Human Molecular Genetics: Evolutionary Insights from Comparative Genomics

Course and Contact Information

  • Course: CELS191 Cell & Molecular Biology (Te Mātau Koiora o te Pūtau me te Rapoi Kota).
  • Lecturer: Professor Peter Dearden, Te Tari Matū Koiora | Department of Biochemistry.
  • Research Interests: Evolution, Development, and Genome Evolution.
  • Lecture Subject: Lecture 23: Human Molecular Genetics – What Does the Genome Tell Us About Being Human?
  • Copyright Notice: Content is subject to copyright and intended for private study or research at the University only. Further distribution or copying, with or without charge, is prohibited.

Lecture Objectives

  • Outline the information gained from genomes through comparative genomics.
  • Explain how comparing genomes facilitates the understanding of human biology.
  • Describe how comparing genomes with relatives provides insights into human origins and environmental adaptation.

Introduction to Comparative Genomics

  • Definition and Purpose: Comparative genomics involves discovering similarities and differences between genomes.
  • Conserved Sequences: Features shared between species are termed "conserved." These sequences often encode biology that remains consistent across different species.
  • Organism-Specific Biology: Aspects of the genome that differ between species may encode biology unique to that specific organism.
  • Function Identification: Comparing genomes serves as a tool to determine which segments of the genome perform specific biological functions.
  • The Process of Aligning: Genomes are compared by "aligning" sequences. This involves lining them up side-by-side and marking every point where the sequences are identical.
    • Example Alignment:
      • Species 1: ACGAGTTACACCAGTGTCTGTAGTCTAGCAAACTGA
      • Species 2: ACGTGTTTGATTAGTGTATCTAGTCTAGAAAACT

Comparing Genomes Within Species

  • Identification of Differences: By comparing genomes within a single species (e.g., between human individuals), researchers identify specific points of variation.
  • Associations of Differences: These variations can be linked to:
    • Disease susceptibility and pathology.
    • Specific individual characteristics (phenotypes).
    • Evolutionary history.
  • Human Genomic Landscape: Mapping and sequencing of human genomes are increasing rapidly. The current cost to sequence a human genome is approximately US$600US\$600.

Comparing Genomes Between Species

  • Inter-species Insights: Comparing across different species reveals:
    • The types of genes an organism possesses.
    • The mechanisms of how differences between species arise.
    • The evolutionary relationships between different life forms.
  • The Challenge of Defining "Human": Scientists attempt to use the human genome to identify DNA segments encoding specific "human" traits, such as tool use or language.
  • Inherent Difficulties:
    • The sheer number of differences between species.
    • The fact that humans share many genes with other animals.
    • The lack of understanding regarding the function of most genes.

Genomes of Close Living Relatives

  • The Chimpanzee Genome (20052005):
    • Humans and Chimpanzees share essentially all of their genes.
    • Differences include approximately 35×10635 \times 10^6 (thirty-five million) single-nucleotide changes.
    • Approximately 5×1065 \times 10^6 (five million) insertion/deletion (indel) events.
    • Presence of various gene duplications differentiating the two species.
  • The Gorilla Genome (20122012):
    • Gorillas are missing a few genes present in humans.
    • Current detection suggests Gorillas have no genes that humans do rely on (they do not possess genes that we lack).

Methodology and Challenges of Ancient DNA (aDNA)

  • Extinct Species Mapping: Genomic comparison is used to determine relationships for extinct animals, such as mammoths and moa.
  • Biological Limitations of aDNA:
    • Dead DNA degrades over time.
    • Sequence changes can occur post-mortem.
    • The average size of aDNA fragments is typically less than 200 bp200\,bp.
    • Chemical modifications are common.
    • Extracts are often dominated by DNA from microbial organisms that colonized the specimen after death.
  • Contamination Risks: Ancient DNA is highly susceptible to contamination with modern DNA.
  • Pioneering Research: Svante Pääbo (Nobel Prize 20222022) was the first to extract DNA from an ancient specimen (40004000-year-old Egyptian mummy) and pioneered the field.
  • Technical Advances: High-throughput DNA sequencing now allows for large-scale, genome-wide sequencing of random fragments extracted from ancient remains, moving beyond the limitations of Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCRPCR).

The Neanderthal Genome

  • Profile: The Neanderthal is considered the closest relative to modern humans, living in Europe and Asia roughly 130,000–30,000130{,}000 \text{--} 30{,}000 years ago.
  • Cultural Evidence: U-Th dating of carbonate crusts suggests Neanderthals created cave art (paintings and engravings) in Europe more than 64,00064{,}000 years ago.
  • The Draft Sequence (20102010, Green et al.):
    • The draft was composed of more than 4×1094 \times 10^9 (four billion) nucleotides from three individuals.
    • Modern contamination was identified and discounted.
    • Key genes identified for comparison:
      • MC1RMC1R (skin pigmentation).
      • FOXP2FOXP2 (speech and language).
      • ABOABO blood group locus.
      • Taste receptor genes.
  • Major Finding – Interbreeding: Modern humans in Europe and Asia carry Neanderthal alleles; modern humans from Africa do not. This suggests that interbreeding occurred where modern humans met Neanderthals.
  • Genetic Contribution: Non-Africans have approximately 2-4%2\text{-}4\% of their genome composed of variants that arose in Neanderthals.

The Denisovan Discovery and Hybridization

  • Discovery at Denisova Cave: A finger bone found in the Denisova cave contained mitochondrial DNA that did not match either modern humans or Neanderthals.
  • Genomic Sequence (20102010): The genome of this archaic human species was sequenced from a tooth found in the same cave.
  • Melanesian Connection: Denisovan variants comprise approximately 4-6%4\text{-}6\% of the genomes of present-day Melanesians.
  • Hybridization Evidence (20182018): The genome of an individual ("Denisova 11") was found to be a first-generation hybrid—offspring of a Neanderthal mother and a Denisovan father.

Functional Implications of Archaic Variants

  • Tibetan High-Altitude Adaptation: Tibetans have genetic adaptations for living at high altitudes (hypoxia response).
  • The EPAS1 Gene: Sequencing identifies the EPAS1 gene as a region of recent selection in Tibetans. This specific version of the gene (haplotype) is absent in most other human populations, such as Han Chinese (CHBCHB), British (GBRGBR), or Japanese (JPTJPT).
  • The "Gift" of the Denisovans: The EPAS1 variant in Tibetans matches the sequence found in the Denisovan genome. This adaptation to high altitude was transferred to our species through hybridization with Denisovans.

Summary of Findings

  • Genomics and comparative technology allow us to understand human origins and identity.
  • Large-scale statistical analysis of whole genomes reveals where our characteristics come from.
  • Comparison within species identifies phenotypic variants; comparison between species identifies unique organism biology.
  • Our evolutionary history is complex, characterized by hybridization with extinct relatives.
  • Extinct relatives are not merely fossils; their variants live on in modern human genomes and continue to affect our biology.