Nonbreaching parties are entitled to recover damages.
9.6 Termination by Operation of Law
Conditions under which an agency ends involuntarily include:
Death or insanity of either principal or agent.
Bankruptcy of the principal.
Changed circumstances.
War between the countries of the principal and agent.
Impossibility of performance.
Loss/destruction of the subject matter related to the agency.
Legal prohibition or illegality of the agency’s existence.
10. Case Study: Smith v. Delta Tau Delta, Inc. (2014)
Facts: A pledge at Wabash College dies due to alcohol poisoning during a hazing incident. Plaintiffs argue there was an agency relationship between the local fraternity and its national counterpart.
Issue: Was there an agency relationship that made the national fraternity liable for the local fraternity's actions?
Decision: The national fraternity does not exercise control over local members' decisions and actions, thus there is no principal-agent relationship. The local fraternity operates independently from the national fraternity.
11. Summary of Key Points
This section elucidates the complexity of agency relationships, their formation, types, and duties involving both principals and agents, alongside the implications of terminating these relationships.