Confirmation Bias and Lineups

Confirmation Bias and Lineups

Lineups: Photo Arrays

  • Generally, lineups consist of photo arrays, not live lineups as frequently depicted in television dramas.
  • The primary purpose of a police lineup is for an eyewitness to a crime to identify whether the presented suspect was involved in the crime.

Purpose of Using a Lineup

  • The purpose of a lineup is to create a control group scenario. It involves presenting multiple individuals (e.g., six people) to the victim or witness, with the hope that the witness identifies the actual suspect.
  • The intention is to make the identification process challenging enough to ensure accuracy.
  • If a lineup only shows one person, the witness might be more inclined to say yes simply because that individual stands out, regardless of their actual involvement in the crime.

Single-Blind Lineups

  • Typical police lineups are "single-blind," meaning the police know who the suspect is.
  • To ensure fairness, it's recommended that the police official instructing the lineup is also blind to the suspect's identity.

Fillers

  • Fillers are known innocent individuals included in the lineup alongside the suspect.
  • It is crucial that these fillers are confirmed to be innocent and are not other potential suspects.
  • Including multiple suspects in a single lineup is inappropriate.

Ensuring a Fair Lineup

  • The suspect should not stand out in any way from the fillers.
  • If the lineup is not fair, any identification made by the witness may be deemed unreliable in court.

Example of a Real Case

  • In an actual case the presenter worked on, the description of the suspect was:
    • Hispanic male wearing a black jacket
  • The presenter shows an image of the lineup used by the police, challenging the audience to identify the suspect.