Trennert CH6-7-1
WHITE MAN'S MEDICINE: Government Doctors and the Navajo (1863-1955)
Author Information
Robert A. Trennert
Published by University of New Mexico Press, Albuquerque, 1998
CONTENTS
Major Chapters
Worlds Apart: Contrasting Medical Practices
Army Doctors: Western Medicine Comes to the Navajo
Missionaries and Politicians
A Like Barbarism
National Disgrace
A Scourge on the Land
Epidemics, Campaigns, and Experimentation
Transition
New Deal
End of an Era
Epilogue
Notes
Bibliography
Index
Key Themes and Concepts
Health Care History Among Navajo
Between 1863-1955, the quality and accessibility of medical care for the Navajo people changed little despite numerous government initiatives.
Doctor Calvin K. Smith, serving in the late 1800s, noted poor working conditions and the inadequacy of medical facilities. No hospitals or trained nurses, reliance on basic remedies.
Efforts to establish better healthcare often failed due to lack of funding and prioritization of other political agendas.
Indian Service's attempts to eliminate traditional healing practices were largely unsuccessful, with continual reliance on traditional "medicine men."
Epidemics Facing the Navajo
Tuberculosis became a significant and deadly health crisis among the Navajo, with various reports indicating high morbidity rates.
Crowding in schools aggravated the spread of diseases like tuberculosis and trachoma, leading to numerous fatalities among children and the community.
Recommendations for better medical facilities were often disregarded, exacerbating public health issues.
Trachoma, a highly contagious eye disease, spread rapidly and resulted in widespread blindness with inadequate treatment options available.
Government Medical Efforts
Indian Service and Federal Response
The Indian Service recognized and acknowledged the gravity of health issues beginning in the early 1900s; however, meaningful reforms were often lacking.
Annual appropriations for Indian health services were typically insufficient, significantly limiting medical staffing and resources.
Relief measures were complicated by government bureaucracy, making effective healthcare delivery to remote Indian populations challenging.
Attempts to Change Public Health Strategies
The hiring of experienced medical personnel was hindered by low salaries and poor working conditions, causing high turnover rates among doctors.
The Meriam Report of 1928 identified profound inadequacies in government healthcare services, calling for comprehensive overhaul in the approach to Indian health care.
Suggested improvements included establishing permanent medical facilities and a greater focus on preventive medicine.
Cultural Dynamics
Resistance to Western Medicine
The Navajo community was deeply rooted in traditional healing practices, which they viewed as effective and culturally relevant.
Attempts to suppress these methods often resulted in mistrust toward government healthcare providers, hindering cooperation.
Cultural clashes between traditional Native practices and Western medicine reflected broader themes of colonization and assimilation policies.
Summary of Medical Events from 1863-1955
Despite some advancements like established hospitals and medical campaigns, overall health outcomes for the Navajo population remained dismal, with continued high disease burdens.
Government strategies often did not resonate with Native populations, leading to dual healthcare systems where traditional practices persisted alongside the government medical system.