Civil Procedure: Detailed Pretrial Procedures and Discovery Notes
The Complaint and Initial Filing
- Commencement of Action: An action is legally commenced for Statute of Limitations purposes when the complaint is filed with the court, not when it is served.
- Filing Procedure:
- The complaint is filed with the court along with a summons.
- The Clerk of Court signs the summons.
- Service of the complaint to the opposing party must occur within 90days of the filing.
- Required Elements of a Complaint: There are three basic elements needed for a valid complaint:
- Jurisdictional Statement: A short and plain statement showing the grounds for the court’s jurisdiction over the action.
- Statement of the Claim: A summary of the facts outlining what happened. This should be a factual summary, not a detailed legal theory of the case.
- Demand for Relief: A statement of the damages or relief being sought by the plaintiff.
- Pleading with Specificity: While general complaints only require a basic statement of facts, certain types of actions must be pled with much higher detail. Examples include:
- Fraud.
- Special Damages (unique money damages).
The Defendant's Answer
- Timing: The answer must be served within 21days after the service of the complaint.
- Content of the Answer:
- The defendant can admit claims, deny claims, or do both.
- Failure to Deny: If a claim is not specifically denied in the answer, it is deemed admitted.
- Affirmative Defenses: These must be explicitly and specifically pled in the answer itself. If not pled, they may be waived. Examples include:
- Contributory negligence.
- Statute of Frauds.
- Statute of Limitations.
- Illegality.
- Duress.
Amending Pleadings and the Concept of Relation Back
- General Standard: Courts follow a very liberal policy regarding the amendment of pleadings.
- Amendment as of Right: A party may amend their pleading once without court permission if it is done within 21days after the service of the original pleading.
- Amendment by Leave of Court: If the 21-day window has passed, the party needs the court's permission. The court will grant leave "when justice so requires."
- Relation Back of Amendments: This concept allows an amended pleading to be treated as if it were filed on the date of the original pleading (often to satisfy the Statute of Limitations).
- Amending a Claim or Defense: An amendment relates back to the original date if the new claim or defense arose out of the "same conduct, transaction, or occurrence" as the original pleading.
- Changing or Adding a Party: An amendment to change a party relates back only if three elements are met:
- The claim against the new party arose out of the "same conduct, transaction, or occurrence."
- Within 90days of the filing of the complaint, the new party received sufficient notice so they would not be prejudiced in maintaining a defense.
- The new party knew or should have known the action would have been brought against them but for a mistake concerning the proper party's identity.
Professional Responsibility Under Rule 11
- Attorney's Signature: When a lawyer signs and submits a document to the court, they are certifying the contents under Rule 11.
- Certification Standards: To the best of the lawyer's knowledge, information, and belief:
- The legal arguments are "warranted by existing law."
- The allegations have "evidentiary support."
- The filing is not being presented for an "improper purpose" (i.e., the lawyer is acting in good faith).
- Purpose: Rule 11 is designed to prevent attorneys from making baseless allegations or "making stuff up."
Counterclaims and Joinder of Parties
- Counterclaims: Claims brought by the defendant against the plaintiff. There are two types:
- Compulsory Counterclaim: Arises out of the "same transaction or occurrence" as the original claim. Because it is related, the court already has supplemental jurisdiction; no new independent jurisdiction is required. It must be brought in the current suit or it is lost.
- Permissive Counterclaim: Does not arise out of the same transaction or occurrence. Because it is unrelated, it requires its own independent basis for subject matter jurisdiction.
- Permissive Joinder of Parties: Multiple plaintiffs may join together, or a plaintiff may join multiple defendants, if:
- The claims arise from a "single transaction or occurrence."
- There is a "common question of law or fact."
- Compulsory Joinder: Occurs when a party MUST be joined because it would be unfair to litigate without them.
- Necessary Party: A party is necessary if not joining them would "impair their interest." If joining them would destroy the court's jurisdiction, the case can generally still proceed.
- Indispensable Party: A party is indispensable if not joining them would "prejudice" them. If their joinder would destroy jurisdiction, the case must be dismissed.
- Adding Claims: A party can join as many claims as they wish against an opposing party, provided the court has subject matter jurisdiction over each new claim.
Class Action Procedures
- Four Prerequisites for Certification:
- Size (Numerosity): The class is so large that joining all members is impractical.
- Common Question: There is a question of law or fact common to the entire class.
- Typicality: The claims of the named representatives are typical of the class members.
- Fair Representation: The representatives will fairly and adequately protect the interests of the class (no conflicts of interest).
- Three Categories of Class Actions:
- B1 Class Action: Based on preventing the impairment of the interests of class members. Members cannot opt-out. Notice is at the court's discretion.
- B2 Class Action: Sought when injunctive relief is the primary goal. Members cannot opt-out. Notice is at the court's discretion.
- B3 Class Action: Most common; involves "common questions" that make the class action the "superior method" for resolving the claim (e.g., mass torts). Members may opt-out. Notice must be given to all members (can be by mail if contact info is obtainable by reasonable effort).
- Diversity Jurisdiction in Class Actions:
- Only the citizenship of the named representatives is considered for diversity.
- Only one named representative must have a claim meeting the $75,000 amount in controversy requirement to bring in other members with smaller claims.
- Exception (CAFA): If the cumulative amount at stake for the entire class is $5million or more, the $75,000 individual requirement is waived for everyone.
- Settlement and Fees: The court must approve any settlement and must approve reasonable attorney's fees based on the size of the class.
Intervention and Interpleader
- Intervention: When a non-party seeks to join an ongoing suit.
- Intervention as of Right: No court permission is needed if the party has an interest in the property or transaction at issue, and their ability to protect that interest would be impeded or impaired if they were not involved.
- Permissive Intervention: Allowed if there is a common question of law or fact between the intervenor's claim/defense and the main suit. This requires court permission.
- Interpleader: A party (the stakeholder) who owes money or property to two or more people but does not know who to pay or how much to pay can force the claimants to litigate amongst themselves.
- Statutory Interpleader: Requires only $500 at stake; allows nationwide service of process; requires "minimal diversity" (any two claimants are diverse); the stakeholder must deposit the money/property with the court or post a bond.
- Rule Interpleader: Requires $75,000 amount in controversy; no nationwide service; requires complete diversity; no requirement to deposit the money with the court.
Impleader and Crossclaims
- Third-Party Impleader: A defendant believes a third party is liable to them for all or part of the plaintiff's claim against the defendant (typically for contribution or indemnification). The defendant impleads them as a "third-party defendant."
- Crossclaims: A claim by one party against a co-party (e.g., Defendant 1 vs. Defendant 2).
- The claim must arise out of the same transaction or occurrence as the original action.
- The party must be asking for actual relief (damages), not just asserting the other is liable.
Discovery Scope and Protections
- Basic Search Definition: Information is discoverable if it is not privileged, relevant, and proportional to the needs of the case.
- Work Product Doctrine: Materials prepared by or for counsel in anticipation of trial are generally immune from discovery (privileged).
- Qualified Immunity: Work product is discoverable only if there is a "substantial need" for the material and it cannot be obtained by "any other substantially equivalent means" without "undue hardship."
- Absolute Immunity: Court protection is absolute for mental impressions, conclusions, legal opinions, or legal theories of the attorney.
- Witnesses: Names and locations of potential witnesses and lists of documents to be used in the case are discoverable.
- Expert Discovery:
- Testifying Experts: Must be identified to the other side. They must prepare a report detailing their opinions, the basis for those opinions, data/exhibits, and their compensation.
- Non-Testifying Experts: Information is only discoverable under "exceptional circumstances" where it is impractical to get the info elsewhere.
- Duty to Supplement: Parties must supplement discovery responses in a timely manner if they learn the original disclosure was incomplete or incorrect.
Discovery Methods and Sanctions
- Methods:
- Depositions: Oral or written questions. Can be of a party or non-party. Non-parties require a subpoena. Limit of 10depositions per side; the same person cannot be deposed twice without permission.
- Interrogatories: Written questions/answers. Only for parties. Limit of 25 per party.
- Request for Admission: Request for a party to admit facts. Admitted facts are "conclusively established" for trial.
- Request to Produce Documents: Request for papers, photos, etc., in a party's possession, custody, or control.
- Physical or Mental Exam: Available only when the condition is "in controversy." Requires a court order and a showing of "good cause."
- Discovery Disputes:
- Object to Request: Used if the info requested is not relevant.
- Protective Order: Used to stop discovery intended to annoy, embarrass, or cause undue burden.
- Motion to Compel: Used when a party blatantly refuses to cooperate with legitimate discovery.
- Sanctions: Courts use a sliding scale starting with fees and costs. More severe sanctions include establishing facts as true, barring defenses, dismissal of the action, or contempt of court.
Pre-trial Conferences and Injunctive Relief
- Types of Conferences:
- Conference of the Parties: Parties must meet to discuss the case, settlement, and discovery. They must submit a discovery plan to the court.
- Scheduling Conference: The court must hold this to limit time for motions and discovery. A scheduling order must be issued within 90days of filing.
- Final Pre-trial Conference: The judge may hold this to expedite trial or push settlement. If held, the judge must enter a pre-trial order, which is only modifiable to prevent "manifest injustice."
- Injunctive Relief:
- Temporary Restraining Order (TRO): Used to prevent "immediate irreparable harm." Can be granted without notice. Expires as stated in the order, with a maximum duration of 14days.
- Preliminary Injunction: Used if the restraint needs to last longer than 14days. Requires notice to the other party and a hearing. The standard is to prevent "irreparable harm."