International Peace and Security

International Peace and Security

Learning Outcomes

  • Understand the concepts of collective security and human security.

  • Examine different multilateral organizations involved in collective security.

  • Identify the organizational structure, leadership, and functions of these organizations.

From International to Human Security

UN System Involvement

  • The UN system addresses a wide range of international political issues.

  • The core of a multilateralist world is the system of collective security:

    • All participant states forswear the use of force in disputes.

    • Collective action is agreed upon against states that use force.

Collective Security vs. Traditional Security Alliances

  • Collective Security: Inclusive system comprising all nations.

  • Traditional Alliances: Exclusive, often preserving state-centric notions focused primarily on national borders.

  • Current trends indicate a shift towards prioritizing human security over state security, introducing a responsibility to protect vulnerable populations.

Security Council and Collective Security

The Purposes of the United Nations are:

1. To maintain international peace and security, and to that end:

2. To take effective collective measures for the prevention and removal of threats to the peace, and for

3.The suppression of acts of aggression and other breaches of the peace.”

UN Charter and Security Council

  • The UN Charter's preamble emphasizes preventing war for future generations.

  • Key Purposes of the UN include:

    • Maintaining international peace and security.

    • Implementing effective collective measures against threats and acts of aggression.

Mechanisms for Peace and Security

  • Chapter VI: Pacific Settlement of Disputes

    • Security Council can intervene in disputes threatening international peace.

    • Rights to investigate, arbitrate, and recommend solutions.

  • Chapter VII: Action on Threats and Breaches of Peace

    • Security Council defines threats and determines responses.

    • Responses range from diplomatic measures to military action.

The Structure of the Security Council

  • Permanent Members (P5): United States, China, France, Russia, United Kingdom.

    • Each has veto power over Security Council resolutions.

  • Elected Members: Ten members serve non-consecutive two-year terms without veto power.

  • The P5's privileges date back to the post-World War II order shaped by victors.

Veto Power of the P5

  • Frequency of Veto Usage:

    • Russia has used its veto 158 times.

    • The United States used its veto 92 times, notably defending Israeli interests.

    • China has increasingly used its veto (21 times), often aligned with Russia.

    • France and the UK have not exercised veto power since 1989.

Presidency of the Security Council

  • The presidency rotates monthly among non-permanent members of the Council.

  • Eligibility Criteria:

    • Significant contributions to international peace maintenance, including financial or troop contributions.

  • Geographical Representation:

    • Regional groups established to ensure equitable representation:

      • African Group: 3 seats

      • Asia-Pacific Group: 2 seats

      • Eastern European Group: 1 seat

      • Latin American and Caribbean Group: 2 seats

      • Western Europe and Others Group: 2 seats

    • Informal agreements manage additional regional seat distributions.

Philippines as a Non-Permanent Member

  • Term: 2004-2005.

  • Focus Areas:

    • Strengthening collective security as per UN Charter.

    • Upholding the rule of law in maintaining peace and security.

    • Fostering multilateral consensus for UN’s peace and security responsibilities.

UN SC Subsidiary Organs

  • Support Functions:

    • Ad hoc committees on sanctions and counterterrorism.

    • International criminal tribunals (Rwanda, Yugoslavia).

    • The Department of Peacekeeping Operations and Department of Operational Support manage operations.

  • Peacebuilding Commission (2005): Advises on best practices for peacebuilding.

Sanctions Regimes Established by the Security Council

  • History of Sanctions: 31 regimes established since 1966. (Southern Rhodesia, South Africa, the Former Yugoslavia (2), Haiti (2), Angola, Liberia (3), Eritrea/Ethiopia, Rwanda, Sierra Leone, Côte d’Ivoire, Iran, Somalia/Eritrea, ISIL (Da’esh) and Al-Qaida, Iraq (2), Democratic Republic of the Congo, Sudan, Lebanon, Democratic People’s Republic of Korea, Libya (2), the Taliban, Guinea-Bissau, Central African Republic, Yemen, South Sudan and Mali.)

Types of Sanctions

  • Vary from comprehensive economic sanctions to targeted measures (arms embargoes, travel bans).

  • Goals include promoting peaceful transitions, deterring constitutional changes, and supporting human rights.

Effectiveness of Sanctions

  • Sanctions most effective as part of comprehensive strategies including peacekeeping and peacebuilding.

  • Many sanctions intended to support governments toward peaceful transitions.

Current Sanctions Regimes and Management

  • 14 ongoing regimes focusing on political settlements and counter-terrorism initiatives.

  • Each regime overseen by a sanctions committee; supported by monitoring groups.

Tools for Conflict Management of the UNSC

  • Chapter VII Powers:

    • Authorizes sanctions or military force to maintain peace.

  • Peacekeeping Missions:

    • As of 2024, 11 operations across 3 continents.

    • Post-2014, limited peacekeeping due to geopolitical tensions.

Peacekeeping Operations Historical Context

  • 48 peacekeeping operations authorized since the Soviet Union's dissolution, focusing on complex emergencies and conflict zones.

  • Personnel Contributions:

    • Predominantly from developing nations in South Asia.

Regional Organizations in Peacekeeping

  • Role of Regional Organizations:

    • Increasingly important in peacekeeping, often collaborating or acting on behalf of the Security Council.

    • Example: NATO’s involvement in Libya following an Arab League request.

Authorization of Military Force

  • Under UN Charter, military force is generally allowed only in self-defense or with Security Council authorization.

Examples of Controversial Interventions

  • NATO air war in Kosovo viewed as illegitimate yet necessary intervention to protect civilians from ethnic cleansing.

  • R2P Doctrine (2005): Justified potential military actions outside Security Council authorization to protect populations from crimes against humanity.