Chemical Weathering Notes
Consequences of Chemical Weathering
When igneous and metamorphic rocks are exposed to water and atmospheric gases, their minerals decompose selectively at varying rates.
Chemical weathering products include:
Compounds formed during incongruent solution of primary minerals.
Ions and molecules dissolved in water.
Resistant minerals liberated by decomposition.
Release of noble gases (He, Ne, Ar, Kr, Xe, Rn) and other gases (H₂, hydrocarbons, N₂, etc.) into the atmosphere
Newly formed compounds accumulate as residual mantle or regolith (saprolite) with unreacted minerals and undecomposed rock pieces.
Further modification of saprolite leads to soil formation, which supports plant life and fauna.
Saprolite is ultimately removed by erosion through gravity, running water, or wind.
Chemical weathering initiates the mass migration of sediment from continents to ocean basins.
It also starts geochemical cycles, releasing elements from rock reservoirs into solution for transport to the oceans.
The practical consequences of chemical weathering include rock decomposition, alteration of water's chemical composition, and dispersion of ions from mineral deposits.
It contributes to the environment's ability to sustain life.
Changes in atmospheric and hydrosphere composition due to human activities can alter our habitat in unpredictable and potentially harmful ways.
Geochemists study how anthropogenic activities perturb natural geochemical processes, predict their effects on the environment, and alert about potentially harmful changes.
Changes in Chemical Composition of Rocks
Comparing major-element oxide concentrations in fresh vs. weathered rock samples reveals the effects of chemical weathering.
The "closed table effect" can mislead direct comparisons because chemical analyses in weight percent must sum to 100.
A change in one constituent causes apparent changes in all others.
For example, loss of an element increases the apparent concentrations of others and vice versa.
Differences in major element concentrations between weathered and unweathered specimens are unreliable indicators of actual gains/losses.
Identifying real gains/losses relies on assuming one major-element oxide remains constant.
is often chosen due to the limited solubility of at pH 6-8.
This choice aligns with the convention of Al conservation during incongruent solution of aluminosilicate minerals.
, , or may be selected if Al is mobile in highly acidic or basic conditions.
Studies on chemical weathering of basaltic igneous rocks are referenced (Eggleston et al., 1987; Claridge and Campbell, 1984; Colman, 1982; Hendricks and Whittig, 1968).
References also include the weathering of silicate minerals in general (Loughnan, 1969; Carroll, 1970; Lindsay, 1979; Colman and Dethier, 1986).
Example of Chemical Weathering Effects on Basalt
Data from Table 19.1 is examined for a basalt from Paraná, Brazil, and its saprolite.
The saprolite has lower concentrations of , CaO, MgO, , , MnO, and compared to the basalt.
It has higher concentrations of , , , and LOI (loss on ignition), including adsorbed water, water in crystal lattices, fluid inclusions, of carbonates, and of sulfides.
The decreases and increases balance so the sum of concentrations equals 100.
Real losses are partly compensated by apparent increases in other components, and vice versa.
Interpretation requires recalculating the analysis assuming one oxide remains constant.
Constant Oxide Method
is selected as the constant oxide, increasing from 12.3% to 26.3% due to weathering.
Concentration in weight percent equals grams per 100 g of rock.
100 g of basalt contained 12.3 g .
If the amount of remained constant, the increase is due to a weight reduction in rock.
The weight of the rock becomes g, indicating 53.3 g was removed by weathering per 100 g of basalt.
Weight loss factor:
Amounts of other oxide constituents are calculated by multiplying their concentrations in the saprolite by the weight-loss factor (w).
For example, remaining after weathering is g.
All concentrations are similarly multiplied by the weight-loss factor; remaining amounts are in column 3.
These amounts sum to 46.7 g, confirming that 53.3 g of material was lost per 100 g of basalt.
Actual gains/losses are determined by comparing column 3 (amounts remaining) to column 1 (basalt analysis).
For , the real loss is g., while for is g.
was lost even though its concentration in the saprolite is higher (21.5%) than in the basalt (15.1%).
The same applies to , which was diminished by 1.34 g despite a higher concentration in the saprolite.
Column 4 shows weathering caused real losses of all constituents, except , , and relative to constant .
The final step is to rank oxide components by loss magnitude.
Losses are expressed in percent of the original amount in basalt.
For example, basalt lost % of its .
Greatest losses occurred for CaO and (99.6%), MgO (97.1%), (96.5%), and (89.1%), followed by MnO (75.0%), (67.6%), (42.0%), and (33.5%).
Chemical weathering of basalt in Paraná forms saprolite composed primarily of , , , and .
Normative Mineral Composition of Weathering Products
Mineral composition of saprolite (Table 19.1) can be studied via x-ray diffraction or electron-transmission microscopy.
Identification is difficult when weathering products are poorly crystallized or amorphous.
Volcanic igneous rocks face a similar issue due to being cryptocrystalline or glassy.
Igneous petrology overcomes this by calculating mineral abundances from chemical analyses, resulting in a mineral norm and normative minerals.
Procedures for calculating mineral norms of volcanic rocks can be adapted to estimate mineral abundances in partly amorphous weathering products.
Saprolite contains varying amounts of minerals from the original rock, amorphous compounds, and minerals formed during weathering.
Mineral Composition
Common primary minerals include: quartz, biotite, K-feldspar, hornblende, pyroxene, olivine plagioclase, rutile muscovite, magnetite, ilmenite
Secondary minerals expected include: kaolinite, smectite gibbsite amorphous silica hematite goethite pyrolusite
The investigator chooses minerals based on bedrock composition, climatic conditions, and available information on mineral composition.
The mineral norm is an approximation, making mineral selection and composition arbitrary.
The saprolite (Table 19.1) is mainly composed of , , , and , occurring in secondary minerals like kaolinite and goethite.
is assigned to K-feldspar, and CaO to plagioclase, MgO to enstatite, MnO to pyrolusite, to ilmenite, and to apatite and berlinite.
Other selections are possible but less likely (e.g., as quartz in granite-gneiss bedrock).
Alternative selections have little effect on the conclusions derivable from the norm.
The calculation of the mineral norm of the saprolite is in Table 19.2.
Mineral formulas are in oxide form, and oxide component concentrations are recalculated to millimoles per 100 g of saprolite.
LOI is assumed to be .
Primary minerals derived from the basalt are satisfied first, then secondary weathering products (goethite, pyrolusite, kaolinite, and gibbsite) are made from the remaining oxides.
likely occurred as ilmenite (), which is resistant but may alter to and/or leucoxene ().
The saprolite lacks sufficient CaO for leucoxene, so is expressed as ilmenite in the norm.
Calculation Steps
Begin with primary minerals and convert all available , 1.38 millimoles (mmol), into K-feldspar.
Reduce available by 1.38 mmol and by mmol.
The amount of K-feldspar in grams per 100 g of saprolite is: g/100 g
Next, all available is used to make albite, reducing the remaining molar amounts of and proportionately.
Convert the millimolar amount of albite to a weight in grams, as in equation 19.3.
Feldspar amounts remaining are small, with residual K-feldspar (0.77 g/100 g) more abundant than albite (0.17 g/100 g).
The amount of CaO is used to make 0.35 mmol of apatite (), and the remaining 0.418 mmol of is combined with to make secondary berlinite (), leaving 255.5 mmol of .
Because all available CaO was used for apatite, none remains for anorthite, which is presumed absent in the saprolite.
MgO is converted into 0.65 g of enstatite () without difficulty.
To convert into ilmenite (), the must be recast as FeO.
The amount of Fe in the saprolite is mmol/100 g, making an equal number of moles of FeO.
49.5 mmol of FeO is consumed in making 7.51 g of ilmenite from 49.5 mmol of , leaving mmol of FeO, equivalent to 109.3 mmol of .
The remaining is converted into 19.4 g of goethite () by combining with an equal millimolar amount of .
MnO is assigned to 0.12 g of pyrolusite (), and the remaining is made into 66.0 g of kaolinite ().
This leaves a residue of 56.3 mmol of and 68.3 mmol of .
Convert into 3.38 g of amorphous silica, or opal, or chalcedony, based on crystallinity.
Remaining is converted into 1.22 g of water, coating the saprolite's solid particles.
Gibbsite does not occur in the norm because is more abundant than .
The normative mineral composition of the saprolite in units of grams per 100 g or weight percent is:
kaolinite 66.0 %
goethite 19.4 %
ilmenite 7.5 %
amorph. 3.38 %
water 1.2 %
misc. traces 1.9 %
Chemical weathering has converted the basalt into a mixture of kaolinite and goethite with lesser amounts of Ti-bearing minerals and amorphous silica.
Only trace amounts of the primary minerals K-feldspar, albite, pyroxene, and apatite remain.
The absence of gibbsite suggests that the activity of silicic acid in the water at was greater than mol/L in accordance with the kaolinite-gibbsite boundary in Figure 12.1.
Susceptibility of Minerals to Weathering
Igneous and metamorphic rock minerals vary in their susceptibility to chemical weathering.
Dissolution reactions of minerals occur at different rates.
The kinetics of many dissolution reactions have been studied to understand rates and mechanisms of mineral dissolution in water (Colman and Dethier, 1986).
Soil chemists are interested in the rates at which plant nutrients (Na+, K+, Ca2+, Fe2+, Mg2+, and P) are released by minerals in soils under different conditions (McLelland, 1950).
Geochemists are interested in the processes that control the rates of congruent and incongruent dissolution.
Important contributions to this subject include papers by Wollast (1967), Helgeson (1971, 1972), Busenberg and Clemency (1976), Holdren and Berner (1979), Berner and Holdren (1979), and Tole et al. (1986).
Factors Affecting Dissolution
Experimental studies with powdered mineral samples commonly showed a decrease in the rate of dissolution with time.
Cations are released and pH rises within one minute after powdered feldspar is placed in water, suggesting cation exchange for to form "hydrogen-feldspar" (Garrels and Howard, 1957).
Hydrolysis (Section 10.2) occurs if feldspar is regarded as a salt of the weak hypothetical acid .
Cations and silica are lost from feldspar grains in nonstoichiometric proportions, coating grains with kaolinite or gibbsite, retarding further dissolution.
Surfaces of grains of powdered minerals are coated with small adhering particles having large surface areas (Grandstaff, 1977), increasing initial dissolution rates.
Grinding may damage the crystal lattice of surface layers of grains, also increasing initial dissolution rates of mineral powders.
Mineral grains from weathering environments examined with a scanning electron microscope did not show the expected layer of alteration products (Berner and Schott, 1982).
Mineral grains dissolve preferentially where crystallographic dislocations exist, producing etch pits that expand and deepen.
The rate of mineral dissolution depends on the density of etch pits per unit area of surface and hence on the abundance of dislocations within the mineral grains.
The layer of weathering products adhering to grain surfaces is permeable and nonprotective and does not affect dissolution kinetics.
Relative susceptibility can be determined from the abundances of primary minerals in saprolites formed at different weathering stages.
Goldich (1938) studied Archean gneisses in the Minnesota River valley.
Degree of weathering is indicated by concentrations because is nearly immobile during chemical weathering, and its concentration rises as weathering progresses.
Goldich (1938) classified saprolite samples from granitic gneiss in the Morton-Redwood Falls area of Minnesota using this criterion; chemical compositions are shown in Figure 19.1A.
Weathering Trends
Chemical weathering of granitic gneiss in southern Minnesota causes rapid decreases in the concentrations of , CaO, and MgO.
and concentrations decline more slowly as weathering progresses.
The concentrations of , total Fe as , , and actually increase.
A constant-oxide calculation for the most highly weathered saprolite from Minnesota confirms real gains in , , and relative to constant , while all other constituents were lost in varying amounts.
Changes in chemical compositions of progressively weathered saprolites reflect what is happening to primary minerals.
Goldich (1938) determined the mineral compositions of the granitic gneiss and two saprolites formed from it.
The data, in Figure 19.1B, show rapid loss of plagioclase and biotite and slower removal of K-feldspar and quartz.
K-feldspar is almost completely removed from the most highly weathered saprolite, while about 20% of quartz and 6% of magnetite and ilmenite remain.
The principal weathering product is kaolinite, which accumulates in the saprolite, making up 66% by volume of the most highly weathered rock.
Changing abundances of rock-forming minerals in saprolites reflect their susceptibilities to chemical weathering.
Figure 19.1B shows plagioclase is more susceptible than K-feldspar, and biotite is destroyed early.
Quartz and K-feldspar increase initially due to preferential loss of plagioclase and biotite; K-feldspar is ultimately completely removed, while quartz decreases by about 30% in the most highly weathered saprolite.
Magnetite and ilmenite also rise, indicating their resistance, but they eventually decompose to form secondary minerals like goethite and leucoxene.
Bowen's Reaction Series
Goldich (1938) related the susceptibilities of rock-forming silicate minerals to their position in Bowen's reaction series (Figure 19.2).
Olivine and Ca-plagioclase are most susceptible, followed by pyroxene, hornblende, biotite, and Na-plagioclase.
K-feldspar is more resistant and is surpassed only by muscovite and quartz.
Susceptibility to weathering of rock-forming silicate minerals decreases with their decreasing temperatures of crystallization from magma.
Exceptions to Goldich's generalization may occur locally due to the environmental conditions strongly affecting the progress of reactions in chemical weathering.
*
Alternative Explanations
The observed differences in the susceptibility to weathering of rock-forming silicate minerals can be explained by considering activity diagrams.
The anorthite diagram contains calcite, which restricts the activity of Ca2+ in natural solutions based on partial pressure and pH.
The solubility limit of calcite prevents the ratio from rising to levels at which equilibrium with anorthite is possible.
Anorthite cannot be stable in contact with water at the Earth's surface and dissolves incongruently to form kaolinite or gibbsite, depending on the activity of silicic acid.
K-feldspar (Figure 12.1) and albite (Figure 12.2A) activity diagrams lack solubility limits other than amorphous silica because alkali metal carbonates are soluble.
and ratios of natural solutions can rise until the solutions are in equilibrium with K-feldspar and albite, respectively.
Hence, these minerals are stable in contact with water and weather more slowly than anorthite and Ca-bearing plagioclase.
The differences in susceptibility to weathering among Mg-bearing silicates (olivine, pyroxene, amphibole) can be rationalized using Figure 12.5.
Olivine, in the form of forsterite (), dissolves congruently by releasing and into solution.
The ratio of natural solutions is restricted by the solubility limits imposed by magnesite (), serpentine (), and sepiolite ().
Natural solutions on the Earth's surface cannot be in equilibrium with forsterite.
The same is true of pyroxenes (enstatite, ) and amphiboles (anthophyllite, ), but the ratios required to stabilize these minerals at a particular value of are lower than that needed to stabilize olivine.
Reactions between olivine and water are further removed from equilibrium than reactions between pyroxene and water and between amphibole and water.
Olivine is more susceptible to weathering than pyroxene, which is more susceptible than amphibole, as implied by Bowen's reaction series.
Other Minerals
Sulfides, carbonates, and oxides may coexist with silicate minerals in ore deposits.
The effects of chemical weathering on such rocks are of great interest to geologists.
The relative susceptibilities to weathering of sulfide minerals will be considered in Chapter 21 using Eh-pH diagrams for the sulfides of different metals.
Metal dispersion from weathered sulfide-bearing rocks causes local geochemical anomalies in the saprolite and soil.
These geochemical anomalies are used to locate potential ore deposits via systematic geochemical exploration surveys.
Anomalous metal concentrations in soils associated with mineralized rocks may be a natural geochemical health hazard.
Sulfides and carbonates (calcite, aragonite, dolomite) are more susceptible to weathering than silicate minerals (olivine, plagioclase, pyroxene, etc.).
Oxides (magnetite, ilmenite, chromite, rutile, cassiterite, etc.) are less susceptible.
The resistance to chemical weathering of certain accessory minerals has interesting consequences.