9/11 Colonial American History: Puritanism, Middle Colonies, the Enlightenment, and the Great Awakening
Puritanism and the Massachusetts Bay Colony
Governor's Vision and "City Upon a Hill":
The governor of the Massachusetts Bay Colony declared that the Puritan settlement would be a "city upon a hill."
This concept originates from the Bible in Matthew 5:14: "You are the light of the world. A city set on a hill cannot be hidden."
Meaning of a City Upon a Hill:
Puritans saw themselves as a physical and moral example elevated above others.
They aimed to set a standard that the rest of the world would aspire to live up to.
Their primary intent was to establish a perfect Christian community.
Puritans vs. Separatists:
Puritans sought to purify the Church of England from within, rather than completely separate from it.
They believed that by creating a model society based on religious rules in America, they could eventually return to England and reform the Anglican Church.
Governance, Rights, and Legal System in Massachusetts Bay:
Voting and Office-Holding Rights: Limited strictly to adult male members of the Puritan Church. Unlike other models, holding land was insufficient to vote or hold public office.
Absence of Religious Tolerance: Religious tolerance was completely absent. While Separatists in Plymouth established a basic separation of church and state, the Massachusetts Bay Colony created a state that was strictly Puritan.
The Bible as a Legal Guide: When English common law provided no guidance for specific colonial situations, colonial authorities used the Bible as their legal text (e.g., applying principles such as "an eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth").
Ecclesiastical Hierarchy and Beliefs:
Rejection of Anglican Hierarchy: Puritans sought to emulate early Christians by eliminating the traditional hierarchy of the Anglican Church (priests, bishops, archbishops).
Congregationalism:
Replaced Anglican hierarchy with Congregationalism.
Definition: A system of church governance where ultimate power rests directly in the hands of the church members forming the congregation.
Calvinism and Predestination:
Strongly influenced by the theology of John Calvin.
Doctrine of Predestination: God has already determined who is among the "elect" (destined for heaven) and who is damned to hell.
Signs of Being Among the Elect:
Experiencing a distinct, physical conversion experience.
Receiving special attention and guidance from local ministers.
Founding of Harvard College:
Established to train new ministers and ensure an educated populace capable of running the colony.
Initial settlement path: Puritans settled first in Salem (located north of Plymouth) before expanding across Massachusetts Bay.
Establishment Timeline and Court Records:
Allocation of funds: £200 to be paid the following year, and £200 to be paid upon completion of the building, with the next court appointing the site and structure.
November 15, 1637: Official court order issued at Newtown regarding the construction.
March 13, 1638–'39: Court officially ordered that the college formally built at Cambridge be named Harvard College.
John Harvard:
An English colonist who died approximately one year after arriving in America.
Left his personal library and financial estate to the college in his will, leading the institution to be named in his honor.
Inscriptions and Architecture:
One of the gates surrounding Harvard Yard bears the historical inscription: "Enter to grow in wisdom."
Buildings on campus include Massachusetts Hall and Harvard Hall.
Dissent, New English Colonies, and Native American Conflicts
Roger Williams and the Founding of Rhode Island:
Theological Opposition: Roger Williams was a Christian minister who opposed making Congregationalism the state religion. He advocated for complete separation of church and state, mirroring the Separatist model in Plymouth.
Banishment (1636): After refusing multiple orders to cease agitating against colonial authorities, Williams was banished from the Massachusetts Bay Colony in 1636.
Establishment of Providence: Williams and his congregational followers purchased land directly from the Narragansett Native Americans.
Colonial Charter (1644): Parliament granted a charter establishing the Colony of Rhode Island and Providence Plantations.
Rhode Island originally referred specifically to Aquidneck Island.
Providence Plantation referred to the mainland agricultural settlement (the term "plantation" signified large farming areas, not slave plantations).
The official name was later simplified to Rhode Island.
Fair Land Transactions: Unlike other colonizers who seized native territory, Williams insisted on purchasing land directly from indigenous inhabitants.
Escalating Friction Between Settlers and Native Americans:
Settler population expansion forced Native Americans to adopt English economic practices, such as raising hogs and selling pork.
Economic Disputes: When natives sold pork below the rates set by New English settlers, colonists accused them of selling below market value.
Property Rights Disputes: Free-roaming English hogs frequently strayed into native fields and destroyed crops. When Native Americans shot the intruding livestock, settlers accused them of violating property rights.
King Philip's War (1675–1676):
Causes and Outbreak: Unable to resolve economic and territorial disputes, Metacom (known to the English as King Philip), chief of the Wampanoag, declared war against the English settlers in 1675.
Alliances:
Native Coalition: Led by Metacom, joined by the Narragansett and Nipmuc tribes.
English Coalition: Puritans and Separatists, joined by the Mohegan (Mohican) and Mohawk tribes.
Devastation and Statistics:
War lasted for one year.
English Losses: One-fifth () of all English towns in Massachusetts and Rhode Island were completely destroyed, and 1,000 English settlers were killed.
Native Losses: Metacom was killed by the native allies of the English. Between 4,500 and 5,500 Native Americans died due to battle and disease.
Aftermath:
Surviving members of the Nipmuc, Narragansett, and related tribes were forced to merge with Algonquin tribes for survival.
The conclusion of the conflict ushered in a prolonged period of peace between Native Americans and English settlers in New England.
The Middle Colonies: New Netherland and New York
Dutch Exploration and Henry Hudson:
The Dutch government hired English explorer Henry Hudson to find the Northeast Passage to The Indies (a northern passage sailing past Russia through the Arctic to China and Japan).
Trapped by Arctic ice in his wooden vessel, Hudson disobeyed orders to return to The Netherlands and sailed west across the Atlantic Ocean.
Hudson claimed the region around present-day New York for the Dutch, naming it New Netherland.
Dutch Settlement and Demographics:
Fort Orange: Established by Dutch merchants as a trading post to acquire furs from Native Americans.
New Amsterdam: Established by the Dutch government on Manhattan Island as the permanent capital of New Netherland.
Cultural Artifacts: The modern flag of New York City retains the blue, white, and orange colors of the Dutch Prince's Flag, displays the year 1625, and features a windmill.
Demographic Challenges:
The Netherlands had a total population of only 1,500,000 people and lacked sufficient manpower to sustain both the home country and the overseas colony.
To build a self-sufficient community of farmers and artisans, the Dutch opened New Amsterdam to non-Dutch settlers from across Europe and other American colonies.
By 1644, New Amsterdam had 5,000 residents, but only half were ethnically Dutch.
Dutch Legacy in Present-Day New York:
Wall Street: Named after the wooden defensive wall constructed by the Dutch to protect their settlement.
Harlem: Named after the Dutch city of Haarlem (originally spelled with two as).
Stuyvesant Town: Named after Peter Stuyvesant, the final Dutch colonial governor (who had a wooden peg leg lost in a Caribbean military campaign).
Dutch Linguistic Contributions:
Stoop (derived from Dutch stuy / stoep)
Creek
Bower (derived from Dutch bouwer, meaning farmer or farm)
Cookie
Waffle
Coleslaw
Boss
Pennsylvania, Quakerism, and Intellectual Movements
The Society of Friends (Quakers):
Founded in England by George Fox and Margaret Fell.
Theological Principles:
Rejected the Calvinist doctrine of predestination.
Believed that every human being possesses an Inner Light that provides direct spiritual guidance and an understanding of right from wrong.
Espoused gender equality: Women were permitted to preach in church services.
During services, men and women sat on separate sides of the meetinghouse to maintain decorum and protect women.
William Penn and Pennsylvania:
Frame of Government: Written by William Penn as the legal foundation for Pennsylvania.
Key Guarantees:
Absolute freedom of religion for all residents.
Voting rights and office-holding rights granted to all property-owning men, without religious qualification.
Rapid Population Growth: Penn distributed promotional pamphlets across England, attracting massive numbers of immigrants.
Boundary Adjustments: Colonial borders shifted over time; for example, land north of a dotted boundary originally belonging to Pennsylvania became part of New York in 1788.
The Enlightenment (1720s–1760s):
An intellectual movement emphasizing human reason and natural laws over strict reliance on religious dogma.
Sir Isaac Newton: Applied mathematics and physics to prove heliocentrism (that the Earth revolves around the Sun). Developed calculus while isolated from Cambridge during a plague outbreak.
John Locke: Political philosopher who authored An Essay Concerning Human Understanding. Argued that human character is shaped by environment, experience, and education rather than innate nature.
Benjamin Franklin and Deism:
Raised as a Puritan, Franklin adopted Deism.
Deist Principles: Belief in a Supreme Creator who created the universe and set natural laws in motion, then stepped back without intervening daily in human affairs (known as the "Clockmaker Theory").
Deists rejected the divinity of Jesus Christ and the absolute authority of the Bible, relying instead on natural reason.
Inventions and Scientific Work: Invented bifocal glasses, the Franklin stove (improving draft efficiency and smoke removal), and the lightning rod. Conducted electricity experiments involving a kite with a wire during a storm (his son held the string and was shocked; his son later became a Loyalist during the American Revolution).
The Great Awakening and Colonial Higher Education
The Great Awakening (1720s–1760s):
A major religious movement characterized by intense, emotional revivals across the North American colonies.
Jonathan Edwards:
Congregational minister in Massachusetts who sought to restore the declining religious fervor of the founding Puritan generation.
Delivered the famous sermon "Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God".
Sermon Imagery and Core Themes:
God holds sinners over the pit of hell like a person holds a spider or loathsome insect over a fire.
God's wrath burns like fire; sinners are 10,000 times more abominable in His sight than a venomous serpent.
Only God's arbitrary grace prevents sinners from dropping into hell at any given moment.
References Proverbs 20:2 ("The fear of a king is as the roaring of a lion…"), contrasting earthly kings (mere worms of the dust) with the Almighty Creator.
Sinners hang over the furnace of divine wrath by a single slender thread that is constantly scorched by flames.
George Whitefield and the New Light Movement:
George Whitefield: An English itinerant preacher who expanded local revivals into an inter-colonial movement traveling from Massachusetts to Georgia.
Preaching Style: Memorized all sermons completely, using dramatic vocal inflections and physical hand gestures to captivate audiences.
New Lights vs. Old Lights:
New Lights: Converts who experienced intense physical and emotional responses during Whitefield's sermons (weeping, falling to their knees, speaking in tongues), interpreting these phenomena as an awakening of their "inner light."
Old Lights: Traditional ministers who condemned Whitefield and the revivals as fakery. They argued that emotional conversions undermined established ministerial authority.
Old Light churches barred New Light preachers from using their pulpits.
Benjamin Franklin's Support: Although Franklin remained a Deist, he admired Whitefield's powerful oratorical skills and ability to command massive crowds.
Institutional Legacy and Schisms:
Denominational Splits:
New Light Congregationalists broke away from traditional churches to form new congregations or joined the small Baptist denomination.
The Dutch Reformed Church in New York and New Jersey split when New Lights rejected the authority of the governing Classis in Amsterdam, asserting that European authorities did not understand colonial conditions.
Founding of Colonial Colleges:
The debate over whether ministers required formal theological education triggered the rapid establishment of higher education institutions:
Harvard College (1636): Established by Puritans to train ministers and colonial leaders.
College of William & Mary: Established by Anglicans, named after King William and Queen Mary.
Yale University: Founded by strict Puritans who believed Harvard had strayed from its original Puritan rigor.
College of New Jersey (Princeton University): Founded by New Light Presbyterians following the Great Awakening to educate ministers.
College of Philadelphia (University of Pennsylvania): Proposed by Benjamin Franklin as a secular, non-sectarian institution free from religious affiliation.
King's College (Columbia University): Founded in New York City by Anglicans to balance competing denominational schools.
Baptist College (Brown University): Founded by Baptists to provide higher education for Baptist youth without non-denomination influence.