Objective Versus Subjective Morality and Moral Relativism

Objective Versus Subjective Morality

Morality is objective if moral facts exist independently of human perspective, meaning moral claims hold true regardless of individual or cultural opinions in a manner analogous to mathematical truths like 2+2=42 + 2 = 4. Morality is subjective if moral facts do not exist, reducing moral claims to individual or cultural preferences, a view known as moral relativism. While moral relativism is commonly endorsed in popular culture within The United States, ethics experts and major ethical frameworks maintain that moral facts do exist and that morality is objective, reflecting the way people actually live their lives.

Arguments for Moral Subjectivism and Their Critiques

Proponents of moral subjectivism typically advance five arguments, each of which exhibits significant logical flaws. First, the appeal to tolerance claims that everyone's views can only be respected if morality is subjective; however, moral relativism undermines this goal because it reduces tolerance, fairness, and equality to mere preferences rather than binding duties. Second, the existence of widespread disagreement does not prove subjectivity, as differences in perspective do not negate objective facts, such as disputes regarding the shape of the earth or the correct sum of 6+66 + 6.

Third, the argument that objective morals would result in universal compliance ignores human motivation and fallibility, as humans routinely violate known truths, comparable to choosing to smoke despite knowing its health risks. Fourth, the claim that morality must be subjective because it is taught by humans confuses the source of knowledge with the reality being studied; mathematics is likewise taught by humans yet remains an objective fact that cannot be altered at will. Fifth, the assertion that objective morality lacks evidence is countered by positive arguments supporting moral realism.

Arguments for Moral Objectivism

Multiple lines of reasoning support the existence of objective moral facts. Across all known human cultures, people share common moral standards and experiences, including universal prohibitions, the fundamental concepts of right and wrong, and the experience of guilt, which inherently implies an obligation to follow moral standards. Furthermore, human beings consistently live as though morality is objective rather than subjective.

Objective moral facts are also logically necessary for moral accountability and evaluation. In the absence of objective standards, there is no coherent basis for holding individuals or cultures morally responsible for their actions. Finally, moral progress requires an objective framework; without objective truths to measure improvement against, societal moral reform becomes impossible, and the efforts of moral reformers would be entirely misguided.