Methods and Sources for Studying Ancient Medicine
Temporal and Geographical Scope
- Focus Area: The study primarily focuses on "Classical" Greece and Rome.
- Time Span: The period covers approximately the 8th century BC (700s BC) to the 5th or 6th century AD (500s AD).
- Terminology: "Classical" is a broad term used to categorize these civilizations.
- Survival of Material: There has been a catastrophic loss of literary material from the classical world.
- Rate of Survival: Less than 1% of literary material from the classical world has survived to the modern day.
- Causes of Loss: Material was lost due to the passage of time, natural disasters, and war.
Historical Periods
- Bronze Age / Dark Age: Prior to the 8th century BC.
- Archaic Period: 8th–6th century BC.
- Classical / Attic Period: 5th–4th century BC.
- Hellenistic Period: 3rd–2nd/1st century BC.
- Roman Period: 1st century BC–2nd century AD.
- Patristic / Byzantine / Late Antique: 3rd century–5th century AD.
- Medieval Period: 6th century–15th century AD.
- Early Medieval: 6th–10th century.
- High Medieval: 11th–13th century.
- Late Medieval: 14th–15th century AD (noting the year 1400 as the death of Chaucer).
- Early Modern Period: 15th century–18th century AD.
Challenges in Ancient Sources
- Bias: Sources often contain inherent biases of the author or the time.
- Oral Traditions: Much medical knowledge was communicated orally rather than written down.
- Literacy Rates: The literacy of the common person is a major limiting factor in what was recorded.
- Craft vs. Written: There is a distinction between craft knowledge (practical skills) and written knowledge (academic theory).
- Folk Knowledge: Medicine often overlapped with folk knowledge, which was rarely recorded formally.
- Survivor Bias via Mockery: Some medical knowledge only survives because it was being mocked or criticized by other practitioners. Examples include:
- Trepanation.
- Dream interpretation.
- Ancient exorcisms.
- Religious rites.
- Literary vs. Academic Sources: Certain medical details survive only because they were discussed in a ‘literary’ context rather than an ‘academic’ one.
- Example: "Healing drugs" or calming drinks distributed in Sparta.
- Economic Barriers: Books were expensive and relatively rare; there was a general lack of libraries and formal institutions to preserve scripts.
Available Evidence and Methodologies
- Written Records:
- Case studies and medical reports.
- Educational treatises, both medical and non-medical (Example: any Latin medical text written prior to 350 CE).
- References to medical practices found in literary texts and "encyclopedic" works.
- Papyri (e.g., Herculaneum papyri, Greek Magic Papyri).
- Archaeological and Physical Evidence:
- Votive offerings (often depicting body parts).
- Medical instruments found at archaeological sites.
- Epigraphic evidence: Writings found on walls or stones, including graffiti and murals.
- Scientific analysis: Modern analysis of ancient medical vessels and human remains (bodies).
Reliability and Interpretation Issues
- Fragmentary Record: Archaeological and written records are often incomplete or misleading.
- Directional Biases:
- Physician to physician writing (professional jargon or elitism).
- Physician to patient writing (normativity and expectations of behavior).
- Modern Misinterpretations: Difficulty in identifying specific weights, measures, and species of flora (plants) and fauna (animals) mentioned in texts.
- Retrospective Diagnosis: The danger of trying to apply modern medical diagnoses to ancient descriptions of symptoms.
- Cultural Background: Many practices are obscured by unknown cultural contexts or the mixing of myth, religion, and legend with practice.
- Market Trends: Survivor bias is influenced by what people actually bought. For instance, in the Middle Ages, many monasteries prioritized religious texts over medical ones.
- Supersession: Some important works were replaced by later, "better" ones. Specifically, many older Greek texts were lost because they were superseded by the works of Galen.
Case Study: Celsus on Liver Pain
- Source: Celsus on Medicine 5.3
- Latin Text: Si iecur dolet, id in quo est balsami lacrimae P. XII ; costi, cinnamomi, casiae corticis, murrae, croci, iunci rotundi, balsami seminis, iridis Illyricae, cardamomi, amomi, nardi, singulorum P. XVI. Quibus adicitur nardum [unguentum], donec cerati crassitudo sit. Et huius quidem recentis usus est: si vero servandum est, resinae terebenthinae P. XVI, cerae P. X ex vino leni contunduntur, tum eo miscentur.
- Translation: "If there is pain in the liver apply the emollient which consists of balsam tears 48grms., costmary, cinnamon, casia bark, myrrh, saffron, round rush, balsam seeds, Illyrian iris, cardamon, amomum, nard, each 64grms.. To these is added nard ointment until the consistency is that of a cerate. And this is for use whilst fresh; but if it is to be kept, turpentine resin 64grms., and wax 40grms., are pounded up together in mild wine, and then mixed with the above."
Ancient Weights, Measures, and Symbols
- P∗: Followed by a numeral, represents one denarius or more (also represented by H or X followed by a numeral).
- − or P∗∼: Uncia denarii, 121 of a denarius.
- PS: Semi-denarius, 21 of a denarius.
- P or P∗ZZ: Triens denarii, 31.
- Pl∗=−: Quadrans denarii, 41.
- P∗=: Sextans denarii, 61 (one obolus).
- P−: Quicunx denarii, 125.
- P=: Bes denarii, 32.
- P∗ or PZ: Semis denarii, 21.
- PE: Dextans denarii, 1210 (this sign reportedly only occurs in V. 18. 17).
- >: Followed by a numeral, represents one scripulum or more.
- S: Followed by a numeral, represents one sextarius or more.
- S (no numeral): Means "semi," or one half.
Transmission of Knowledge
- Hand Copying vs. Printing: Before 1450 (the start of printing in Europe), all books were hand-copied, leading to errors and losses. Post-1450, virtually nothing has been "lost."
- Arabic Translations: Significant Greek medical knowledge survived only through Arabic translations.
- Hunain ibn Isaq: Provided the only surviving copy of Galen’s On Demonstration (the original Greek version is entirely lost).
- Sources of the Patient's View: To understand the patient’s perspective, we look at non-medical sources, such as descriptions of doctors and illness in general literature.
Critical Cautions
- Non-Monolithic: Ancient medicine is not a single, unified system; it changed significantly over more than 1000 years.
- Diversity: It is not limited to just Greek and Roman influences.
- Definitions: A central question in the field remains: "What is Medicine?" — the definition itself varies across time and culture.
Questions & Discussion
- Approaching the History of Medicine: How should we study this field?
- Motivations: What are the reasons for studying Ancient Medicine today?
- Cultural Context: What are our own cultural practices that inform contemporary medical approaches?
- Perspective: What kinds of sources give us different perspectives on Ancient Medicine?