Fuel Cells: Fundamentals, Technologies, and Stationary Applications
Overview
Lecture topic: Moderne Energiesysteme with a focus on Brennstoffzellen (fuel cells).
Key question: How does energy conversion in a fuel cell work, especially for a single Membranbrennstoffzelle (Membane Fuel Cell, MFC)?
Hydrogen as the common fuel for electricity, heat, and combined heat-and-power (CHP) applications.
Typical fuel for operation: Erdgas (natural gas) used to generate hydrogen via reforming (Reformierung).
Structure of the talk: (1) energy conversion in one MFC, (2) hydrogen source and reforming, (3) two example stationary CHP applications.
Historical context: development from Schönbein (late 18th to 19th c.), Grove, Siemens, Ostwald; early concepts and limits of efficiency and materials challenges.
Modern drivers: environmental concerns and higher efficiencies spur renewed interest in fuel cells for stationary and mobile uses.
Hydrogen can be produced by electrolysis, reforming of fossil/biogenic fuels, or from biomass; renewable hydrogen is often termed a secondary energy carrier.
Emphasis on stationary systems in Kraft-Wärme-Kopplung (KWK) and the broad applicability across scales (milliwatts to megawatts).
Core history and concept highlights
Sir William Grove (early 19th c.) conceptualized cells as an inverse of electrolysis; Grove’s gas battery inspired later work on practical fuel cells.
Werner von Siemens (1880s) pushed the idea aside due to dynamics of dynamos and competing technologies.
Wilhelm Ostwald (early 20th c.) quantified theoretical potential for fuel cells; theoretical efficiencies around 83% were forecast, spurring many design proposals.
Postwar developments: Francis Bacon built practical early fuel cells (alkaline) with hydrogen and alkaline electrolyte.
1960s: NASA used a low-temperature membrane fuel cell (PFSA) with perfluorinated sulfonic acid polymer membrane in Gemini missions; later alkaline and PAFC/LMS developments followed.
End of 1970s and 1980s: hydrogen-based, high-temperature fuel cell research rose due to interest in CO2-free power generation; phosphoric acid fuel cells (PAFC) at ~200°C and solid oxide/fused carbonate developments emerged.
1980s–late 1980s: renewed interest in fuel cells due to energy efficiency and environmental concerns; emphasis on stationary and mobile uses, including automotive concepts.
Hydrogen sources: water electrolysis (green hydrogen) and reforming of hydrocarbons/biomass; reforming is dominant for hydrogen production in many systems.
Thermodynamics and fundamental voltages of a single membrane fuel cell (MFC)
Standard reaction enthalpy (formation of water) is exothermic with magnitude ~ riangleHextupper=241.8extkJ/mol for the upper heating value (UHV) pathway and similarly for lower heating value (LHV) cases around 241.8 kJ/mol in the problem's framing.
Thermoneutral (enthalpy-based) cell voltage for the upper heating value (UHV): Uextthextupper=nF−riangleHextupperextwithn=2F=96487extC/molhereforeUextthextupperextapproximately1.48extV
Thermoneutral (enthalpy-based) cell voltage for the lower heating value (LHV): Uextthextlower=nF−riangleHextlowerhereforeUextthextlowerextapproximately1.25extV
Gibbs free energy (standard) gives reversible cell voltage:
E0=nFriangleG0
Realistic versus ideal: actual single-cell voltage under load is reduced by overpotentials due to activation, ohmic, and concentration losses.
Open-circuit voltage per cell (ruhespannung): around 1.0 V (not equal to the ideal 1.23/1.18 V, or to the thermoneutral 1.25–1.48 V; losses exist). The polarization curve shows four main loss regions:
Activation losses (onset) at low current density due to electrode kinetics (catalyst activation).
Ohmic losses (linear region) from electronic and ionic resistances.
Concentration losses (mass-transport) at high current densities due to limited supply of hydrogen and oxygen to the catalyst layers.
The total loss can be expressed as: u=Uextth−(extactivation+extohmic+extconcentration)
The maximum electrical power per cell occurs at some intermediate current; at very low current, voltage near open-circuit but power low; at very high current, voltage collapses due to diffusion limits.
Practical in-cell example (MEA): if a cell delivers ~0.6 V under load, the corresponding ideal efficiency relative to LH or UH references is:
If using LH 1.25 V reference, extefficiency=1.250.6=0.48(48%)
At 0.7 V: extefficiency=1.250.7=0.56(56%)
The polarization curve can be summarized as: at zero current, high voltage; as current increases, voltage falls; the resulting power P = V × I peaks somewhere between.
Single-Cell structure and materials (Membrane Fuel Cell, PEMFC)
Core component: Proton exchange membrane (PEM) that is proton-conductive; separates fuel sides (anode) and oxidant side (cathode).
Cathode and anode catalysts: typically platinum-based catalyst layers near the membrane.
Gas diffusion layers (GDL): carbon fiber paper on both sides to distribute reactant gases to the catalyst surface and to conduct electrons.
Bipolar plates: channels machined into plates to supply hydrogen to the anode and air (O2) to the cathode; also serve as electrical contacts.
Cell stack composition (7 layers):
2 bipolar plates, 2 GDLs (left and right), 2 catalyst layers, and the central membrane – total 7 layers.
Physical dimensions and thickness: typical PEM membranes ~100 micrometers thick in older designs; automotive membranes now ~10–15 μm (significant reduction to enhance performance and reduce costs).
Open-circuit voltage per cell is near 1.0 V; under load, voltages drop with current due to loss mechanisms.
Stack concept: many cells in series to achieve higher voltage; e.g., 100 cells yield roughly 100 × ~1 V = ~100 V; 200 cells ~200 V; 300 cells ~150–300 V depending on per-cell voltage and design.
Practical automotive example: a stack with ~300 cells in series; typical single-area size around DIN A4 for the active area per stack.
Real-world examples and components:
Bipolar plates made from polymer composite plastic (injection-molded) to simplify channels and gas paths; reduces manufacturing steps.
ZBT Duisburg and CPT (Siemens) examples of stacks used in research and industry.
U-boat fuel cell stack by Siemens demonstrates long-life, fuel-flexible operation using reformate gas.
Performance example (ZBT fuel cell):
20 cells in a stack; open-circuit ~19 V => ~0.95 V per cell.
Under load, voltage drops; at around 40 A, power is ~370 W (20 cells × ~9.8 V per cell ≈ 196 V total, delivering ~370 W) – illustrating the high current and power relationship.
Teillast (partial-load) operation advantage: PEMFCs often show higher efficiency at partial load than at full load due to higher cell voltage at lower currents; this is a favorable trait for mobile applications (city driving, etc.).
Fuel-cell types, operating temperatures, and typical roles
Alkaline Fuel Cell (AFC):
Electrolyte: hydroxide (OH−) in solution.
Temperature: relatively low (~80°C).
Historical use: aerospace/space applications; largely supplanted by PEM due to issues in modern gas streams.
Fuel: hydrogen-rich reformates; CO tolerance higher than PEM; supports high-temperature exhaust heat usage.
SOFC (Solid Oxide Fuel Cell):
Electrolyte: solid oxide (oxide ion conductor, e.g., O2−).
Temperature: very high (~1000°C).
Fuel flexibility with reformates; very high electrical efficiency potential, especially in hybrid configurations with turbines.
Key purity requirements by type (gas inlet hydrogen quality):
PEMFC (80°C operation): CO ≤ ~10 ppm (ppm of CO in the hydrogen stream); sulfur compounds also problematic; requires very high purity hydrogen.
PAFC (200°C): CO tolerance up to ~1% CO in the gas stream; less strict than PEMFC but still requires gas cleanup.
SOFC/MCFC: higher tolerance to CO at high temperatures but still benefit from clean gas streams for longevity and performance; CO/CH4 content affects catalysts and reforming balance.
Hydrogen sources and reforming considerations (brief):
Direct electrolysis of water to generate hydrogen (green hydrogen) is ideal but energy-intensive; commonly combined with renewable energy.
Reforming of hydrocarbon fuels (gas, LNG, LPG, diesel, jet fuel, etc.) to produce hydrogen-rich gas mixtures for PEM or high-temperature cells; requires desulfurization and gas cleanup to meet purity requirements.
Typical reforming processes: steam reforming, autothermal reforming (ATR), partial oxidation (POX), and their combinations.
Gas clean-up and conditioning steps in reforming pathways:
Desulfurization to remove sulfur-containing compounds that poison catalysts.
Water-gas shift (WGS) to convert CO + H2O → CO2 + H2, boosting hydrogen yield and reducing CO content.
CO cleanup and selective oxidation (SeOx or SeOxidation) to reduce CO to CO2, particularly important for PEMFC at low temperatures to protect catalyst surfaces.
Final gas polishing for PEM feed: aiming for CO ≤ 10 ppm and very low sulfur and trace contaminants.
Reforming pathways and gas-quality impacts
Steam reforming (SR):
CH4 + H2O → CO2 + 4 H2 (typical overall stoichiometry with water adding).
Requires high-temperature reformer (~800°C) and a nickel-based catalyst; endothermic reforming; heat supplied by a burner.
Product gas typically contains ~80% H2 and ~20% CO2/CO before shift/conversion.
Water-gas shift (WGS):
CO + H2O ↔ CO2 + H2; used to reduce CO content and increase H2 yield.
Performed in two stages often: high-temperature shift (HTS, ~350–400°C, Fe-Cr or similar catalysts) and low-temperature shift (LTS, ~200°C, Cu-Zn catalysts).
Autothermal reforming (ATR):
CH4 + 1/2 O2 → CO2 + 2 H2 (and other products); combines reforming with partial oxidation in one reactor;
introduces nitrogen in the reformate due to air; hydrogen content is typically lower than SR, with higher CO if not cooled properly.
Partial oxidation (POX):
CH4 + O2 → CO2 + 2 H2; no external heat input required; gas contains more nitrogen and CO due to the oxidizing conditions; hydrogen content is generally lower than SR.
Autothermal reforming vs steam reforming: gas quality (hydrogen content) varies; SR provides highest hydrogen content (≈80%) with little to no inert nitrogen, while POX introduces inert N2 and CO; ATR lies in between.
Gas-cleaning sequence for PEM feed:
Desulfurization (to remove sulfur compounds before reforming).
Reforming (SR/ATR/POX) to generate a hydrogen-rich gas.
Shift conversion (HTS/LTS) to convert CO to CO2 and produce additional H2.
Gas-cleanup step (SeOx) to reduce residual CO to levels acceptable for PEM (CO ≤ ~10 ppm).
Final polishing to ensure minimal contaminants (S, halogens, heavy metals) that could degrade membranes or catalysts.
Gas quality and temperature dependence: as the operating temperature decreases (toward PEM ranges), the requirement for gas purity increases (CO tolerance becomes tighter) due to adsorption/desorption dynamics on Pt surfaces.
Practical example (4 kW reformer, ZBT Duisburg):
Hydrogen production capacity around 4 kW; can power a fuel cell stack of ~1.5–2 kW electrical output.
Product gas around 80% H2 across a broad load range; CO ~0.6% at full load; CH4 remaining ~1%; total CO2 and H2O in product gas.
Reformer efficiency (stand-alone) > 75% at full load; overall system including burner efficiency influences overall energy balance.
System integration: from reformer to PEM fuel cell stack (illustrative example)
Functional schematic for natural gas reforming to PEM feed:
Desulfurization unit to remove sulfur-containing compounds.
Reforming stage (SR, ATR, or a mix) with heat supplied by a burner to provide endothermic heat.
Shift conversion (HTS then LTS) to maximize hydrogen and reduce CO.
Gas-cleaning stage (selective oxidation to reduce CO to CO2 to meet PEM tolerances, e.g., CO < 10 ppm).
Feed to PEM fuel cell stack (hydrogen-rich gas).
Practical demonstration project:
A 4 kW hydrogen reformer developed at ZBT Duisburg to supply a 1.5–2 kW PEM stack; includes reformer burner, heat exchangers, shift converter, and selective oxidation.
Measured reformer outputs show ~80% H2 in product gas across load range; CO around 0.6% at full load; methane remainder around 1% at peak load.
Reforming efficiency > 75% (steam reforming conditions) with post-reform gas cleaning improving purity for PEM feed.
Stationary fuel-cell CHP applications and performance benchmarks
KWK (Kraft-Wärme-Kopplung) or micro-CHP contexts:
Various manufacturers offer micro-CHP fuel-cell systems around 1 kW electrical output based on PEM or SOFC; typical electrical efficiency ranges between 30–45% for standalone electricity generation.
Systems designed for domestic energy supply, with heat recovery providing significant thermal energy, raising total (electrical + thermal) efficiency up to 80–90% or higher in some configurations.
Some systems claim total efficiency up to ~85–90% with integrated heat recovery; long-term economic viability remains challenging due to high capital costs.
Larger scale CHP and industrial power plants:
SOFC systems and high-temperature fuel cells can achieve substantially higher electrical efficiencies, with hybrid configurations (e.g., SOFC with gas turbines) achieving electrical efficiencies above 60% and even above 70–75% in gas-turbine hybrids.
In many configurations, micro-CHP units can operate more efficiently due to favorable partial-load operation compared to conventional power plants or engines.
Comparative emissions (stationary fuel cells vs conventional technology):
Emissions for PEM fuel cells (CO, NMHC, NOx) can be negligible relative to conventional internal combustion engines and gas turbines; some data from DLR shows near-zero emissions for CO, NMHC, and NOx under certain operating conditions.
Relative environmental benefits include very low emissions when operated on hydrogen or highly clean reformate gas.
Efficiency and performance across scales (from small to large installations):
At small scales (kW range), PEM and PAFCs offer modularity and quick start-up advantages; at larger scales, MCFC and SOFC-based systems can leverage higher efficiencies and heat recovery.
The general trend is: higher temperatures (MCFC/SOFC) enable higher electrical efficiencies in combined cycles with turbines; lower-temperature PEM may provide lower electricity efficiency but superior control and integration for CHP with heat recovery.
Practical engineering and design considerations
Materials and manufacturing challenges:
Fuel-cell performance is strongly influenced by the choice of electrolytes and catalysts; materials science remains a core challenge (durability, poisoning resistance, temperature compatibility).
In PEM, membrane hydration is critical; membranes need to be thin (10–15 μm in automotive) to reduce ohmic losses while maintaining adequate moisture.
Bipolar plates and GDLs are often produced with injection-molded polymer composites to reduce cost and enable complex channel geometries for gas distribution.
Gas purity and system reliability:
Gas feed quality is a critical driver of lifetime and performance; lower-temperature systems (e.g., PEM) require much purer hydrogen (CO ≤ ~10 ppm) compared to high-temperature systems (e.g., PAFC, MCFC).
Sulfur compounds and particulates must be removed upstream to avoid catalyst poisoning and membrane degradation.
System integration architectures:
A fuel cell stack by itself produces electrical energy; in stationary CHP, the exhaust heat is captured for space heating or hot water, greatly increasing overall system efficiency.
In automotive applications, stacks are designed in large series, with per-cell voltages around 0.6–0.8 V under load; hundreds of cells in series yield usable voltages for propulsion systems.
Economic considerations and market uptake:
Investment costs for fuel-cell stacks and balance-of-plant components remain a key barrier to widespread adoption in residential and commercial markets.
Despite high efficiencies and low emissions, total cost of ownership (CAPEX and OPEX) must be favorable for broad deployment; ongoing R&D aims to reduce costs via manufacturing scale, materials, and system integration improvements.
Real-world submarine and vehicle applications:
Siemens and related research have developed stacks for submarines with high energy density and long duty cycles; stacks in such contexts demonstrate high reliability and fuel-flexible operation via reformate gas.
Hydrogen supply, storage, and energy density considerations
Hydrogen sources and storage challenges:
Green hydrogen (electrolysis powered by renewables) is ideal for clean energy but currently energy-intensive and cost-sensitive.
Reforming of hydrocarbons (natural gas, LPG, gasoline, diesel, biofuels) is a practical approach to hydrogen production but requires gas-cleaning and CO management.
Storage and volumetric energy density considerations:
Hydrogen storage options: compressed gas (CNG, typical 200–700 bar), liquid hydrogen, or solid-state stores (not covered in depth here).
Volumetric energy densities (typical order): liquids and hydrocarbons provide the highest volumetric energy densities; compressed/liquefied hydrogen provides lower densities per unit volume than hydrocarbons, complicating storage for mobile applications but not for stationary use.
Comparative energy densities (typical values given in the talk):
Gasoline (gasoline energy density by volume): around 31–32 MJ/L; Diesel ~35 MJ/L; Liquid fuels offer high energy density per volume.
Hydrogen (gas, compressed 700 bar): roughly 1.2–1.4 MJ/L (approximate, depending on pressure and temperature), much lower than hydrocarbon fuels, presenting storage challenges for mobile applications.
CNG (~200 bar): around 2.49 MWh/m^3; Liquid hydrogen ~2.4 MWh/m^3; Gasoline ~8.9 MWh/m^3; Diesel ~9.99 MWh/m^3; These figures illustrate the relative volumetric density differences.
Practical observations:
Conventional fuels (gasoline, diesel) offer compact, high-energy density storage; hydrogen requires bigger volume or higher pressure to meet similar energy payloads.
Energy carriers like methanol or other alcohols offer a compromise: can be reformatted to hydrogen with somewhat easier storage and handling characteristics, but lower energy density than pure hydrocarbons.
Implications for system design:
For mobile applications, the need for compact and lightweight storage drives ongoing research toward higher-pressure tanks, cryogenic storage, or on-site reforming to adapt to the energy density constraints of hydrogen.
For stationary applications, energy density is less critical than reliability, fuel sourcing, and heat integration; reforming-based hydrogen supply from natural gas can be a practical approach.
Cleanliness and hydrogen purity implications for different fuel-cell types
Relationship between operating temperature and gas purity requirements:
Lower temperatures (e.g., PEM at ~80°C) necessitate ultra-pure hydrogen with very low CO (< 10 ppm) to prevent catalyst poisoning and membrane degradation.
Higher-temperature systems (e.g., PAFC at ~200°C, MCFC, SOFC) can tolerate higher CO levels (e.g., PAFC up to ~1% CO in gas) but still benefit from reduced impurities.
Summary: as operation temperature drops, purity requirements tighten; gas-cleaning steps become more critical for PEM and other low-temperature cells.
Key practical metrics and constants highlighted in the talk
Faraday constant: F=96487extC/mol
Number of electrons transferred in the hydrogen oxidation reaction: n=2
Example catalytic and diffusion processes influenced by gas diffusion layers (GDL) and bipolar plates; the membrane acts as the primary electrolyte with porphyrin-like catalysts on both sides.
Typical single-cell voltage and performance data:
Open-circuit voltage around ~1.0 V per cell (not equal to ideal or thermoneutral values).
A typical single cell may deliver ~0.6–0.8 V under practical load, with power depending on current and active area.
Stacks (hundreds of cells) yield practical voltages in the tens to hundreds of volts and power in the kilowatt range.
Connections to broader themes and real-world relevance
Fuel cells offer a modular, scalable energy conversion platform suitable for a wide range of power needs—from micro-CHP in homes to large stationary power plants and mobile applications (vehicles, ships, submarines).
They provide potential for high efficiencies and low emissions, especially when hydrogen is produced from clean sources.
In stationary CHP, fuel cells can exceed the performance of conventional power plants in certain regimes due to superior part-load efficiency and heat recovery potential.
The barriers to widespread adoption include high capital costs, the need for robust hydrogen supply chains, and the development of durable, cost-effective materials and manufacturing processes.
Reforming-based hydrogen production remains a practical bridge technology for fleets and stationary systems that rely on existing fossil fuel infrastructure while transitioning toward cleaner energy carriers.
Quick recall prompts (for exam-style review)
Name the four main loss mechanisms in a fuel cell polarization curve and what they correspond to physically.
Write the thermodynamic expressions for U_th upper and lower, and E^0 upper and lower with the corresponding ΔH and ΔG values.
Derive the ideal efficiency for a fuel cell under upper heating value using E^0 and U_th, and compare with the lower heating value case.
What are the main reforming pathways to generate hydrogen from hydrocarbons, and how do their hydrogen contents compare?
What CO tolerance levels are typical for PEMFC and PAFC, and why does this matter for the reforming train?
Describe the seven-layer structure of a single PEM fuel cell and the role of GDLs, catalysts, and bipolar plates.
Explain why partial-load operation often yields higher efficiency in a fuel cell stack compared to a conventional internal combustion engine.
Compare volumetric energy densities of gasoline, diesel, propane LPG, CNG, liquid hydrogen, and compressed hydrogen at typical storage conditions.
Note on sources and context
The material reflects a university-level lecture on fuel cells, combining historical development, thermodynamics, electrochemistry, and system engineering aspects, with real-world examples from industry partners (Siemens, ZBT Duisburg) and aerospace/spaceflight heritage (NASA).
While data points are specific to the lecture, the general relationships (thermodynamic voltages, overpotentials, polarization curve regions, reforming chemistry, and system architecture) are representative of standard fuel-cell theory and practice.