MOD 23:

GOV 312L: US Foreign Policy

Course Instructors
  • Rob Moser

  • Pat McDonald

  • Department of Government, The University of Texas at Austin

Outline
  • Types of International Migration and Their Global Patterns

  • Politics Surrounding Migration Policy

  • Migration and Globalization

  • Migration and National Identity

  • Migration and National Security

Types of International Migration
  • Definition: International migration involves individuals moving across national borders, categorized primarily into two forms:

    • Voluntary Migration

    • Legal Migration: Movement of individuals who follow legal processes to settle in another country.

    • Illegal or Undocumented Migration: Movement of individuals without following the legal immigration processes.

    • Forced Migration: Movement due to coercion or threats, which includes:

    • Refugees: Individuals forced to flee their home country due to persecution, war, or violence.

    • Human Trafficking: Involves the illegal transportation of individuals, often for forced labor or sexual exploitation.

  • Growth Statistics:

    • Since 2000, the number of international migrants has dramatically increased by nearly 50%, rising from 173 million to 258 million.

Global Patterns of International Migration
  • Trends: Predominantly, international migration exhibits a net flow of individuals from less developed (developing) countries to more developed countries.

    • Top Receiving Countries:

    • United States

    • Saudi Arabia

    • Germany

    • Top Sending Countries:

    • India

    • Mexico

    • Russia

    • China

  • Refugees: A notable exception is the refugee crisis; developing countries, such as Turkey, carry the majority of the refugee burden.

  • Cumulative Stock Comparison:

    • While the U.S. has the largest cumulative stock of migrants by absolute numbers, migrants constitute a higher percentage of the total population in countries such as the United Arab Emirates, Saudi Arabia, Australia, and Canada.

Politics Surrounding Migration Policy
  • Public Opinion vs. Policy: There exists a gap between public sentiments regarding immigration and the actual immigration policies enacted in democracies.

  • Collective Action Problem:

    • This phenomenon occurs when certain powerful interests reap concentrated benefits from immigration (such as businesses) while the costs are distributed among less organized groups, complicating policy reform efforts.

Migration and Globalization
  • Interrelation: International migration is an integral part of globalization, similar to the movement of goods and services through international trade.

    • The flow of labor across national borders boosts economic growth for countries at an aggregate level.

  • Economic Impact:

    • Migration leads to income distribution effects, producing economic winners and losers:

    • High-Skill Labor: Sectors like technology prefer high-skill migrants to optimize operational costs.

    • Low-Skill Labor: Industries like agriculture, construction, and services aim to exploit low-skill foreign labor to reduce expenses.

  • Price Effects: Lower labor costs facilitate lower prices for consumers and can stimulate economic growth.

  • Economic Downsides:

    • While immigration boosts demand and economic growth, it raises the labor supply in certain sectors, potentially driving down real wages for local workers.

Remittances: Financial Transfers
  • Definition: Remittances are monetary transfers sent by migrants to their family and friends remaining in their home countries.

  • Financial Statistics:

    • Total remittances exceeded $600 million in 2017, having increased more than fivefold since 2000.

  • Comparison with Foreign Aid:

    • Remittances outstrip foreign aid, which amounts to less than $200 million, establishing a greater redistribution of wealth from wealthier to poorer nations.

  • Advantages of Remittances:

    • Unlike foreign aid or foreign direct investment, remittances have unique qualities:

    • They are typically familial transfers and cannot be withdrawn or revoked.

    • They bypass government bureaucracies, thus diminishing corruption risk.

    • They provide targeted financial support, offering a form of social insurance, credit, and investment in regions lacking those services.

Immigration and National Identity
  • Demographic Shift: Immigration contributes to significant demographic changes in the U.S. and other major recipient countries.

    • This phenomenon intensifies racial tensions and conflicts.

  • Cultural Debates in the U.S.:

    • The discourse frequently focuses on the debate over designating English as the primary language, along with the roots of national identity in Anglo-Protestant culture.

  • European Concerns:

    • In Europe, apprehensions often revolve around Muslim immigration and integration, reflected in public sentiment emphasizing the importance of knowing the national language and the identification with Christianity as essential to national identity.

Immigration and National Security
  • Security Concerns: Immigration raises national security fears, particularly about potential terrorist infiltration.

  • Regulatory Response: This concern leads to increased calls for stricter border regulations, especially concerning refugees and migrants from war-torn regions.

  • European Context:

    • These fears are more pronounced in European countries that are directly affected by the migrant crisis originating from the Syrian civil war and the overall instability in the Middle East.